Just International

A Resounding Defeat For Trump

By Michael K Smith

Backpedaling like a whirling dervish, TACO* Trump claims that yesterday’s crushing electoral defeat has nothing to do with him as he wasn’t even on the ballot, which ignores the fact that throughout the mid-term campaign he harangued his followers to vote as though he were on the ballot.

Voters appear to have taken him at his word, handing control of the entire Congress to a far from popular Democratic Party, as well as the state governorships that were in play. The most eye-catching result may be that Democratic candidates won not only in so-called purple states, a customary kind of shift in mid-term elections, but also in states that until yesterday were considered permanent Republican strongholds, like South Carolina and Kansas. The last time Kansas had a Democratic Senator was 1939.

Just as significant as the magnitude of yesterday’s rejection is the responsibility for it, which falls squarely on Trump. He strove to make the elections about his persona, even when polls indicated his average popularity had dipped under 37%, an all-time low. At the beginning of the year nobody was saying that the deeply-disliked Democrats had any prospects for taking control of both houses of Congress. As late as May, 59% of U.S. adults had an unfavorable opinion of the party.

Four prominent factors largely account for yesterday’s results. One, Trump’s intervention in the GOP’s internal processes of candidate selection, in many cases choosing inexperienced and corrupt acolytes with divisive profiles over more vetted party favorites. Two, and also three, as the factors overlap, was the unprovoked attack on Iran, which Trump himself said would be a particularly stupid target for a regime-change war, a policy he claimed to have rejected no matter where it might be proposed, on the basis of the disastrous outcome of the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq. In short, his Iran attack went directly against his own advice against “forever wars,” while also unleashing a ferocious wave of inflation on American workers, a large majority of whom live precariously from paycheck-to-paycheck to begin with. This third factor erased the 2024 voter perception that Trump would be the better bet to manage the economy well. Add to this Trump’s comments that he gave no thought to the impact on American wallets of plunging the Middle East into prolonged war, and his retrospective justification that no one should resent soaring gas prices because the oil companies were making “a freaking fortune,” and one should have no difficulty seeing that Trump was practically begging for a voter backlash.

Finally, Trump’s vicious and indiscriminate witch-hunt against immigrants, regardless of their legal status, expelled the Latino vote from the Trump coalition, a crucial part of his previous victories as well as any continuing hopes for Republican governing majorities. The best illustration of this change in voting preferences was seen in Texas, where James Talarico (Senate) and Gina Hinojosa (Governor) crushed their conservative opponents by margins nobody foresaw. In Florida, the far-right came very close to losing its stronghold in the face of liberal challengers.

Having said all this, it remains clear that yesterday’s vote does not represent a blank check for the Democratic Party, but rather a thunderous rejection of Trump himself, his arrogance, his perverse priorities, and his extreme policies. Very noteworthy in this rejection was the highly competitive performance of democratic socialist candidates, most of them young and from ethnic minorities typically marginalized or stigmatized. They fearlessly confronted the open contempt the Republican party holds for them, as well as the craven submission of corporate Democrats to cowardly and hypocritical compromises. They and millions of their fellow-Americans didn’t allow themselves to be manipulated by the lies and distortions of Republican candidates awash in billionaire cash.

Having said that, however, California’s Proposition 40, a modest tax on billionaires, appears to be going down to defeat on the pretext that billionaires might move out of state in response, as though their assets wouldn’t be taxed nonetheless.

As the final electoral results continue streaming in, the great question now hovering over the United States and the world is how the Republican Party will react to restrictions on its power, until now allowed to lurch from one disaster to the next without restraint.

In typical Trumpian style, the early signals have been contradictory: to the New York Times Trump said he was disposed to accept the results, and that he would probably make an agreement with the Democrats. On the other hand, before the polls closed he had assured CBS News the presidential veto gave him “the ultimate power,” while the Supreme Court had granted him “tremendous powers” over federal agencies without regard to who controls Congress.

With Democratic Party leadership in the hands of the likes of Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer it would be foolish to expect an abrupt shift into rational policy. On the other hand, they will be under strong pressure to appease a rising social democratic party base intoxicated with the exotic notion that democracy means representative power.

One can only hope that this means Democratic Party cowardice has a limit, which would be very good news, as Trump’s appetite for despotic authority clearly doesn’t.

*Trump Always Chickens Out

5 November 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

Trump Went to Iran for Regime Change. Iran Delivered It in Washington.

By Junaid S. Ahmad

Donald Trump went to war against Iran to demonstrate the invincibility of American empire. Eight months later, Iran has helped deliver one of the most devastating strategic defeats in the history of American imperial power. The battlefield was in Iran. The political earthquake struck Washington.

Trump wanted regime change in Tehran. American voters delivered it in Congress.

The November midterm elections have demolished Republican control of both the House and Senate. But this is more than an electoral humiliation. It is a historic indictment of the imperial arrogance, Israeli-driven militarism, and political establishment that dragged America into another catastrophic Middle Eastern war.

The implications are staggering: Iran survived the American-Israeli assault. Trump’s congressional majority did not.

On February 28, Washington and Israel unleashed overwhelming military force, assassinating Iran’s supreme leader, devastating infrastructure, and inflicting enormous human suffering. They possessed the aircraft, missiles, intelligence systems, and technological superiority. They could kill leaders, destroy installations, and terrorize cities.

What they could not do was compel Iran to surrender.

That failure is the heart of their strategic catastrophe.

Iran demonstrated that defeating an empire does not require defeating its armies. It requires denying the empire its political objectives while making aggression unbearably costly. Tehran survived, reorganized, retaliated, and transformed American military superiority into strategic frustration.

The Strait of Hormuz became a powerful instrument of that resistance. Energy disruptions, soaring fuel costs, inflationary pressures, military expenditures, and commercial uncertainty carried the war directly into American households.

Washington exported bombs. Iran made Washington import the consequences.

The Pentagon could count its missiles. It could not count the votes those missiles would cost Trump.

Here lies the magnitude of Iran’s achievement: a country subjected to devastating assault exposed the political vulnerability of the world’s most powerful military establishment. American imperialism discovered that its capacity to inflict destruction vastly exceeds its capacity to impose submission.

And the political reckoning did not stop with Trump.

The election also represents a potentially historic defeat for Zionism’s political power in America.

For decades, the pro-Israel political establishment has worked to make unwavering support for Israeli military objectives a virtually unquestionable principle of American foreign policy. Washington’s strategic priorities were repeatedly subordinated to a regional alliance whose costs ordinary Americans were expected to absorb.

The Iran war exposed the danger of that arrangement on a spectacular scale.

Trump embraced Israel’s confrontation with Iran, sacrificed his own antiwar promises, and helped plunge his presidency into political disaster. The electoral backlash now threatens something deeper than Republican control of Congress: the assumption that alignment with Israeli militarism carries no decisive domestic political price.

This election does not establish that Americans have collectively rejected Zionism. But it delivers a devastating warning to its political advocates: supporting Israel’s wars is no longer guaranteed to be politically cost-free.

The irony is merciless. Trump built his movement by denouncing endless wars, Washington corruption, and the foreign-policy establishment. Then he became the very interventionist president his supporters believed they had rejected.

He promised America First. He delivered another war abroad and political collapse at home.

Certainly, economic insecurity, corruption, and dissatisfaction with Trump’s broader presidency contributed to the Democratic landslide. But the Iran war intensified those grievances and exposed the bankruptcy of a foreign policy built on military supremacy and political impunity.

The suffering of Iranians must never be minimized. Nor should strategic resistance be confused with an uncomplicated military victory. But the historic significance remains: Iran denied Washington the outcome for which it went to war, while the war helped destroy Trump’s ability to govern with a compliant Congress.

The empire could devastate Iran. It could not dictate Iran’s future. And it could not protect its own political masters from the consequences.

Trump sought to demonstrate America’s power by changing Iran’s government. Instead, Iranian resistance helped reveal the limits of American power, shake the foundations of Washington’s pro-Israel consensus, and overturn his party’s congressional dominance.

Trump went to Iran to change its regime. Iran survived. American voters changed his.

Prof. Junaid S. Ahmad teaches Law, Religion, and Global Politics and is the Director of the Center for the Study of Islam and Decolonization (CSID – https://csidpk.org), Islamabad, Pakistan.

4 November 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

Across the Red Sea, the Wars Feed Each Other

By Vijay Prashad

Sudan’s war is usually described as an African catastrophe, Yemen’s as an Arabian conflict, and the war around Iran as a Gulf crisis. Such divisions obscure the movement of weapons, money, soldiers, and commercial interests between them. Looking Look from Africa’s Red Sea coast,coast and another picture emerges. These wars have distinct origins, but they increasingly sustain one another through military patronage, competition over ports, and the destruction of civilian livelihoods.

The starting point must be Sudan’s people. The World Food Programme currently estimates that 19.5 million face acute hunger, while around 8.6 million are internally displaced. It reports that sorghum prices are nearly three times higher than a year ago and wheat flour prices have almost doubled. Maritime disruption is raising fuel and fertiliser costs. Sudanese families therefore confront their own war and the economic consequences of wars across the water.

The fighting that began in April 2023 between Abdel Fattah al-Burhan’s Sudanese Armed Forces and Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo’s Rapid Support Forces grew out of from Sudan’s militarised political economy. Dagalo, commonly known as Hemedti, built his power through a paramilitary apparatus rooted in Darfur’s violence. Both military centres accumulated economic power and obstructed civilian democracy. Foreign intervention enlarged their capacity to destroy a country whose popular movement had demanded a different future.

Yemen helped prepare this disaster. After Sudan joined the Saudi-led intervention in 2015, Sudanese soldiers, including large RSF contingents, crossed the Red Sea. The International Crisis Group’s 2019 investigation found that Hemedti supplied considerably more troops than the regular army and that his forces frequently occupied frontline positions. Poor families supplied recruits attracted by military earnings. An impoverished African population became a source of fighting labour for wealthy Gulf monarchies.

That deployment strengthened Hemedti’s standing and external relationships. His forces acquired battlefield experience while he cultivated patrons beyond Sudan’s borders. The significance exceeds any individual payment or deployment. Gulf intervention helped a Sudanese commander consolidate an armed organisation with resources and relationships outside civilian control. A war fought in Yemen contributed to the growth of a military centre that would later wage war inside Sudan. The connection is direct and historical.

Gold supplied another foundation. The UN Panel of Experts’ January 2024 report described gold as a continuing revenue source for Sudan’s warring parties and documented smuggling networks. One consignment linked to an RSF-associated trader reached Dubai through Port Sudan in May 2023. The panel also found that routes shifted towards Egypt after fighting began. This is a regional war economy, capable of changing its commercial pathways when circumstances require.

Interventions in Sudan

The UAE’s role requires scrutiny. Amnesty International reported in May 2025 that guided bombs and howitzers used by the RSF had almost certainly been re-exported through the Emirates. Its analysis examined identifiable weapons and munition remnants. Abu Dhabi denies supplying the RSF, but that denial must be recorded alongside the visual evidence. International arms suppliers also bear responsibility for preventing diversion into Sudan.

An October 2026 European Union Agency for Asylum assessment describes reported RSF supply routes through eastern Chad, southeastern Libya, and northeastern Somalia. These routes connect Sudan’s interior to a much wider African geography. Airfields, border crossings, commercial intermediaries, and military patrons matter as much as formal alliances. Darfur cannot be protected while the networks replenishing armed groups remain intact. Nor can responsibility be confined to the men who pull the trigger.

Saudi Arabia and Egypt, meanwhile, favour the Sudanese army, although their interests and policies differ. Riyadh combines mediation with support for the continuity represented by Burhan’s authorities, while Cairo regards Sudan’s territorial integrity and the survival of a central state as strategic concerns. These preferences do not make either government an advocate of Sudanese popular democracy. The danger is that negotiations become a bargain among military patrons over the country’s future.

There is consequently no single Gulf policy towards Africa. Saudi and Emirati interests overlap, then collide. Sudan exposes these differences, as does Yemen. Nor does hostility towards Iran produce an uncomplicated regional division. Such relationships show how local military authorities seek assistance from different sources, while foreign governments calculate their interests separately in each theatre. Their alignments are practical, contingent, and dangerous.

The African coastline gives these relationships their strategic setting. Port Sudan connects a vast hinterland to the Red Sea. Further south, ports facing the Gulf of Aden offer access to shipping near Bab al-Mandab. Commercial investment can meet real development needs, but port contracts become politically combustible when combined with foreign security arrangements or agreements that bypass national institutions. Control of an entry point can shape an entire country’s economic options.

Somalia has challenged this pattern. In a January interview with Al Jazeera, Minister of State for Foreign Affairs minister of state for foreign affairs Ali Mohamed Omar explained his government’s cancellation of agreements with the UAE. He accused Abu Dhabi of undermining Somali sovereignty through dealings with entities outside the federal government. He said military personnel and equipment should leave, while investments in Berbera and Bosaso required a legal settlement. These were Mogadishu’s stated demands, not proof that every arrangement immediately ended.

The dispute reveals the African stakes of competition across the water. Somaliland and Puntland have their own political histories and interests, but outside powers can exploit disputes over authority to secure ports and military access. African sovereignty then becomes negotiable between external capitals and competing local authorities. What appears from abroad as logistical efficiency may appear locally as the fragmentation of the state and the loss of democratic control.

Yemen provides a warning against assuming that such arrangements are permanent. One assessment records the collapse of much of the UAE-backed Southern Transitional Council’s territorial control in January 2026 after advances by Saudi-backed forces. Emirati troops withdrew, including from Socotra and Perim. Yet local allies retained influence. Withdrawal therefore changed the form and extent of Emirati power without demonstrating that Abu Dhabi had ceased to matter in Yemen.

Renewed fighting now threatens the southern Red Sea. On October 29, Ansarallah claimed attacks on Saudi refineries, an Aramco facility, and airports. Saudi authorities reported interceptions and limited casualties and damage from debris. On October 30, the coalition announced another interception towards the Mecca region, which Ansarallah denied targeting that day. These competing statements establish escalation, but they cannot establish that every claimed target was struck.

Saudi–Emirati rivalry nevertheless coexists with security cooperation. On October 7, the UAE Foreign Ministryforeign ministry condemned attacks on Saudi civilian and economic facilities and Saudi vessels in the southern Red Sea and Bab al-Mandab. The two governments can oppose each other’s local partners while supporting each other against another adversary. Treating them as either a unified bloc or irreconcilable enemies conceals how intervention actually operates.

The United States and Israel widened this system of insecurity through their war against Iran. The military escalation made countries already involved in African conflicts confront new threats at home. Yet their vulnerability has not dissolved their competing African ambitions. For Africa, the lesson is that dependence on outside military patrons imports their wider confrontations. A government seeking weapons for one battlefield may become entangled in struggles whose decisions are taken elsewhere, while its own population inherits the economic costs and the political dangers of those decisions for years afterwards.

The war around Iran magnifies these dangers through the maritime economy. Hormuz and Bab al-Mandab are separate straits, but disruption at both strains connected trading systems. UNCTAD estimated in March that about one-third of global seaborne fertiliser trade passes through Hormuz. Energy costs, insurance premiums, and freight charges transmit military escalation into agricultural costs. African countries experience this connection through import bills, shortages, and pressure on already restricted public finances.

For a Sudanese farmer, these pressures arrive on top of displacement and lost harvests, and for neighbouring countries sheltering refugees, they increase the cost of supporting people driven from their homes. The consequences extend far beyond the coastline. War damages production directly, then raises the price of restoring it. The same commercial system that facilitates the circulation of weapons becomes more expensive for those trying to move food and fertiliser.

Diplomacy must address these connections without denying each conflict’s political roots. On October 20, Iranian Foreign Minister foreign minister Abbas Araghchi said Saudi Arabia and Ansarallah had not responded to Tehran’s mediation offer. An understanding involving Washington and Tehran could reduce regional pressure, but it would not automatically settle Yemen’s struggles over government, territory, and resources. Likewise, a Saudi–Emirati accommodation would leave Sudan’s demand for civilian democracy unresolved.

An African agenda for peace must therefore insist on halting external military supplies, protecting humanitarian routes, and defending sovereign control over ports and resources. Sudanese civilian organisations must have decisive political space in any settlement. The Red Sea should connect peoples through trade and cooperation, and its shores cannot be surrendered to arrangements in which African wealth pays for African destruction while outside powers negotiate their shares of the resulting ruin.

Vijay Prashad is an Indian historian and journalist. He is the author of forty books, including Washington Bullets, Red Star Over the Third World, The Darker Nations: A People’s History of the Third World, The Poorer Nations: A Possible History of the Global South, and How the International Monetary Fund Suffocates Africa, written with Grieve Chelwa. He is the executive director of Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research, the chief correspondent for Globetrotter, and an editor at LeftWord Books (New Delhi).

3 November 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

Fetishists for Bombing: Resuming the Attacks on Iran

By Dr. Binoy Kampmark

Tenured insanity is set to return after the midterm elections in the United States. In October, US President Donald Trump seemed to ice the ongoing conflict against Iran with the dismissive promise that it would be dealt with after November 3. This could involve the renewal of force so far shown to be woefully incapable of bringing Tehran to heel. “Somebody asked me before, when will the war in Iran end?” he stated during a campaign stop in Lubbock, Texas last month. “I said, ‘Whenever I want it to end.’ It’ll be very quick, but we have to have it end properly, with total and complete – a total statement they will never have a nuclear weapon.”

The Pentagon is certainly adding to the military complement in the Persian Gulf, having deployed the USS Theodore Roosevelt, with various amphibious landing ships with Marines, from San Diego, in late September. Towards the end of October, Associated Press reported that the latest deployments would inflate the number of US sailors and marines to over 20,000, including hundreds of aircraft.

To this can be added the incessant prodding of the Israelis. The New York Times on October 21 cited US officials, among various appraised sources, that US-Israeli military drills had been taking place for “a short but intensive operation”, including flyovers over Iraq to simulate strikes. Proposed targets include energy sites, nuclear facilities that were supposedly so thoroughly eliminated in previous attacks, and the usual operations against the missile and drone arsenals that always seem to diminish without any notable effect.

On November 2, however, the schizophrenic leader of Freedom’s Land suggested that another deal to end the conflict “could happen”, though he made various jaws drop with his assessment that Washington and Tehran were not really at war. (His world is evidently all that is not the case.) There had, in his cod assessment, been “very little fighting” between the two powers. The usual rusted issues would remain non-negotiable, foremost the injunction against acquiring nuclear weapons. “We’re not going to allow Iran to ever have a nuclear weapon, and they understand that. They’ve understood that and they’ve said it even recently.”

Background furniture is certainly moving. On November 1, for instance, Iranian negotiators were in Doha for a third consecutive day of talks with Qatari mediators seeking some means of ending the war. Vice President JD Vance also opined that there had been “a number of good conversations with the Iranians”, a point he never expands upon with much credibility. “Look, the president and I both feel pretty good about the prospects for potentially coming to a negotiated settlement. We’re going to keep working on it.”

How much of this is a last minute, if grasping attempt to placate voters ahead of the November 3 poll is impossible to say, though it would be unwise to rule it out. For voters who care to consult the historical and economic record, the president who swore to end the “forever wars” pursued with relish by the US security and defence establishment has been responsible for military operations he cannot define against an adversary he cannot fathom along a timeline he does not know. His inability to understand the risks posed to fabled global supply chains, from oil to fertilizers, and his refusal to accept the nexus between the Iran War and the rise in fuel prices in the US, show him to be touched in all manner of ways. Ditto a lack of appreciation that the war has widened to include attacks by Iran-backed Houthi rebels against the oil and aviation infrastructure of Saudi Arabia.

In the meantime, the Iranians have been rearming and refining their weapons stocks, helped by a vast clandestine network of over 5,000 entities able to import at least $2 billion worth in hardware, explosives and heavy-duty trucks since January 2025. Expansive retaliation is also being mooted. Spokesman Hossein Mohebbi claims that the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) was ready to confront another assault, adamant that the Islamic Republic is pursuing “maximum deterrence” as a goal. Army spokesman Mohammad Akraminia affirmed the approach that Iran’s armed forces will pursue with brio: asymmetric warfare across a wider theatre. “If the US president once again embarks on another adventure in the region through threats and inducements offered by the Zionists, the flames of war will undoubtedly engulf a wider geographical area, and its end will not be in his hands.”

Talking heads are also on the circuit predicting greater regional convulsions should the US and Israel wish to resume their despairing military efforts against the Islamic Republic. “In terms of offence,” promises Hossein Kanani Moghaddam, a former senior IRGC commander, “our target database has expanded, the range, accuracy and warheads of our missiles has improved and our drone capabilities have increased.” In the wooden language of military bureaucracy, so often proximate to the argot of finance and the stock market, Moghaddam also confirmed that “new” enemy assets had been identified across a broader geographical scope.

The oppressive fogginess of war resists clarity; identifying the difference between hot bluster and cool empirical truth can be an impossible task. But Tehran has shown that, however crippled or damaged its infrastructure for making war might be, it can do much with what it has. It’s up to the deluded fetishists for bombing to take note.

Dr. Binoy Kampmark was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge.

3 November 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

If AI Thinks for Us, Democracy Will Suffer

By John Palfrey

CHICAGO—Sometime in the 18th century, the Enlightenment settled a contentious, centuries-old question: Where does knowledge come from? For millennia, many people had pointed to God. But the early modern period brought a new consensus, namely that knowledge comes from human scientists working at the edge of what is known, armed with observation, mathematics, experimentation, and logic.

As the historian Steven Shapin has noted, this was a social as much as an intellectual revolution. Science started rewiring our shared value system around the idea that research and rigor are virtuous. We held ourselves and our highest institutions to the standard of scientific inquiry.

No political system reflects this shift better than democracy. The ideal of popular sovereignty rests on the principle that each of us is capable of comparing candidates or policy proposals and reaching our own informed conclusion.

Today, we are on the cusp of a similar revolution. In September, one of OpenAI’s models took less than a week to solve a math problem that had stumped scientists for decades; and AI systems are already identifying novel antibiotic candidates by searching chemical spaces too vast for any research team to explore. In a growing number of fields, machines are autonomously producing new information. Humans are still posing the questions and evaluating the outputs, but the generative act—the creative leap across the unknown—is increasingly sparked by systems that do not think the way we do or really think at all.

As we saw with the Scientific Revolution, new information systems often lead to new epistemological and ethical systems. AI implicitly teaches us to value ease, speed, and outsourcing, and these values do have their place in certain contexts. No human can parse as much data as quickly as an AI can, and in sectors like medicine, speed often saves lives.

But as anyone who has watched the internet evolve in recent years knows, moving fast can mean breaking things. We cannot allow our democratic institutions to become one of those things.

AI’s greatest skill is pattern recognition. We feed the algorithm a question or equation, and it compares inputs to identify an answer. What it cannot do is decide which questions are worth asking, which outcomes are worth pursuing, or what kind of future we should try to build. These are precisely the kinds of questions democracy demands we consider.

Many of the most important questions humans face cannot be outsourced. For example, which policies can mitigate political polarization? How should a liberal democracy balance surveillance and civil liberty? And what does justice require of a society plagued by deepening inequality?

These are not problems that pattern recognition can solve, because none has a single solution. They require human judgment—however imperfect, contested, ever-evolving, and unsettled it may be—as well as context that only people in communities can recognize and feel. Whatever value system we adopt for our newest information age, we will need to account for AI’s inability to answer humanity’s most important questions.

We have been here before, and more recently than many people realize. Ever since the internet became ubiquitous in our personal and professional lives, we have had to figure out how to metabolize more and more information, while protecting the truth. We have had to find ways to ensure that the digital economy serves the public interest, not just corporate interests and the bottom line. Fortunately, litigants and courts have finally begun to hold the big social-media platforms liable for harms to children.

At the same time, digital technologies brought many benefits. The Digital Public Library of America has ensured access to books that are banned or unavailable in some parts of the country. The Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine allows us to track down an article on the web from decades ago. Wikipedia has made a wealth of collective knowledge accessible for free. And Khan Academy has used digital technologies to democratize education.

These projects are testaments to the values we adopted centuries ago during the Scientific Revolution. Even as mis- and disinformation became omnipresent online, we made a choice to protect truth and evidence from being buried, to make facts freely available, and to welcome anyone who wanted to learn more.

AI requires us to make a similar choice. Whereas the internet buried us in information—true and false, benign and malicious—AI offers to outsource analysis altogether.

We should resist the temptation. Answers, however derived, are not as valuable as insights (as mathematicians responding to OpenAI’s breakthroughs have pointed out). We shouldn’t value the product over the process of learning and discovery. Democracy demands that all citizens show up, whether at the ballot box, the school board meeting, or the dinner table.

Our institutions, by design, cannot run on inertia. Democracy, like science, is powered by dissatisfied people always asking the next question about how we can be better, smarter, faster, and freer. When we stop showing up or start substituting informed opinions for AI-generated answers, that engine stops.

Philanthropy can help. Along with nine other funders, we at the MacArthur Foundation are supporting Humanity AI, a $500 million initiative to ensure that humanity remains at the center of the development of AI in the years to come. Two of the key areas of focus at the outset are democracy and education. These institutions must evolve to meet the moment, and AI itself needs to be designed and deployed always in ways that leave humans in the driver’s seat.

AI may ultimately empower us to create a better, smarter, safer world. But we would do well to remember that it was built on the backs of peer review and public research universities.

The products of the Scientific Revolution cannot supplant the process and the principles that created them. That process is precious, and it must be protected.

John Palfrey is President of the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation.

Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2026.

2 November 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

The Solution Staring Israel in the Face

By Jeffrey D. Sachs

Benjamin Netanyahu, Itamar Ben-Gvir, and Bezalel Smotrich decisively lost Israel’s election on October 27. The governing coalition of Likud, the far right, and the ultra-Orthodox parties fell from 64 seats in 2022 to 53, eight short of a majority in the 120-seat Knesset. The other 67 seats went to parties that campaigned to replace the government: 48 to the Jewish-led opposition headed by Gadi Eisenkot, a former army chief of staff, and 19 to the two Arab parties. Turnout was 77.9 percent, the highest since 1999, and Arab citizens, who make up about one-fifth of Israel’s population, voted at an estimated rate of about 80 percent, up from 53 percent in 2022. The results make it clear: Israeli voters chose to end the Netanyahu government. The solution to Israel’s political crisis is in plain view. The only thing standing in the way of ousting the government is racism: the refusal of Israel’s Jewish opposition leaders to treat Arab citizens as part of the political community.

The racism is not hidden. On election night Netanyahu claimed a “decisive majority among the Zionist and Jewish public,” a formula that simply subtracts the votes of one citizen in five. His Likud party then viciously and absurdly declared that the election ha

d been “stolen” by the Arab parties and demanded investigations by the police and the Shin Bet, Israel’s internal security service. The purpose, of course, is to brand Arab votes as illegitimate, so that no government resting on them can be accepted.

The tragedy is that the opposition leaders have adopted the same premise. Naftali Bennett, a former prime minister, has said that the Arab parties “are not Zionist, and therefore we will not rely on them.” Avigdor Liberman has ruled out any government that depends on Arab votes, even a temporary one. Eisenkot has said that Ra’am’s leader “won’t be part of my next government,” and that he does not “see any Arab or Haredi parties who accept” his conditions for partnership. These leaders do not object to anything the Arab parties would do in government. With good will, they could easily negotiate a governing arrangement.

The consequences of the racism are predictable. If the opposition leaders hold to their refusal, only two outcomes remain. Israel will go to another election, with the current murderous government remaining for many more months, or the opposition will join a unity government in which Netanyahu stays in power. Netanyahu has ruled out abandoning his far-right partners. Either way, the opposition leaders would hand Netanyahu and his murderous colleagues the victory that the voters denied him.

There are no real policy obstacles to cooperation. Ra’am, the United Arab List, has already served in an Israeli government. In 2021 it joined the coalition led by Bennett and Yair Lapid, the first independent Arab party ever to do so. The other Arab party, the Joint List, has said it would vote with an Eisenkot-led government to establish an official inquiry into the failures of October 7, which is the opposition’s own first priority. Israel’s voters appear to be ahead of their leaders. A Hebrew University survey on election night found that more than 61 percent of opposition voters want Eisenkot to form a government with Ra’am, while only 20 percent prefer new elections. Arab and Jewish opposition voters want the same thing, which is to oust Netanyahu, Ben-Gvir, and Smotrich.

A practical plan should follow directly from the arithmetic. First, when the new Knesset convenes, the 67 members opposed to the Netanyahu government should elect a new Speaker, giving the new majority control of the parliamentary agenda even before a government is formed. Second, Eisenkot should form a true coalition in which Ra’am sits as a full partner with ministerial posts, giving 56 seats, with the Joint List supporting the government from outside to reach 67.

The program of such a government would not be hard to negotiate, because the parties that would be in it already share most of it. The government would establish an official inquiry into the failures of October 7. It would adopt an emergency plan against the crime and violence that have devastated Arab towns, and it would invest in housing and services for Arab communities, including the unrecognized Bedouin villages of the Negev. It would restore the independence of the courts and the attorney general.

The government might last a year. Questions of borders and the Palestinian territories would not be settled by this government, but a non-racist coalition government now would move Israel toward a lasting peaceful solution, perhaps toward a binational democratic state or toward the two-state solution of the long-standing Arab Peace Initiative. In the meantime, and crucially, Netanyahu and the other war criminals would be ousted.

Israel’s leaders should also understand what is at stake beyond Israel’s borders. Israel’s racism and murderous campaign in Gaza and the occupied West Bank have profoundly alienated people all over the world. A Pew Research Center survey of 36 countries this spring found that a median of 67 percent of respondents view Israel unfavorably, including 60 percent of Americans. In Pew’s surveys this year, Israel was viewed more negatively than any other country it asked about. More Americans now sympathize with the Palestinians than with the Israelis. The alienation extends to Jews all over the world. If the politicians double down on their racism now, they will confirm the world’s harshest judgments of Israel.

What is needed from the opposition leaders? Nothing beyond decency. The government that ousts Netanyahu is the one that accepts the votes of Arab citizens. Israel’s president has asked the party leaders to come to his consultations with an open mind. The majority to remove Netanyahu exists, provided that the leaders drop their racism

Jeffrey D. Sachs is a University Professor and Director of the Center for Sustainable Development at Columbia University, where he directed The Earth Institute from 2002 until 2016. He is also President of the UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network and a commissioner of the UN Broadband Commission for Development.

31 October 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

Thoughts on the Midterm Elections

By Chris Hedges

“The Democratic Party hierarchy will see the results not as a repudiation of Trump, but an endorsement of the flaccid and ineffectual position of a party that stands for little and fights for less.”

The Democrats may have taken control of the House and the Senate, they may have humiliated Donald Trump and the Republican Party, but the real fight is only beginning. It is not simply a battle to hold the corrupt Trump regime to account, something that can only be done if the Democrats are willing overcome their reluctance to carry out impeachment proceedings against the president. It is also a battle to sweep away the corporate-indentured hierarchy of the Democratic Party, including Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries.

The Democratic Party since the presidency of Bill Clinton, who gave us the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), the greatest betrayal of the working class since the 1947 Taft-Hartley Act, and gutted New Deal-era welfare programs such as the Aid to Families with Dependent Children, is a more polished version of corporate and oligarchic rule, abjectly subservient to the war machine, the Israel lobby and their funders in the billionaire class.

The country is broken. Corruption, in both parties, is endemic. Federal agencies have been hollowed out and destroyed. The courts, including the Supreme Court, have been handed over to right-wing ideologues. The working class is crippled with debt peonage and substandard wages. Constitutional norms and protections have been erased. Billionaires, including Trump, pay little to no income tax. The 2010 Citizens United Supreme Court ruling, which allows big business to fund their hand-picked candidates, sustains a system of legalized bribery.

The public may clamor for a raise in the minimum wage, Medicare for All, regulation of the big banks and private equity firms, an end to arms shipments to Israel and campaign finance reform, but no one in the leadership of the Democratic Party listens or cares. They serve their paymasters.

Will cutthroat capitalism, sold to us under the sanitized name of neoliberalism, be allowed to continue to impoverish the citizenry and funnel wealth upwards into the hands of the 1 percent? Will corporations be regulated and policed? Will corporate criminals be brought to trial? Will our democracy be restored? Or will the grotesque sight of a trillionaire, Elon Musk, gutting federal agencies and pouring hundreds of millions into elections to try and control the outcome be normalized?

The handful of politicians who attempt to confront the corruption and the devastation visited on the American working class through deindustrialization and deregulation, such as Bernie Sanders, see their campaigns sabotaged by the Democratic Party leadership, including Barack Obama.

We must demand that progressive candidates, including Michigan senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed and Maine’s Troy Jackson, build coalitions to oust the Democratic Party leadership, raise the minimum wage, enact universal health care, prosecute corporate crime and impeach Trump. It will be up to us.

The Democratic Party hierarchy will see the results not as a repudiation of Trump, but an endorsement of the flaccid and ineffectual position of a party that stands for little and fights for less. This would be yet another betrayal by the Democrats of voters. It would keep alive the very real prospect of another fascist, one better organized and more intelligent, taking the White House in two years.

Of course, this fight will mean not only jettisoning a corrupt Democratic Party leadership, but turning on the mega-donors, lobbyists and corporations that fund and control the Democratic Party.

The effort to wrest the party back from the hands of corporations and oligarchs will be vicious and difficult. It will require us to rely on the power of mass movements to sever these bonds. Nothing else will work.

If we fail, our anemic democracy will not be saved by these midterm elections, but doomed.

Chris Hedges, who graduated from seminary at Harvard Divinity School, worked for nearly two decades as a foreign correspondent for The New York Times, National Public Radio and other news organizations in Latin America, the Middle East and the Balkans.

5 November 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

The Republicans’ Defeat…An Israeli Angle

By Awni Al-Daoud

Most public opinion polls in the United States had predicted that the Democrats would gain several seats and the Republicans would lose some. However, no one anticipated such a “sweeping” victory for the Democrats or such a crushing defeat for the Republicans. In fact, this Democratic triumph marks only the third time since the end of World War II that one of the two major parties has managed to win both the Senate and the House of Representatives in the same midterm election.

Ever since the final results began to emerge, various analyses, articles, and commentaries sought to explain the reasons behind the Democratic victory and the Republican defeat. They point out that, ever since the outbreak of the US-Israeli war against Iran last February, most American polls indicated that a broad segment of the American public does not view this conflict as one necessitated by US national security interests. Instead, they see it as a war that the US President and the Israeli Prime Minister chose to wage based solely on their own personal preferences.

Therefore, regardless of all the analyses that have been—or have yet to be—published, if we truly wish to uncover the real reasons for the Republicans’ defeat in these midterm elections, we must first “look for Israel!” – This is not merely a personal opinion; rather, the evidence confirms the following:

1 – First, these midterm elections may be unique in that American voters based their decisions—at least in part—on foreign policy issues. A primary point of contention was foreign policy—specifically, the war on Iran and its resulting economic consequences—which have directly impacted the livelihoods of American citizens in the following ways:

a) Americans are feeling the direct, negative effects of this war through fuel prices, which have risen by approximately 50% compared to their levels before the conflict began.

b) In many American cities, people rely heavily on their own vehicles for transportation and commuting to work.

c) The impact of rising fuel prices is not limited to individual travel; it also extends to the agricultural sector. Large-scale farms depend on fuel and fertilizers for production, which has been a significant factor in the Republicans’ defeat across rural America.

2 – Criticisms regarding the pursuit of wars—rather than ending them, as President Trump had promised—specifically concerning Gaza and Iran (and Israel’s pivotal role in drawing the United States into these conflicts), are seen by observers as having significantly contributed to the victories of many Democratic candidates. These candidates capitalized on the negative economic repercussions and their direct impact on the livelihoods of American citizens. Evidence of this includes:

a) – The historic, sweeping victory of candidate Abdul El-Sayed (Abdel Rahman Mohamed El-Sayed), the son of Egyptian immigrants. His win—securing a seat in the Michigan State Senate—made him the first Muslim ever elected to that body in U.S. history. Throughout his campaign, El-Sayed focused on healthcare and economic justice, while also criticizing US support for Israel and the war in Gaza. He frequently argued that American taxpayer dollars are being used by a foreign government to fund a “genocide” in the Gaza Strip, and that prioritizing foreign military aid at the expense of urgent domestic issues is a serious problem. This specific issue—foreign aid—prompted President Trump to announce, on the morning of the election, that aid payments to Israel would cease by the end of the year.

b) – In New Jersey, Adam Hamwy won a seat in the House of Representatives, becoming the first Muslim and the first Arab American to represent the state in the U.S. Congress. A plastic surgeon of Egyptian descent and a former US Army officer who served in Iraq, Hamwy gained national prominence after participating in medical missions inside Gaza during the war. He made his human experience in the [Gaza] Strip a central pillar of his election campaign; he also called for an end to military aid to Israel and criticized the prospect of a war with Iran.

c) Darializa Avila Chevalier, who won the seat for New York’s 13th District—her political background suggests that her experience in the West Bank and her involvement in pro-Palestinian student activism played a key role in shaping her political stances.

In summary:

1 – The biggest loser in these midterm elections is Benjamin Netanyahu. He has lost the Republicans’ ability to provide him with unconditional support—having already alienated the Democrats by turning his back on them in recent years and betting exclusively on Trump. This loss compounds the diminishing prospects of him forming an Israeli government following the results of the most recent Israeli elections.

2 – The results demonstrate that the image of Israel as a “pampered” state—enjoying a sense of immunity among Americans—has shifted; the situation in Gaza and regional conflicts have altered the sympathies of the American public.

3 – The election results will have a significant impact within the United States, globally, and certainly on our own region. The occupant of the White House—despite retaining veto power—has now entered a “lame duck” phase, and will no longer be able to continue providing the same level of unconditional support to Israel as seen over the past two years.

Awni Al-Daoud wrote this column in the Arabic Ad Dustour as one of the editors of this nation-wide newspaper in Jordan. Here it appears in translated form in Crossfirearabia.com

5 November 2026

Source: countercurrents.org

A new UK hierarchy of racism will gag Israel critics from Westminster to the playground

By Jonathan Cook

Antisemitism is being weaponised once again, as Andy Burnham’s government rounds on the Jewish-led Greens and rolls out a Big Brother programme in schools

NOTE TO THOSE READING VIA EMAIL: This article may have been truncated by your email client. In which case, please click on the headline to take you directly to the full Substack article.

Britain is firmly back in the grip of a full-blown moral panic about leftwing “antisemitism”, once again manufactured by the UK’s political and media classes desperate to shield themselves and Israel from scrutiny.

They are keen to smear large swaths of the British public as Jew haters, just as they did a decade ago when they targeted Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour party.

But this time the task will be far harder.

Britons are being told they must pretend that the last three years – years in which they watched Israel butcher and maim many tens of thousands of children in Gaza, and then starve them – never happened. They must not believe their lying eyes.

Nor apparently did they see the British political class actively collude in those atrocities year after year: by supplying weapons, passing on intelligence, excusing atrocities, providing diplomatic cover, and crushing protest.

Nor did they witness the billionaire-owned media smear the anti-genocide protests as Jew hatred and soft-soap Israel’s relentless atrocities as a “war on Hamas”.

Now the British establishment is recruiting once again a self-serving definition of antisemitism it foisted on public life a decade ago to smear its critics, from the Jewish leader of the Green party to schoolchildren expressing solidarity with slaughtered Palestinian children.

The Israel-initiated definition of antisemitism, formulated by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA), focuses on stigmatising criticism of Israel and its apologists rather than protecting Jews.

It cites as examples of Jew hatred the description of Israel as a racist state and any kind of historical comparison between Israel and the actions of the Nazis – long the West’s cultural yardstick for judging crimes against humanity.

Under the IHRA’s misleading definition, the International Court of Justice, the world’s highest court, must be judged antisemitic for concluding in 2024 that Israel enforces a system of apartheid against Palestinians – that is, a system of institutionalised, racist segregation.

Similarly, the critically acclaimed Israeli documentary NAZA must be called out for Jew hate, because an intelligence officer compares the military actions he took part in in Gaza, using AI to kill Palestinians on an industrial scale, with those of the Nazis.

One-party state
In this latest round of the British establishment’s weaponisation of antisemitism, the main target is once again a political leader whose party has broken with the decades-old, failing neoliberal consensus.

Zack Polanski, the only Jewish leader of a major political party, is being painted as an enabler of antisemitism – accused of permitting Jew hatred to infect the Green party just as Corbyn was while heading the Labour party.

[https://x.com/Jonathan_K_Cook/status/2111900750984942023]

The pretext this time is that the Greens passed a motion at their annual conference – supported by a majority of the wider membership – declaring Zionism to be a racist political ideology.

The motion notes that the self-declared “Jewish” state of Israel, the realisation of the Zionist movement’s ambitions, was created through the mass expulsion of the native Palestinian population. As the ICJ concluded, Israel also upholds a system of apartheid rule for the benefit of Jews only.

This may all be hard to refute but the British political and media classes aren’t interested in truth. They want blood – and the IHRA antisemitism definition supplies the knife.

Both prime minister Andy Burnham and Lib Dem leader Ed Davey have responded to the motion by refusing to work with Polanski and the Greens, should the next general election produce a hung parliament.

[https://x.com/EdwardJDavey/status/2112269863561429032]

In other words, they are prepared to spurn the only Jewish-led party, supposedly on the grounds of fighting antisemitism, even if it means killing their own chances of holding power. By default, that may open the door to the right and far-right forming the next government.

That is where, as both Labour and the Lib Dems know only too well, real racism, not the confected kind, runs rampant.

According to a 2017 Institute for Jewish Policy Research survey, recording antisemitic attitudes by political affiliation, those holding “very rightwing” views were three times more likely than other political factions to have strongly antisemitic views.

Notably, the proportion of “very leftwing” voters holding strongly antisemitic views was entirely in line with the rest of the population – that is, it was a marginal phenomenon.

A similar survey by MORI two years later showed a similar pattern: of the right being both far more pro-Israel than the left and far more anti-semitic.

Nonetheless, at the time of these surveys, the political and media classes were claiming, contrary to all the evidence, that a leftwing, Corbyn-led Labour party was plagued by Jew hate.

Now they are doing exactly the same to the Greens.

The Polanski smears alone should serve as proof of the deep, institutionalised corruption of the British political system – a system that continues to excuse and conspire in Israel’s genocide.

Wrecking the Greens

As with the Corbyn era, the all-out assault on Polanski is intended to wreck his party by prising open divisions.

During Corbyn’s time as leader, he found his ability to represent the views of Labour’s huge grassroots membership consistently undermined by the bulk of his MPs and a rightwing party bureaucracy content to rely on big donations from corporations and the super-rich.

They were determined to stop Corbyn from ever reaching a position of power from which he could implement a popular programme of mildly socialist policies, such as ending austerity, redistributing wealth, halting forever wars, and taking failing utilities like the privatised, profit-seeking water companies back into public ownership.

His opponents struggled to attack him directly on policy, so they focused on character-assassination instead.

Now Polanski and Green members find themselves in the same boat, facing off against the old guard of the Green party, headed by former leader Caroline Lucas and a handful of MPs.

The media have been helping to bolster this group as a supposed safe pair of hands – the adults in the room – who can take back control of the party.

The goal, one assumes, is that, stripped of Polanksi, the Greens will sink back into electoral irrelevance.

Then there will be no danger of a Polanski-led party ending austerity, redistributing wealth, halting forever wars, and taking failing utilities like the privatised, profit-seeking water companies back into public ownership.

Soap-opera politics

During Corbyn’s tenure, the establishment narrative was that the many hundreds of thousands of disillusioned British voters drawn back into politics by Labour’s new-found commitment to democratic socialism were all dangerous “antisemites”.

In this fanciful telling, Labour became Europe’s largest party only because Jew-hating entryists overran it.

In response, Sir Keir Starmer, Corbyn’s successor, purged Labour of its left wing, once again making the party dependent on donations from Big Business.

The left evicted from Labour found a new political home in the Green party, sending membership numbers rocketing to record highs there.

According to the political and media class, this is not proof that large swaths of the British public want a different kind of politics: an end to permanent austerity and imperial wars – an end to a policy agenda dictated by billionaires.

No, in their view, it simply means that the “antisemitic” left has now infiltrated the Green party and must be rooted out again.

This is the establishment’s whack-a-mole interpretation of rising public anger – anger it would prefer to channel into support for racist scapegoating led by the Reform far-right than risk the left gaining power to tackle the billionaire class’s chokehold on public policy.

Even as the two-party system splinters into an array of factions, Britain continues to look solidly like a one-party state, whose different rosettes represent the same monied interests.

You either back neoliberal austerity at home and corporate-sponsored imperial wars and genocides abroad – or you must be figuratively burnt at the stake as an antisemite.

Hierarchy of racism

The manufacturing of a “left” antisemitism scare for a second time is more ambitious and high-risk than before. Parts of the public are waking up to the playbook after three years of British government collusion in Israel’s genocide.

This time, the political and media classes are widening their dragnet to intimidate a far wider section of the population, through a new Big Brother programme to be rolled out in schools.

On this occasion the gaslighting and bullying of the British public is not being restricted to the left, or even to adult voters. It is reaching deep into the UK education system, with the government formally imposing for the first time a hierarchy of racisms to be enforced on children.

Schools will now be required to treat antisemitism as a unique and especially pernicuous form of racism – even as all the evidence shows racism towards Muslim and black communities is far more prevalent and troubling.

The large mobs taking to Britain’s streets, trying to stop small boats crossing the Channel and seeking to burn down migrant hostels, are chiefly hostile to brown people and Muslims, not Jews.

Survey after survey shows a swelling tide of Islamophobia.

According to data compiled by the Crime Survey for England and Wales for the three-year period to spring 2025, Muslims were the most likely of any religious and ethnic group to face both religious and race-based hate crime.

Nonetheless, Burnham’s government has announced it is adopting in full all 27 recommendations made by an official review charged with tackling a supposed antisemitism crisis in British schools. It was set up earlier this year, shortly before Starmer stepped down as prime minister.

The review was entrusted to Sir David Bell, a former chief inspector of schools and senior civil servant in the education department. Bell is described in the review’s terms of reference as “independent of government” and as having “no conflict of interest”.

And yet, as the media watchdog body Newscord notes, Bell was actually receiving a salary as vice-chair of a government agency called Skills England through much of the period he was conducting the review.

[https://x.com/newscord_org/status/2113701963837677675]

For the past decade he has also been listed as sitting on the national council of the Academic Study Group.

The ASG states that its sole “firm policy” is opposition to the BDS movement, which seeks peaceful means – through boycotts and sanctions – to end Israel’s criminal behaviour towards the Palestinian people, echoing the campaign against apartheid South Africa.

The group’s director, John Levy, wrote in 2021 that the trust was founded to curb “hostility” towards Israel and serve “as a vehicle for introducing British academics to some of the predicaments of contemporary Israel”. Its work includes providing talks supportive of Israel to British schools.

Bell himself has in the past been accused of Islamophobia. In 2005, when he was head of Ofsted, he singled out Muslim faith schools for putting Britain’s “national coherence” at risk.

Antisemitism weaponised

Bell’s decision to treat antisemitism as a “distinct form of racism” – separate from other racisms and requiring special safeguarding procedures to protect Jewish pupils – is exactly the approach fiercely rejected in an earlier inquiry, one set up by Starmer.

Martin Forde KC was appointed in early 2020 to investigate claims of an antisemitism problem under Corbyn, Starmer’s predecessor.

Much to Starmer’s annoyance, Forde’s report, published in 2022, found that Corbyn had been largely correct that antisemitism was weaponised during his tenure for factional gain, chiefly by the right of the party that Starmer had come to lead.

Forde also criticised the rightwing Labour bureaucracy, which had opposed Corbyn, for “in effect operating a hierarchy of racism”, privileging antisemitism while ignoring or downplaying other forms of racism. Staff were berated for using antisemitism for political point-scoring against the left instead of taking a serious approach to tackling antisemitism.

With the help of the media, Starmer has succeeded in largely wiping Forde’s report from the record. It is almost never referenced.

With the Bell review, we seem to be back to square one: the weaponisation of antisemitism to create a hierarchy of racism is being extended from politics to schools.

Hidden in the report’s later pages, Bell actually notes that there has been no rise in antisemitism, observing of recent years: “Anti-Jewish attitudes are typically less prevalent and have remained more stable.”

Perhaps not suprisingly, in parallel Bell points out that opposition to Israel has steadily risen during the period that the world watched Israel murdering, maiming and starving Gaza’s children.

Or as the report observes: “Anti-Israel sentiments are more prevalent and have been increasing.”

Bell himself points to a survey conducted in 2025 – at the height of the Gaza genocide – in which a quarter of all Britons and half of those aged between 18 and 24 said they were uncomfortable “spending time with people who openly support Israel”. By contrast, only 3 per cent said they were opposed to having a friendship with someone because they were Jewish.

In other words, Bell implicitly accepts the very premise of his review is flawed: antisemitism is not more of a problem than it was. It is opposition to Israel’s atrocities that is on the rise.

And that, it seems, is what the Bell review and the government’s new policy towards schools is really seeking to stifle.

Conjured from thin air

It should hardly need stating that, if the review’s premises are faulty, then any conclusions based on those flawed premises are likely to be wrong too.

But that is beside the point. The purpose of the Bell review is not to eradicate a problem of antisemitism in schools that the review largely has to conjure out of thin air.

It has been widely pointed out that Bell’s headline figure of nearly “three in five Jewish children” suffering antisemitism – cited by education secretary Lucy Powell and the corporate media – is completely unfounded.

In fact, the figure is based on a minuscule survey sample of 92 Jewish six-form students, aged between 16 and 19. Of them, 29 reported experiencing antisemitism – less than a third.

But there is a further problem. Even those 29 Jewish students who claim to have experienced antisemitism were likely to have based that experience on the IHRA definition of antisemitism, which focuses on criticism of Israel more than hatred of Jews.

It is quite possible that in many, if not most, of these cases Jewish students perceived as evidence of antisemitism not hatred of Jews but opposition to Israel, or anti-genocide protests, or the promotion of Palestinian rights.

That is even more likely given that more than two-thirds of all Jewish pupils study in exclusively Jewish faith schools, many of which characterise themselves as Zionist and teach pupils to identify strongly with an apartheid Israeli state currently carrying out genocide.

That some Jewish children have been educated, like their parents, to regard critics of Israel’s crimes or its apartheid character as Jew haters, does not make Israel’s critics at fault. It is not their behaviour that needs policing.

Rather, it is the racist, anti-Palestinian education being promoted in Britain’s Zionist schools that needs to be rooted out.

Not fit for purpose

Nonetheless, under the Bell recommendations, pupils, teachers and parents will be bullied into accepting that the horrors they watched Israel commit over the past three years – and that the UK colluded in – are not what they seem.

How is this to be achieved? Burnham’s government is to impose on British schools the IHRA definition of antisemitism – the one that was used to trash Corbyn’s Labour party and is now being wielded against Polanski and the Greens.

On the basis of the IHRA definition, Polanski is being branded the “wrong sort of Jew” – that is, one whose leftwing policies cannot be tolerated.

Now the same atmosphere of the witch-hunt is to be unleashed in British schools.

Leading legal authorities in the UK long ago criticised the IHRA definition as being unfit for purpose. Sir Stephen Sedley, a former Court of Appeal judge and himself Jewish, warned back in 2017 that the definition was poorly worded, imprecise and was being used to stifle legitimate debate about Israel.

One of the IHRA’s examples of antisemitism expressly cites holding Jews collectively responsible for Israel’s actions.

And yet, because seven of the IHRA’s 11 examples focus on Israel, the definition risks increasing antisemitism through its conflation of Jews with Israel – paradoxically, in violation of its own precepts.

It is precisely because of this continuing and wilful misuse of the IHRA definition that its lead author, Kenneth Stern, has repeatedly stated his opposition to it being codified into law and used to police behaviour in schools and colleges.

In a 2019 Guardian oped, Stern accused “rightwing Jews” of “weaponizing” his definition to silence debate about Israel.

But the problem is not just rightwing Jews weaponising antsemitism, it is governments like Burnham’s. The British political and media classes have realised that the IHRA definition is far too useful – in crushing leftwing critics – to ever be mothballed.

Zionist re-education

It is not difficult to predict the combined effect of imposing a hierarchy of racisms in which antisemitism sits at the top and of enforcing the IHRA definition on schools, effectively outlawing robust criticism of Israel.

It will require school administrations and teaching staff to police classrooms and playgrounds as never before and to crack down on any demonstration of normal, empathetic behaviours among pupils. Henceforth concern for the suffering of Palestinians will be classed as aberrant, as “radicalisation”.

Expressing solidarity with Palestinian children killed or injured in Gaza risks being flagged as a safeguarding threat to Jewish pupils. As will displaying pro-Palestinian or anti-genocide badges. As will holding bake sales to raise money to feed and house Gaza’s children living in Gaza’s ruins. As will wearing traditional Palestinian costume on national identity days celebrated in many of Britain’s more diverse schools.

Already since the Gaza genocide, record numbers of pupils have reportedly been referred to the government’s Prevent “counter-extremism” programme for wearing pro-Palestine badges and stickers.

Acts of fellow feeling for the oppressed, for the victims of what the world’s highest court warns is an apartheid regime, will be banished from schools.

Daniel Kebede, head of the National Education Union, has warned: “Recommending the IHRA definition risks tightening the chilling grip already stifling classroom discussion of the Gaza genocide.”

The logic of the government’s hierarchy of racisms will be fully on display.

Pupils will be denied the right to identify with traumatised Palestinian children in Gaza, so that Jewish children in Britain can be left in peace to identify with a foreign state – Israel – even as it is widely accused of committing genocide.

Presumably, the government’s hope is that, if caught early enough, pupils can be trained out of their normal instincts to care for the less fortunate, for those who suffer. They can be taught that such feelings are shameful and evidence of Jew hatred.

And by extension, they can be made to believe that the British state’s years-long collusion in Israeli atrocities is not a crime but the moral thing to do.

Any pupils who stray from the correct path, who refuse to be cowed, will be subjected to mandatory Zionist re-education, implemented through fiercely pro-Israel lobby groups masquerading as Jewish community organisations.

That is the prospect too for British children who have Palestinian, Arab or Muslim heritage, including those who have had family members killed, maimed, ethnically cleansed or tortured by Israel.

For years they have watched the suffering and humiliation of their communities, while knowing that the British government – their government – is complicit in those crimes.

Now they will have to permanently hide and suppress their true feelings to avoid punishment.

Those who fail to do so will be subjected to British state-sponsored instruction programmes – re-education – run by pro-Israel groups to “correct” their wrongthink, to force these children to love the very state that has murdered and abused their compatriots and loved ones.

Racist double standard

To put in proper perspective the government’s crackdown on a largely non-existent antisemitism problem in schools, remember that more than 2,000 young British Jews are believed to have headed off to Israel to help its military commit genocide in Gaza.

The government has done nothing to stop them going. Meanwhile, British police have been repeatedly handed details of potential war crimes suspects but so far have failed to investigate, arrest or charge any of them.

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fzj3_gbsk-g]

Powell, the UK’s education secretary, has told Sky News: “I don’t think that our schools should be a place where it’s about making protests and statements about geopolitical events around the world.”

And yet only a year ago her predecessor, Bridget Phillipson, who set up the Bell review, was filmed in British classrooms with primary schoolchildren waving Ukrainian flags.

[https://x.com/educationgovuk/status/1989017111109210332?s=20]

Despite Powell’s new prohibition, many Jewish pupils will continue to be encouraged by their schools to identify strongly with the foreign state of Israel – a state almost permanently mired, in the worst possible way, in “geopolitical events”.

If it is important for British children to identify with and support Ukraine’s white children through their suffering, why is it not possible – why is it antisemitism – for British children to similarly identify with and support the brown children of Gaza as they go through far greater suffering?

It is hard to imagine an answer that is not racist to its core.

Whatever the government claims, these double standards are not driven by principle. They are not about antisemitism. This is about protecting Israel.

Burnham entered office apologising for how his predecessor, Starmer, “got it wrong” at the outset of Israel’s slaughter in Gaza.

But his government is now doubling down on what Labour got equally wrong in the years leading up to the genocide – when it dedicated its energies to crushing the section of the party led by Corbyn that was warning of Israel’s deeply racist character and of what it was likely to do to the Palestinians.

The gencoide has vindicated Corbyn and the left in the most horrifying manner possible.

No matter. As with the attacks on Polanski, none of this is really about antisemitism. It is about Israel.

It is about the British establishment and the billionaire class protecting their interests both in the war industries Israel is so central to and in the oil-rich Middle East, where Israel acts as the West’s attack dog.

This is about crushing dissent to prop up a crumbling western political order, led by a greedy, belligerent narcissist in the White House, as it is afflicted by collapse on every front: economic, environmental, political and social.

Dissatisfaction and unrest are growing. Violence is simmering. Bullying children into saluting the Israeli flag will not halt the decline. It simply underscores how much the “liberal” western order has lost the plot.

2 November 2026

Source: jonathancook.substack.com

Three years of Sumud in a world of bent rules

By Dr Muslim Imran

A few months ago, during the World Cup, the world witnessed a small but telling spectacle. US President, Donald Trump, telephoned FIFA and demanded that an American footballer, Folarin Balogun, be allowed to play despite a clear ban. FIFA obliged and the rules were rewritten overnight. One phone call, one flex of political muscle, and the law melted away for the empire.

Unfortunately, this is how power in this age actually works. Rules are iron cages for the weak, and mere suggestions for the strong. And if you want to see this principle written in blood, look no further than the three years of genocide that Israel has unleashed on Gaza.

But to measure these three years only by the rubble and the body count would be a mistake. History’s great turning points are not measured by who held which hill at sunset. They are measured by what they changed in the lives and minds of the living.

What Fanon and Gazans understood very well

Frantz Fanon, the Martinican doctor who went to Algeria in the 1950s and saw colonialism up close, wrote in his seminal book The Wretched of the Earth that colonialism “is not a machine capable of thinking, a body endowed with reason. It is naked violence and only gives in when confronted with greater violence.” This is the analytical core of the Palestinian condition. Colonialism is not a negotiation. It is not a misunderstanding between two equal sides. It is one people taking another people’s land, homes, and future by force. And in such conditions, the colonized do not choose resistance as a political preference. They resist because the alternative is to disappear. Fanon is read across the Global South for a reason. His diagnosis of the colonial condition was not written for Algeria alone; it was written for every people told that their suffering is the price of someone else’s civilization. No one understood this better than the Palestinians, especially the people of Gaza.

Gaza did not erupt on October 7, 2023, from nothing. It had been suffocated for decades under a siege that almost everyone, including the United Nations, said was making life impossible. It had been ruthlessly bombed in regular cycles that Israeli generals called “mowing the lawn.” It had watched incredulously the world sign trade deals with its occupier while its children starved. What happened that day did not create a new Israel. It tore the mask off the one that was already there: an atrocious settler-colonial project that, from its inception, carried within it the seeds of genocide.

The dead who gave us life

After three years, the numbers have become a kind of white noise. Entire families of grandparents, parents, and grandchildren have been erased from the civil registry. Not only killed, but also erased. Universities have been turned to dust. Hospitals have been surrounded and emptied of life. This is not the chaos of war. This is the methodical dismantling of a society, carried out with bombs and bullets supplied by the very Western states that repeatedly blocked every attempt at accountability at the UN Security Council. The hypocrisy is not hidden. It is performed in public, almost as a dare.

More than 75 thousand Palestinians were murdered before the eyes of the entire World. [Add to that more than 9 thousand other innocents killed mercilessly across the region by the Israeli war machine]. Among these thousands of innocents was our dear colleague, Dr. Muhammad Jameel, who worked with us at the Asia Middle East Center (AMEC) in Malaysia before his return home. By August 2023, he returned back to Gaza, after completing his doctorate, only to be murdered in October 2023 by an Israeli airstrike on his home that killed him together with twenty-two members of his immediate family. May their souls rest in peace.

The killing of Palestinians spread beyond Gaza, as Israel’s war machine targeted Palestinians, and their allies, across the occupied West Bank and beyond. Israel purposely targeted the leaders of the resistance, assassinating them one after another: Saleh al-Arouri, was assassinated in Beirut, Ismail Haniyeh was assassinated in Tehran, while Yahya Sinwar, was killed fighting in the ruins of Rafah. Leaders of the Lebanese, Yemeni and Iraqi resistance were also targeted and assassinated. The little imperialist colony respected no state’s sovereignty, killing the leaders of the Palestinian people in Gaza, Beirut, and Tehran. Yet all of them were martyred defending their people, some on the battlefield, and other in the corridors of international advocacy. They did not flee. Nor did they negotiate safe passage for themselves. They lived and died among the people they led. That matters a lot, as it helps explain why, despite everything, support for the resistance holds.

The killing did not stop at resistance leaders. The Israeli regime targeted Palestinian intellectuals and professionals across all fields. Thousands of school teachers and hundreds of university professors were killed by Israel’s air force. Doctors and nurses were killed or kidnapped, and journalists were especially targeted, killing hundreds of them. Israel continued to perpetrate more crimes in order to cover the traces of its earlier crimes. Within days of the start of the Israeli military campaign, it was becoming clear to everyone Israel was intent on committing a genocide. Palestinian poet and academic, Dr Refaat al-Areer, who wrote and tweeted about Israeli atrocities, told media in one of his last interviews: “I wish I was a freedom fighter to fight the invading Israeli army. But since I have no gun, I will use anything my hands can hold to fight back. I won’t surrender even if the last thing I do is to throw a pen at the invading army”. Refaat was murdered, but his people, just like him, did not surrender. Three years on, the whole world continues to witness how an impoverished besieged nation has been able to deny a heavily-armed nuclear-power victory. All thanks to the bravery and resilience of its people, and the unending support and solidarity of their friends.

A people return from the margins

Before October 2023, the Palestinian cause was being quietly buried. The “Abrahamic Accords” were weaving a new Middle East in which normalization with the occupier required no end to occupation. Netanyahu stood shamelessly before the United Nations General Assembly and declared, with brazenness, that Palestine was no longer relevant. The Palestinian had been reduced to a face on a UNRWA card, a recipient of aid, a victim to be pitied but never a political actor. But that era is now over!

Three years later, Palestine is back at the center of the world’s moral imagination. The Palestinian has returned as someone who makes history, not just someone who suffers it. The world may not like the methods, but it can no longer pretend the actor does not exist.

The words of the old world have collapsed

The Israeli regime was built upon many myths, such as: Israelis being the eternal victims, Israel being the safe haven for the Jewish people, Israel being the only democracy in the Middle East, the “IDF” being the army that cannot be defeated, and Israel being the peace maker against “terrorist” Palestinians. After three years of footage from Gaza, none of these myths hold. They have been dismantled, not by propaganda, but by the sheer weight of evidence streaming out of a besieged enclave on phone cameras.

Something deeper has happened too. The very language the world used to discuss this struggle has been rewritten. For decades, Israel imposed its own dictionary: this was a “conflict” between two equal sides, the occupation was “self-defense,” and the Palestinian was either a “refugee” or a “terrorist.” Now, words that were once confined to academic footnotes have entered the global conversation: genocide, settler-colonialism, apartheid, ethnic cleansing, accountability. The International Court of Justice has found a plausible case of genocide. The International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Israeli leaders, a move met with a furious campaign of American pressure, including threats and sanctions against the Court’s officials. The message from Washington was unmistakable: international law is not to touch our allies. Yet the warrants were pursued anyway. These are not just legal documents. They are a new vocabulary, and in the battle over words, the Zionist narrative has lost its grip.

The destruction of Gaza has not only exposed Israel. It has exposed the entire system that protects it. The international legal order stands revealed as a selective tool, invoked against enemies, suspended for friends. The great institutions of justice have shown that their enforcement mechanisms vanish the moment a powerful state decides to shield an ally. And the civilizational claims of the Atlantic powers—their professions of universal human rights, of justice, of the rule of law—have been shown to be a story they tell themselves, not a principle they apply.

Three things are now beyond dispute. First, the myth of the invincible Israeli army has been shattered. A strip of land smaller than most cities, under total siege, has held out against a nuclear-armed state for three years. Second, Western complicity is no longer an accusation. It is a matter of public record—the weapons shipments, the diplomatic vetoes, the intelligence sharing, all documented, all deliberate. And third, the Palestinians have not been broken. They have lost more than any people should ever be asked to lose. Yet they remain on their land. They remain organized. They remain, in their millions, committed, more than ever, to the idea that liberation is possible. This is not mysticism. It is the accumulated experience of a people who understand, as Fanon understood, that for the colonized, surrender is just a slower form of death.

The new battleground

The most important shift of these three years has been away from the battlefield and into the arena of moral and legal standing. Israel might have made some tactical gains on the ground, but it is losing the war. This is not our assessment alone; it is the assessment of its own generals and military experts, most recently former Shin Bet chief Ami Ayalon, who has said plainly: “Israel is winning battles, but losing the war.”

Israel has lost something far harder to recover than battles: its image, its founding myths, and the pretense that a closed, exclusivist settler project can ever produce lasting stability. Time, it turns out, does not automatically turn conquest into right. The memory of the dispossessed can be stronger than time, and history is not written only by the victor. It is also written by what the defeated refuse to forget.

And the most important achievement of the Palestinian people’s steadfastness is that global public opinion has actually shifted. Anyone following opinion polls in the United States can see that the new generation, on the left and on the right, views Israel as the root of the problem, not a party to a conflict. This generation understands that the single most important factor in Israel’s survival and power is blind American support; and that this support is beginning to end.

This shift is not confined to the United States. In Western Europe, calls for accountability are on the rise, and countries that have sidelined Palestinian voices for decades are now leading the call for recognition of a Palestinian State. The world is changing.

In the Global South, solidarity with Palestine has always been the norm. South African leadership on the legal front epitomizes the feelings and aspirations of the entire Global South. This is not a symbolic gesture from a country that knows what it means to have international law applied selectively. It is the Global South speaking in its own voice, insisting that the rules must apply to everyone, or to no one. But we know well that the Global South is capable of more.

As for Israel, the colony is heading toward ruin. Not necessarily because anyone will bring it down by force, but because it has planted around itself genocide, racial discrimination, and injustice; and what the oppressor plants, he reaps. When I was a child, my father used to tell me a saying that the old ones repeated in the past: the house of the oppressor ends in ruin. That is what is happening to Israel today.

The Atlantic powers will bend rules for a footballer. They will shatter international law for an ally. But Gaza has shown something more lasting: a people who refuse to disappear, who bury their dead and keep walking, can change the terms of history. Three years in, the struggle continues; not because victory is near, but because the alternative is unthinkable. The road from military might to moral authority is paved with terrible suffering. But moral authority is the last thing a people loses, and the first thing an empire forfeits when its survival rests on force alone.

There is a final note worth remembering. After all that bending of FIFA’s regulations, after the phone call and the political pressure and the rewriting of the rulebook, the United States still lost the match to Belgium. The favor did not deliver the outcome. Something similar is unfolding in Palestine, on a far grander and bloodier scale. Netanyahu and his government have had every international law bent for them, every diplomatic shield extended, every arms shipment approved, even the prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) was threatened and sanctioned to protect them. And yet, after three years of destruction, total victory remains as distant as ever. The Sumud of the Palestinians -the stubborn, unreasonable, magnificent refusal to break- has denied the occupier the one thing it cannot manufacture: an ending written on its own terms.

-Dr Muslim Imran is the Director of Asia Middle East Center. He contributed this article to the PIC.

31 October 2026

Source: english.palinfo.com