Just International

“It is a Holocaust”: An Open Letter to Media Executives Regarding the Vast Undercount of Gaza Carnage

By Ralph Nader

August 15, 2025

New York Times:
Patrick Kingsley
Aaron Boxerman
Isabel Kershner
Adam Rasgon
Natan Odenheimer
Ronen Bergman
International Editor: Philip P. Pan

Washington Post:
Louisa Loveluck
Shira Rubin
Abbie Cheeseman
Miriam Berger
Gerry Shih
John Hudson
Associate Editor: Karen DeYoung

Wall Street Journal:
Foreign News Editor: James Hookway

The American Prospect:
Editor, David Dayen

Dropsite News:
Ryan Grim
Jeremy Scahill

The New Yorker:
Editor, David Remnick

You are some of the leading reporters and editors who have covered the Netanyahu genocidal mass murder and mayhem in Gaza. This important plea asserts that you all know better than to rely only on the extensive understatement of the deaths and serious injuries put forward by Hamas. You need to DO BETTER for your readers by digging deeper into the much higher estimates of deaths by experts in disaster casualties. Eye-witness accounts which do not support the Hamas undercount.

Both Hamas and Netanyahu, for different reasons, favor undercounts. Hamas, the governing entity in Gaza, keeps a strictly defined undercount of casualties from Israeli bombardments, does not count the large immediate secondary fatalities from the effects of Israeli blocking of food, water, medicine, healthcare, electricity, fuel, and medical supplies for what’s left of destroyed hospitals and clinics.

An official undercount from the Hamas Ministry of Health, whose fifteen counters are now themselves starving, temper accusations by the people of Gaza and its allies that Hamas has not protected them, even by sharing bomb shelters. Hamas badly underestimated the total savagery of the Israeli response to its October 7 attack through the mysteriously collapsed multi-tiered Israeli border security complex. Hamas fell into a lethal trap prompted by fears that a near deal between the U.S., Israel, and Gulf Arab states would sideline permanently the question of Palestine.

As sensitive journalists, you probably agree that the undercount is significant. As the Washington Post Foreign Affairs Editor, Karen DeYoung has often said, “…Independent media are not allowed by Israel to enter Gaza and the casualty counts are most certainly under-reported.”

In thousands of news articles, there is the same exact obligatory reference, to wit: “More than X number of Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since the war began according to the Hamas Ministry of Health.” That severe undercount becomes the reported casualty figure despite the Israeli unchallenged, daily demolition bombing of Gaza.

As a result, unlike other armed conflicts in the world, the vast undercount of fatalities and injuries in Gaza is a vastly underreported story. Coming to more accurate estimates would affect the intensity of the political, diplomatic, and civic pressures for a ceasefire. It would also prompt more strenuous calls for immediate humanitarian aid, an immediate ceasefire, and peace negotiations.

Start with common sense. Gaza had 2.3 million people before October 7, 2023, in a cramped area the geographical size of Philadelphia. The Gaza Strip has experienced the most intense, daily bombardment on civilians and civilian infrastructure since World War II. There are no army bases or airfields in Gaza, only an under-armed small guerrilla force hiding in tunnels facing a super-modern military backed by super-modern U.S. military weapons and other Biden/Trump assistance.

As of mid-April 2025, University of Bradford (U.K.) Emeritus Professors Paul Rogers, a specialist on aerial and artillery bomb devastation, described the level of destruction in totally besieged Gaza as the “equivalent of six Hiroshimas, but even more destructive” because many more of the bombs over Gaza drop over targeted locations – schools, apartment buildings, hospitals, clinics, markets, refugee encampments, roads, water mains, electricity circuits and even the agricultural areas to deny the people of Gaza from growing some of their own food. Starvation, death by uncontrolled fires, infections, and the thousands of babies born into the rubble each month spiral the daily accelerating toll.

Now, if you take the current Hamas figure of just over 62,000, you are telling the public that 97% of Gazans are still alive. This is lethally absurd. A more conservative figure is that over 500,000 Palestinians have been killed from Netanyahu’s non-stop Palestinian Holocaust (more than all the U.S. soldiers killed in WWII.) This means that an incredible about one-out-of-four Palestinians have been killed.

American doctors and other health workers back from Gaza say almost all the survivors are either sick, injured, or dying. Without insulin, medicines for cancer, asthma, and heart disease for many months, with no shelters, with dense/deadly air pollutants, from incessant bombings, their observations are not surprising.

So, reporters and editors, start working on casualty estimates that accurately reflect the realities, in addition to respecting the Palestinian dead and properly highlighting the Trump/Congress role in this slaughter. Imagine if you will, if the shoe were on the other foot; does anyone think such an undercount would be tolerated from the outset?

The State Department testified in late 2023 that their estimates were higher than Hamas, and the witness, an Assistant Secretary of State, was shut down from further disclosure. FOIA litigation, pending before the Biden and Trump State Departments, is confronting the usual stonewalling that this Department has long been conducting.

There are credible sources for you to pursue among universities, international relief organizations, and UN food and humanitarian agencies. Specialists (e.g., the University of Edinburgh’s Global Health Department, The Lancet, etc.), have spoken out or published reports on the undercount. Reporting on the work of these and other specialists will advance the public’s right to know.

Dr. Feroze Sidhwa, a Gaza hospital volunteer, has compiled many of these sources and can be reached through the website gazahealthcareletters.org. His writing for The New York Times and other established publications and electronic media is compelling and reflects the on-the-ground reality in Gaza. (See my lengthy interview with Dr. Sidhwa on the Ralph Nader Radio Hour, to be released on August 16, 2025).

Thank you for considering the higher significance of your crucial profession,

Ralph Nader

16 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

Gaza: Apply Sanctions To Apartheid Israel, US, UK, German, French, Australian & US Alliance State Terrorism

By Dr Gideon Polya 

The US Alliance applied sanctions on Russia several days before its illegal invasion of Ukraine. However no significant sanctions have been applied to Apartheid Israel after 22 months of the Gaza Massacre that has transmuted to a Gaza Urbicide (most of Gaza demolished), a Gaza Genocide (680,000 Gazans killed by violence and deprivation, mostly children) and now horrifying mass starvation. The civilized World must apply sanctions to Apartheid Israel and all its state terrorists supporters.  

The World is seriously and existentially threatened by nuclear weapons and climate change [1, 2] but for starving Gazans seeking scarce food,  “deaths from violence and imposed deprivation” (Google the phrase) is a present daily reality. Gaza Genocide-promoting Trump America is bullying the World with lies, threats and tariffs while it supplies the weapons, munitions, bombs, missiles, $3.8 billion annually of military assistance, and the US vetoes at the UN Security Council that enable Zionist Israeli impunity in its unforgivably-imposed and remorselessly ongoing Gaza Genocide. Zionist Israeli imposition of mass starvation on Gaza  will not only kill hundreds of thousands but is so shocking an ongoing war crime as to threaten all of Humanity through an erosion of common humanitarian values.  The World must immediately  stop the killing,  the mass starvation and genocidal Occupation by urgently applying rigorous and comprehensive sanctions on Zionazi Apartheid Israel and its key supporters, notably US, UK, neo-Nazi Germany, France, Australia and US Alliance state terrorism. These appalling realities are succinctly detailed and quantitated below.

(1). The West rightly applied sanctions on Russia  for its war criminal invasion of Ukraine.  Under Stalin Ukraine was subject to collectivisation and a consequent huge famine (Holodomor) in which 7 million perished in 1930-1933. In WW2 the Ukraine was the scene of huge fighting against  the invading Germans with 4.5-7 million Ukrainians  serving in the Red Army, and 6 million Ukrainians dying, including  1.5 million Jews. Some nationalist and fascist Ukrainians collaborated with the Nazi German invaders. The fall of Communism in the Soviet Union led to Ukrainian independence in 1991. However US machinations led to NATO territory steadily moving eastwards and accordingly aggravating the Russians. The removal of the pro-Russian president Yanukovych in 2014 after he rejected moves to join the EU led to Russian seizure of the strategic and mostly Russian-speaking Crimea and armed backing of rebels in the Eastern Ukraine  regions of  Donetsk and Luhansk. A Russian scholar informs that  the difference between Ukrainian and Russian is like that between English in Glasgow and London.

Led by the US, the US Alliance countries and other countries imposed sanctions on Russia on 21 February 2022 after it recognised the independence of the Russia-backed Donetsk People’s Republic and Luhansk People’s Republic in Eastern Ukraine.  After the Russian invasion  on 24 February 2022, Western countries applied increasingly severe economic sanctions on Russia with the aim of devastating the Russian economy. Donald Trump after courting Vladimir Putin is now threatening even more severe sanctions on Russia if it doesn’t agree to a ceasefire [3, 4]. Russia has been damaged economically but has maintained oil, gas,  grain, fertilizer and vegetable oil exports to non-sanctioning countries, notably China and India [5].  Marianne Stein : “Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 caused an immediate disruption in the global wheat market, with serious implications for food prices and global food security… Global wheat prices jumped by 28% in the early phases of the war, but within a few months, they began to decrease, although they remain 2-3% higher than before the invasion. Price increases of 2-3% may not seem like a lot, but it comes on top of ongoing global inflation, and it contributes to worsening food insecurity in many poor countries that are already suffering from high prices and inadequate supply of staple foods” [7-9]. About 7.4 million people die avoidably from deprivation each year, overwhelmingly in the Global South and about 70% under-5 year old infants. It is not known how many millions (?) may have died avoidably from deprivation the Global South [1] as a result  of the global fertilizer, vegetable oil and wheat price increases due to the war in Ukraine.

Ukraine has been devastated by the war but has kept the Russians at bay with arms from the US, NATO and Australia and clever use of drone technology. It is estimated that Russian military dead and wounded total 250,00 and 700,000, respectively, and Ukrainian military dead and wounded total 100,000 and 300,000, respectively [10, 11]. The populations of Russia and Ukraine are 146 million and 39 million, respectively. There are 5 million Ukrainian refugees across Europe and a further 8 million are internally displaced [12]. UN Ukraine (10 July 2025): “Since the beginning full-scale invasion of Ukraine by the Russian Federation on 24 February 2022, HRMMU [the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine] has documented the deaths of at least 13,580 civilians, including 716 children, and 34,115 civilians injured, including 2,173 children” [13].  

(2). The US, West, Australia and US Alliance State terrorists back genocidally racist, egregiously mendacious, endlessly thieving and serial war criminal Apartheid Israel.

Ideologically the Palestinian Genocide notably began with espousal of  a British form of proto-Zionism in the mid-19th century by mass murderer and racist psychopath Benjamin Disraeli (the Irish Famine, Indian famines, Australian Aboriginal Genocide, genocidal British imperialism) [14-20]. Continental European Zionism was founded in the 1890s by genocidally racist Jewish Hungarian psychopath Theodor Herzl  who regarded non-Europeans as “barbarians” and proposed ethnic cleansing of Palestine. Orthodox Jews firmly opposed Zionism and indeed Nathan Birnbaum who coined the term “Zionism” later rejected it and returned to the Orthodox Jewish position (no Jewish return to Zion before the Messiah arrives). Herzl  thought about Argentina as a Jewish State  (it had already been ethnically cleansed of Indigenous inhabitants by the Spanish) but returned to favour  Palestine for Eurocentric and geopolitical reasons [21-26]. Indeed there have been about 20 sites world-wide proposed for Jewish colonization, including in my own country Australia [27-29].    

Oil was discovered in Iran in 1908, the British navy was shifting from coal to oil, the British invaded Ottoman-ruled Iraq in 1914 after deliberately forcing Turkey into WW1, and the British and French prospectively divided up the Ottoman-ruled Middle East by the 1916 Sykes-Picot Agreement. The Palestinian Genocide  began in earnest over a century ago with catastrophic famine in Palestine due to World War 1 (WW1) that caused a demographic deficit of 110,000-250,000 Palestinians [30-37]. Palestine had been continuously inhabited by the Semitic forebears of the present Palestinians for over 4,000 years. Conversion to Islam occurred in about 640 CE. The Al Aqsa mosque in Jerusalem (Al Quds) is the third holiest site in Islam. In  1516 the Ottoman Turks conquered Palestine and thence the Ottoman Caliphate ruled for 400 years until the British invasion in 1917 in WW1. The British forced Turkey into war by seizing warships paid for by Turkey, and then set about sharing the Ottoman Empire between the UK and France who in 1916 signed the secret Anglo-French Sykes-Picot Agreement to divide up the Middle East (notwithstanding the T.E. Lawrence-promoted Arab revolt on promise of Arab independence). In 1917 the Turks were defeated by a British-Arab coalition,  a key Allied victory being the charge of the Australian Light Horse at Beersheba on  31 October 1917.  2 days later, on 2 November 1917,  the UK Balfour Declaration was issued granting a Jewish Home in Palestine  with the caveat that there should be no detriment to Arabs and Jews. In actuality the Balfour Declaration was an inducement for Russian Zionists to keep Russia in the war, but in the event Russia sued for peace and the caveat was quickly violated [38].

Violent mass killing of Palestinians commenced on 10 December 1918 when soldiers of the Australia and New Zealand Army Corps (ANZAC) massacred 100 Palestinian men and boys in the Surafend Massacre [39]. As of  August 2025 the ongoing, century-long, UK- and US-backed, and Zionist-imposed Palestinian Genocide has been associated with 2.7 million Palestinian deaths from violence, 0.2 million, and from imposed deprivation, 2.5  million, since the British invaded the Middle East in WW1 for oil and imperial hegemony. In  1922 the Palestine League of Nations Mandate was granted to Britain.

In 1880 in Palestine there were about 500,000 Indigenous Palestinians (90% Muslims and 10% Christians) and 25,000 Jews, of whom half were immigrants. In  1900-1939 the  Jewish population rose from 50,000 to 300,000 under the racist British Mandate. Many Palestinian tenant farmers lost their livelihoods as owners sold their land to Zionist colonizers. In 1936, there was a  Palestinian general strike, and a guerrilla war broke out between Indigenous Arabs and the British-armed and British-trained invading Jewish colonizers [40]. About 10% of the adult male Palestinian population were killed, wounded, imprisoned or exiled [41, 42]. In 1939 with war looming a  British White Paper constrained Jewish immigration in order to placate the hundreds of millions of Muslim British Empire subjects  but nevertheless in 1939-1945 there was substantial illegal Jewish immigration of Jews fleeing the Nazis. In 1944 the British War Cabinet secretly approved post-war Partition of Palestine. In 1947 the UN adopted the  UN Partition Plan that ignored the desire of many parties for a secular, unitary and democratic state in Palestine (that still remains the most practical and humane option for Palestine) [43]. In  1948 the British left, the UN recognized the State of Israel (but not a Palestinian State), and war commenced between Israel and neighbouring Arab states. The genocidal Zionists committed major atrocities (notably the  Deir Yassin Massacre and the Tantura Massacre, with over 100 and 200 killed, respectively), 800,000 Indigenous Palestinians were expelled, 530 villages were emptied, 120 mosques were ultimately destroyed, 15,000 Palestinians were killed and the Zionists seized 78% of Palestine [44, 45].The residual Indigenous Palestinian  population  in Israel was subject to martial law  until 1966, suffered dispossession from land,  and still suffers discrimination under 65 race-based, Nazi-style discriminatory laws [46, 47].

In 1956 Israel revealed its role as an agent of Western imperialism by colluding with  the UK and France in invading Egypt at the same time as Russia was quashing the Hungarian revolt (the US successfully demanded UK, France and Israeli withdrawal). The Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) was formed in 1964.  In 1967 Apartheid Israel  (now nuclear-armed with US and French help) attacked all of its neighbours (and the defenceless USS Liberty) with occupation of the Sinai (Egypt), Gaza (Egypt), the West Bank (Jordan), Jerusalem (Jordan) and the Golan Heights (Syria) and the expulsion of a further 400,000 Indigenous Arabs. In the 1973 Yom Kippur War (Egypt versus Israel) Egypt unsuccessfully attempted to recover the Sinai that had been captured by Israel in 1967. In 1974 PLO leader Yasser Arafat addressed the UN. In  1976, 6 Palestinians were killed, 100 were wounded and hundreds were arrested in Palestinian protests  in Israel over land seizure (there have been subsequent annual 30 March Land Day protests). US offices secured peace with Egypt in 1979 with return of the Sinai to Egypt. In 1982 Israel invaded Lebanon as far as the capital Beirut where it was complicit in the Sabra and Shatila refugee camp massacres (3,000 Palestinians murdered in Israeli-occupied Beirut by Christian Falangist Israeli allies). The period 1982-2000 saw Israeli occupation of southern Lebanon. The first Palestinian Intifada (revolt; Arabic “shaking  off”) commenced in 1987, and in  1988, Arafat eschewed violence and recognized Israel. The 1993, US-brokered Oslo Agreement for Palestinian self-government permitted small arms arming of Palestinians. Apartheid Israel continued seizure of Arab lands in the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT).

In 2000 Israeli abuses provoked renewed Intifada, and in 2004 Arafat died (unexpectedly high levels of polonium were found on his clothes). In  2005 Apartheid  Israel pulled out from Gaza but imposed strict border controls with continued air attacks on a densely populated Gaza Concentration Camp. Apartheid Israel expanded the Apartheid Wall and  illegal Jewish settlements on ethnically cleansed Arab land in the military-ruled and increasingly diminished West Bank. In 2006 the Muslim Hamas organization convincingly won the Occupied Palestinian elections held under Israeli guns. The US Alliance and Israel rejected the result, and Hamas MPs were variously imprisoned, killed, exiled or confined to the Gaza Concentration Camp . In  2007  Hamas defeated Fatah and took control of Gaza. Apartheid Israel made repeated  violent attacks by land, air and sea  on the Occupied Palestinians confined to the Gaza Concentration Camp [48] (2008-2009, 2012, 2014, 2017 and 2021 Gaza Massacres) with thousands killed, tens of thousands wounded, massive infrastructure and home destruction, and imposition of a deadly blockade to deliberately achieve near-unliveable conditions. The excuses for these ongoing Gaza Massacres were home-made rockets fired from Gaza that killed about 40 Israelis this century.

The genocidally racist Zionists continued their illegal and war criminal Occupation with massive, illegal Jews-only settlements and Jews-only roads in the Occupied West Bank. 90% of Palestine was ethnically cleansed, this rendering the “two state solution” impossible, and underscoring the reality of Israeli Apartheid recognized by global and Israeli human rights groups. In  2017, Trump America recognized all of Occupied East Jerusalem and West Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, this prompting weekly Friday demonstrations by unarmed Occupied Palestinians in the Gaza Concentration Camp (over 180 killed, and 9,200 wounded in the Great March on Return).

(3). The state of 15 million Indigenous Palestinians before the Apartheid Israel-facilitated  Occupied Palestinian Breakout from the Gaza Concentration Camp.

The  Apartheid Israeli-facilitated Occupied Palestinian Breakout from the Gaza Concentration Camp on 7 October 2023 was evidently to secure 250 Israeli hostages to bargain for 5,000 Palestinians prisoner held by Apartheid Israel  and indeed for 5.6 million Occupied Palestinian hostages of the genocidal Zionazis. Before 7 October 2023  there were about 15 million Indigenous Palestinians: (a) 5.6 million mostly impoverished  Occupied Palestinians confined under highly abusive Zionist Israeli military rule to West Bank ghettoes (3.2 million) or the Gaza Concentration Camp (2.4 million), denied all human rights [46, 47] and excluded from voting for the government ruling them (i.e. subject to egregious Apartheid ), (b) 2.1 million “lucky” Israeli Palestinians (who can vote for Zionist-vetted  candidates for the government ruling them but as Third Class citizens subject to 65 Nazi-style, race-based discriminatory laws ), and (c) 7  million mostly utterly impoverished Exiled Palestinians forbidden to return to the land continuously inhabited by their forebears  for over 4,000 years [36, 49- 51]. The ongoing, century-long Palestinian Genocide had been associated by 2023 with 2.2 million Palestinian deaths from violence, 0.1 million, or from imposed deprivation, 2.1 million, since 1916 whereas  5,000 Zionist invaders/Israelis have been killed by Palestinians since 1920 [36, 44, 52].

The Occupied Palestinians (5.6 million pre-war but as few as 4.9 million now according to expert epidemiologists [52-79] and also by National Security Agency (NSA)-advised President Donald Trump [79]) have zero human rights, live under violent  military rule, are brutally confined to small  parts of their own country, and cannot vote for the government ruling them [36]. This is egregious Apartheid as pointed out by eminent Jewish and non-Jewish commentators in South Africa and around the world [80, 81]. Before 2023  the per capita GDP was $55,500 for Apartheid Israel, $3,500 for the Occupied Palestinians, and was only $1,000  for Gazans after 16 years of blockade in which the Zionist Israelis permitted entry of carefully calculated food for bare survival. The life expectancy of Occupied Palestinians is 10 years less than that of Israelis. Apartheid Israel was violating (and still is violating) 15 major International Laws and Conventions, notably the International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid [81, 82], the Geneva Conventions [83]the Universal Declaration of Human Rights [84], the UN Conventionon the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (UN Genocide Convention)[85] and the UN Charter[36, 86].

(4). 22 months of the Gaza Urbicide, Gaza Massacre, and Gaza Genocide: Gaza demolished and 680,000  Gaza deaths from violence and imposed deprivation by 25 April 2025.

A brutally  Occupied and subjugated people (like the Occupied Palestinians for 58 years) have the right to defend themselves according to the UN Charter [86] and the Preamble to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights [84]. Conversely, Occupiers (like Apartheid Israel that has brutally and criminally subjugated Occupied Palestinians for 58 years and the Indigenous Palestinians in general for 77 years) do not have the right to defend themselves in a belligerently occupied territory.  The Occupied Palestinian Breakout from the Gaza Concentration Camp on 7 October 2023 was evidently to get 250 or so hostages to exchange for about 5,000 Occupied Palestinians imprisoned by the Zionazis (there are now about 10,000) and indeed 5.6 million Occupied Palestinians held hostage by Zionazi Apartheid Israel for 58 years [36, 48, 49].

It is now clear that Apartheid Israel knew of the planned Breakout a year in advance and by greatly delayed IDF response permitted and facilitated the Breakout from the Gaza Concentration Camp guarded by a double-layer, state-of-the-art security fence and surveillance system [87-92]. Just as Hamas was materially supported by Israeli Shin Bet and Apartheid Israel in a divide-and-rule Zionazi policy to cripple Palestinian resistance, so too the 7 October 2023 was clearly facilitated by the Zionazis to provide an “excuse” for  the subsequent genocidal atrocity (680,000 Gazans killed by violence and imposed deprivation by 25 April 2025). The Zionazis immediately declared “7 October” to be “the worst atrocity against Jews since the [Jewish] Holocaust” and “Israel’s 9/11”. Ignored by Western Mainstream media, 32 million Muslims died from violence (5 million) and imposed deprivation (27 million) in 20 countries invaded by the US Alliance after the US Government’s 9/11 false flag atrocity that killed 3,000 Americans [93, 94]. 9/11 and 7 October were described by the Americans and the Zionazis, respectively, as massive intelligence failures yet the US and Apartheid Israel lead the world in high technology intelligence acquisition and analysis .  

 On 7 October 2023 about 6,000 unarmed or lightly armed Occupied Palestinians escaped from the Gaza Concentration Camp, 1,600 were killed, and 150 were captured.  1,200 Israelis were killed (perhaps 600 of them killed in the belated IDF response involving high explosive shelling and hellfire missiles from helicopters). 97.5% of the Israelis killed (1,170) were adults and hence (because of compulsory  Jewish Israeli military service) overwhelmingly former or present members of the war criminal and Zionazi IDF occupying and abusing the Occupied Palestinian Territories including the Gaza Concentration Camp. About 2.5% of the Israeli dead (36) were children, many of whom would have been killed by high explosive fire from the responding IDF, this belying Zionazi propaganda about the Palestinians trying to exterminate Israelis on 7 October 2023 [91]. About 250 Israeli hostages were taken and these dominate the Western discussion, but ignored are the 10,000 political prisoners held by the Zionazis, this including 400 children. From 7 October 2023 to April 2025, the number of Palestinian political prisoners doubled, rising from 5,250 to nearly 10,000 [95]. 

As estimated from data published by a succession of expert epidemiologists in the leading medical journal The Lancet, 136,000 Gazans died violently by 25 April 2025 with  a “conservatively estimated” 4 times that number (544,000) dying from imposed deprivation for a shocking total of 680,000 deaths that is under-reported 10 fold by Western Mainstream media. In impoverished countries  about 70% of avoidable deaths from deprivation are those of under-5 year old infants (see Gideon Polya, “Body Count. Global avoidable mortality since 1950” that includes an avoidable mortality-related history of every country [1]). It is estimated that the 680,000 dead Gazans (28% of the pre-war Gaza population of 2.4 million) included  380,000 under-5 year old infants, 479,000 children in total, 63,000 women and 138,000 men [52-79].

Now the surviving Gazans are suffering man-made famine and mass starvation while the world looks on. This crime has been perpetrated many times in history, notably in the “forgotten” WW2 Bengali Holocaust  (WW2 Indian Holocaust, WW2 Bengal Famine; 6-7 million Indians deliberately starved to death in 1942-1945 for strategic reasons in Bengal, Bihar, Assam and Odisha by the British under fervent Zionist Winston Churchill with food-denying Australian complicity) (for details of this and some 70 other genocide and holocaust atrocities see Gideon Polya, “Jane Austen and the Black Hole of British History. Colonial rapacity, holocaust denial & the crisis in biological sustainability” [96]) .

There need to be ICC-led Nuremberg-style war crimes trials  dedicated to the trial and punishment of all those responsible for the Gaza Massacre, Gaza Genocide and Gaza Urbicide. If these ICC processes are insufficient or otherwise thwarted then People’s Tribunals  should be emplaced after the fashion of the People’s Tribunal on the Iraq War. Apartheid Israel like Zionist-perverted America rejects the authority of the  ICC and indeed rejects  some 15 major  International laws  and conventions [36]. There is a shocking list of 52 Zionist- and Apartheid Israeli-Nazi Germany comparisons [97]. Indeed it appears that the IDF and the Israeli Government have committed war crimes against Jewish Israeli  citizens by allowing and facilitating  the 7 October 2023 Palestinian Breakout from the Gaza Concentration Camp and operating under the so-called Hannibal Directive (killing Israelis to stop them becoming hostages) [90].

(5). Genocidally racist  Apartheid Israel wants all the land of Palestine (and more) but not the Indigenous inhabitants who are to be expelled, killed or confined to ghettoes or concentration camps. 

The consistent theme of the Holy Bible’s  Old Testament (The Torah of Judaism) is ethnic cleansing of Canaan (Palestine) [98]. The genocidally racist Zionists follow this obscene imperative as clearly and horribly stated by Zionist leaders from racist psychopath Theodor Herzl in the 1890s to racist psychopath Benjamin Netanyahu today [98]. Indeed today the Israelite “God” would be charged with genocide by the International Criminal Court (ICC) for advocating and ordering genocide, noting the UN Genocide Convention: “Article I. The Contracting Parties confirm that genocide, whether committed in time of peace or in time of war, is a crime under international law which they undertake to prevent and to punish. Article II: In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such : (a) Killing members of the group; (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group. Article III. The following acts shall be punishable: (a) Genocide; (b) Conspiracy to commit genocide; (c) Direct and public incitement to commit genocide; (d) Attempt to commit genocide; (e) Complicity in genocide” [85].

By way of example, Theodor Herzl (1895): “We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit counties, while denying it employment in our country. The property owners will come over to our side. Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discretely and circumspectly” [98] and Benjamin Netanyahu (1989): “Israel should have exploited the repression of the demonstrations in China, when world attention focused on that country, to carry out mass expulsions among the Arabs of the territories” [98].

A brief summary of Zionist-imposed Palestinians Genocide by the numbers [31, 35, 43, 44]:

(i) 1881 (450,000 Palestinians/25,000 Jews).

(ii). 1916 (600,000 Palestinians/60,000 Jews): mass murder by famine of 100,000-250,000 Palestinians occurred in WW1.

(iii). 1922: large Zionist immigration started

(iv). 1936 (1,000,000 Palestinians/360,000 Jews):   90% of tenant farmers were kicked out by Zionist land purchases, this leading to the Arab revolt in which 10% of adult males were killed, imprisoned or expelled by the British and British-armed Zionists.

(v). 1946 (1,270,000 Palestinians/543,000 Jews): massive immigration despite ostensible WW2 British constraints.

(vi). 1947 (1,324,000 Palestinians/630,000 Jews): British-armed and British-trained Zionist terrorists started the ethnic cleansing  of Palestine.

(vii). 1948, Nakba (Catastrophe): 800,000 Palestinians expelled, Jews seized 78% of Palestine; subsequent immigration from Western-dominated Muslim countries.

(viii). 1967, Naksa (Setback): 400,000 Arabs expelled, Jews seized all of Palestine plus parts of Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and Syria.

(ix). 2023 (before the Gaza Massacre): 5.6 million Occupied Palestinians (2.4 million Gazans, 3.2 million West Bank). 9.8 million in Apartheid Israel (7.2 million Jews, 2.1 million Palestinians , 0.5 million  others).  Jews were 46.8% of Apartheid Israel Subjects, Palestinians 50.0%.  The Zionazi killing  of 700,000 Gazans (so far) means that Jews are now 48.3% of Apartheid Israeli Subjects, and Palestinians are  now 47.6%.

The West with the exception of Trump America still dishonestly  clings to the fig-leaf of a 2-state solution that has been rendered impossible by Zionazi Israeli settlements  and is firmly rejected by US-backed and genocidally racist  Apartheid Israel that wants all the land of Palestine (plus neighbouring lands) but not the Indigenous inhabitants who are to be expelled, killed or confined to ghettoes or concentration camps.  Trump America notoriously advocated complete ethnic cleansing of the remaining 1.7 million Gazans to make way for Riviera-style luxury American real estate development [79]. 

(6). Horrific Occupied/Occupier Reprisals Death Ratios in the Zionist-imposed Gaza Genocide – terrorism is as terrorism does,  Nazism is as Nazism does.

On 7 October 2023 (Day 1 of the latest Gaza Massacre) the  Occupied/Occupier Reprisals Death Ratio was 1,600 /600 = 2.7 (assuming that the overwhelming high explosive firepower of the shells and missiles of the responding IDF was responsible for 50% of the Israeli deaths) [100]. Thus on Day 1 of the Gaza Genocide the Zionazis had already exceeded the Biblical injunction of an “life for life, eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth” by a factor of about 3. Whereas the Old Testament stated: “And if any mischief follow, then thou shalt give life for life, Eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot”( Exodus 21, 23-24),  the wonderful Jewish Palestinian humanitarian Jesus stated: “Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also” (Matthew 5, 38-39) [101].

As of 14 December 2023 (Day 70 of the Gaza Massacre), Palestinian dead in and near Gaza = 24,711 + 1,600 (fighters killed in Israel on 7 October) + 8,000 (dead in rubble) = 34,311 [100]. Conservatively assuming that the responding IDF killed half of the 1,200 Israelis who died on 7 October 2023 (i.e. 600) then the Occupied/ Occupier Reprisals Death Ratio = 34,311/ 600 = 57, nearly 3 times greater than the Occupied/ Occupier Reprisals Death Ratio of 10  ordered by Nazi leader Hitler and carried out in the 1944 Ardeatine Cave Massacre [99]). Nazism is as Nazism does.

As of 25 April 2025 (Day 570 of the Gaza Massacre) the Occupied/ Occupier Reprisals Death Ratio was 680,000/ 600 = 1,113 or over 100  times greater than the Reprisals Death Ratio ordered by Nazi mass murderer Adolph Hitler. Nazism is as Nazism does. Terrorism is as terrorism does. By 25 April 2025 the genocidally racist Zionazis have exceeded the Jewish Torah’s injunction of “life for life” by a factor of over 1,000. Applying this West-backed and  Zionazi-imposed  Reprisals Death Ratio of 1,113 to the 0.7 million Gazans killed so far would indicate Reprisal killings of 780 million, similar to the 2025 population of  NATO countries (958 million) and greater than the population of all NATO countries minus the US and Canada (571 million). Applying the relatively “modest” Nazi-advocated Reprisals Death Ratio of 10 to 0.7 million massacred Gazans would mean 7 million Reprisal Deaths, this being about the same as the number of Jewish Israeli Subjects of Apartheid Israel (7.2 million) [50]. Nazism is as Nazism does. Terrorism is as terrorism does.

And the killing continues while the World looks on and genocidally racist, Zionist-perverted and Gaza Genocide-backing Trump America vetoes any UN action.

I was a founding member of Free Palestine Melbourne that helps organize huge Sunday Rallies for Gaza that until recently were  held weekly in the Melbourne CBD since 7 October 2023 (due to Zionist pushback they are now held monthly). I have attended most of these rallies. Sometimes I see people with  placards saying that the Gaza Genocide started in 1948 and not on 7 October 2023.  I have corrected them, saying that the Gaza Genocide actually started in World War 1 (see section (2) above).  However the UN has recorded Palestinian and Israeli deaths in the violence in the Gaza Strip in the circa 16 years  of Israeli-imposed blockade of the Gaza Concentration Camp prior to 7 October 2013. In the Gaza Genocide  from 2008 to  6 October 2023  the Death Ratio from 7,077 Palestinian deaths/340 Israeli deaths was  21 [102, 103]. As of 25 April 2025 or Day 570 of the present, post-7 October 2023  Gaza Massacre  the Death Ratio was a shocking 1,113.

For decades I have been observing that while terrorists are rightly condemned  for bombing and other atrocities that kill a few to scores of people (e.g. 130 were killed in the appalling 2015 Paris atrocity), the retaliatory consequences from   such atrocities   are vastly more deadly. Thus 32 million Muslims died from violence, 5 million, and imposed deprivation, 27 million, in 20 countries invaded by the US Alliance since the US Government’s 9/11 false flag atrocity that killed about 3,000 innocent Americans [93, 94]. The Palestinian  Breakout from the Gaza Concentration Camp on 7 October 2023 was associated with 1,200 Israeli deaths of which perhaps 50% were caused by the responding IDF. If the Palestinians guessed that  they might kill about  600 Israelis in capturing 250 hostages (the evident purpose of the Breakout)  then on the basis of the previous 16 years of conflict in Gaza, they could have estimated that 21 x 600 = 12,600 Palestinians would be killed in Reprisals by the Israelis. Culpable sangfroid indeed to mount an operation that would surely kill 12,600 fellow Palestinians, albeit killed by mass murdering Zionazis. I must presume that they had no conception that their actions would have the consequences of massive demolition of densely populated, 4,000 years old and culturally super-important Gaza (the Gaza Urbicide)  and an ongoing a Gaza Genocide killing  680,000 people by 25 April 2025 (28% of the pre-war population and mostly children) with Zionist-perverted America  and Zionazi Apartheid Israel  adumbrating total ethnic cleansing of Gaza.

(7). All terrorism is evil but Western “state terrorists” are vastly more deadly than Western-declared “non-state terrorists” or indeed numerous national resistance people the genocidally racist West doesn’t like.  

 This leads us to definitions of what is a terrorist. In the post-9/11 world and indeed in the post-WW2 world, the most generally applied Western definition of a  terrorists is that of national resistance  people that the US doesn’t like. However a vastly more objective and quantitative definition of “terrorism” would necessarily include the numbers of people killed, and on that basis Western “state terrorism” is vastly more deadly and horrific than utterly repugnant “non-state terrorism” in its various manifestations.  Indeed one person’s terrorist is another person’s freedom fighter.

We have limited freedom of speech in Zionazi-perverted and US lackey Australia and so because I value my physical liberty I am extremely reluctant to comment on the specifics of US Alliance-asserted “non-state terrorism”. However by way of example,  the Zionist- and US-perverted Australian Broadcasting  Corporation (the ABC, Australia’s equivalent of the UK BBC) obtained expert legal opinions that the late and great John Pilger (Australia’s greatest journalist) would have violated Australia’s draconian anti-terrorism laws by comparing Iraqis resisting the illegal UK, US and Australian invasion and Occupation of Iraq with the heroic French Resistance fighters operating against Nazi Germany in WW2.

Below is a brief sketch of US Alliance state terrorism that is involved in the post-9-11 Muslim Holocaust, the century-long Palestinian Genocide, and the Gaza Genocide.

 US. Apart from inevitable border spats, most countries in the world have not invaded other countries. In stark contrast, as of 2023 the US has invaded 72 countries (52 since World War 2],  has committed 469 invasions from 1798 onwards, committed 251 invasions since 1991, invaded or otherwise had a military presence in all but 3 countries, and has 800 military bases in over 70 countries. Indeed there are only 3 countries that have not had US forces on their territory [104-114]. About 32 million Muslims died from violence, 5 million, and imposed deprivation, 27 million, in 20 countries invaded by the US Alliance since the US Government’s 9/11 false flag atrocity that killed 3,000 innocent Americans [115-118]. 1950 onwards US Asian wars were associated with 40 million Asian deaths from violence and imposed deprivation [1]. The US under both Biden and Trump  supplied Apartheid Israel with 69% of  its weaponry, funded the Gaza Genocide with $3.8 billion each year, supplied  the bombs and missiles to destroy Gaza and kill 680,000 Gazans, and used its veto at the UNSC to block any international action to stop the Gaza Genocide.    

UK. A genocidally racist, settler colonialist and imperialist Britain has invaded 193 countries over the last millennium [1, 113, 119]. Britain has had a long history of slavery, and genocidal colonialism in the Americas, Africa, Asia and Australia. About 1,800 million Indians died avoidably from British-imposed deprivation in the 2 centuries between the 1769-1770 Great Bengal Famine (10 million died) and the 1943-1945 WW2 Bengali Holocaust (WW2 Indian Holocaust, WW2 Bengal Famine; 6-7 million Indians deliberately starved to death for strategic reasons in Bengal, Bihar, Assam and Odisha by the British with food-denying Australian complicity) [120]. The UK was a key participant in the US War on Terror (aka the US War on Muslims) including the Iraqi Genocide (1990-2011, 5 million killed) and the Afghan Genocide (2001 -2021, 6.8 million killed) [1, 117, 118]. The UK was responsible for giving the ancient and important country of Palestine to the  genocidal Zionists, enabling mass immigration of Zionist settler colonialists and arming and training Zionist terrorists. The UK assisted Zionazi Apartheid Israel’s Gaza Genocide with overflight intelligence and US use of British bases. PM Keir Starmer’s Starmer Troops have recently been  used to arrest 500 British activists supporting non-violent Palestine Action that has been proscribed by the UK Government as a “terrorist organization”, an action that  has been described by legal experts as a dangerous shift in British  law [120].  A good peace activist friend of mine for decades, Allen Jasson, was among those arrested in this travesty of justice that threatens the civil rights and human rights of all people in Britain and consequently of all Humanity. I have told  Allen that I admire his moral courage and will use my present freedom to continually update the World about the circumstances of him and his fellow arrested peace activists. 

Germany. Germany commenced a century of genocide with the genocide of the Indigenous Hereros and Namas in South West Africa. In the 1940s genocidal German  racism was responsible for the following atrocities (deaths from violence and imposed deprivation in brackets): WW2 Sinti and Roma Holocaust (1 million), WW2 Jewish Holocaust (5-6 million), WW2 Polish Holocaust (6 million), WW2 Soviet Holocaust (23 million) and the WW2 European Holocaust (30 million) [1].  Germany gave billions of dollars in reparations for the WW2 Jewish Holocaust  to support Apartheid Israel’s remorseless Palestinian Genocide, supplied Apartheid Israel with 30% of its weapons imports, supported the US War on Muslims, suppled 5 submarines to carry Israeli nuclear weapons, fervently supports Apartheid Israel and persecutes pro-Palestinian human rights Jewish and non-Jewish Germans [121]. The post-WW2 de-Nazification of Germany was clearly insufficient.

France. France has invaded 80 countries and has a long history of slavery and genocidal colonialism in the Americas, Africa and Asia [113, 122], supplied advanced weapons systems  to Apartheid Israel, enabled Apartheid Israel to acquire nuclear weapons [123], was a key player in the post-9/11 War on Muslims in Africa [115], helped the UK devastate Libya, and fervently supports Apartheid Israel and hence the utterly vile crime of Apartheid. The pro-Apartheid Israel and hence pro-Apartheid new Vichy France soils “Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité”.  

Australia. Variously as a UK or US lackey Australia has invaded 85 countries with 30 of these invasions being genocidal [113, 124-127]. The over 2-century Australian Aboriginal Genocide was associated with 2 million Indigenous deaths from violence, dispossession, deprivation and introduced disease, the forced removal of Indigenous children from their mothers  (that is still proceeding at a record rate), and massive Aboriginal Ethnocide (of 350-700 unique languages and dialects before the British invasion in  1788 , only 120 survive with all but 20 endangered) [127]. Australia has been involved in all 1950s onwards US Asian wars (atrocities associated with 40 million Asian deaths from violence and imposed deprivation) [1]. Variously as a UK lackey, a US lackey or as one of the world’s worst climate criminals Australia has violated all 81 Indo-Pacific countries. Indeed Australians were involved in 8 US-backed Coups in the Indo-Pacific, namely Laos (1960), Indonesia (1965), Cambodia (1970), Chile (1973), Australia (1975), Fiji (1987), Fiji (2000), and Australia (2010) [134, 135]. The Australian Labor Government and the Coalition Opposition are complicit in the Gaza Genocide in 20 ways [136] and lie for Apartheid Israel in 35 ways [137-139].

 One notes that none of these state terrorist countries recognize the State of Palestine (although they have recognized the genocidally racist and serial war criminal State of Israel since 1948),  all of them are members of the anti-Arab anti-Semitic,  anti-Jewish anti-Semitic   and holocaust-ignoring International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) [128-131], all reject the absolutely vital Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) that stands between Humanity and near-total annihilation [132], are associated with nuclear terrorism, and all showed their true colours by utterly disgracefully voting No to the annual UN General Assembly anti-Nazi Resolution [133]. 

It gets worse. The carnage inflicted by the US Alliance is exhaustively analysed in my huge book “Body Count. Global avoidable mortality since 1950”  that (among many other things)  includes an avoidable mortality-related history of every country” [1], noting that elevated avoidable mortality occurs in threatened countries, occupied countries and in countries after the occupier leaves. In Chapter 3, “Correlates and causes of post-1950 avoidable global mass mortality”, I estimated 1950-2005 “avoidable deaths from deprivation” in countries variously occupied by aggressor countries in the post-WW2 era. The results for the victims of the following major occupying countries  of present interest are shocking:  Apartheid Israel (24 million),  Australia (2 million), France (142 million), the UK (727 million) and the US (82 million). In the period analysed Australia had only occupied Papua-New Guinea and the Solomon Islands as a major occupier, however as a party to all US Asian wars it has a notional share in the deaths of the 40 million Asians who died from violence and (mostly) deprivation in those US atrocities [1]. Likewise, Germany temporarily stopped killing in 1945 but as a NATO member was involved in the 2001-2021 Afghan Genocide (6.8 million Afghan deaths from violence, 0.4 million,  and deprivation, 6.4 million) [1, 96, 117, 140-142], and thus in the 32 million deaths from violence (5 million) and deprivation (27 million) in the US-imposed post-9/11 Muslim Holocaust and Muslim Genocide [1, 93, 117, 118, 142]. 

(8). From 2008-7 October 2023 inclusive the number of  Israelis murdered by fellow Israelis (2,475)  greatly exceeded the number of  Israelis killed by Occupied Palestinians (940). 

Assuming that 50% of those killed on 7 October 2023 (i.e. 600) were killed by the responding IDF then the number of Israelis killed by Occupied Palestinians (a) from 2008 to 6 October 2023 inclusive was 340 [102], and (b) from 2008-7 October  2023  2008 to 7 October 2023 inclusive  was 600 (7 October 2023) + 340 (2008 – 6 October 2023)[102] = 940.

The murder/homicide rate in Israel proper was 19.4 killed per million of population per year in 2022 [143]. The average Israeli population in the period 2003-2025 was 8.1 million [1, 50]. Accordingly the number of Israelis killed by Israelis in the period 2008 – 7 October 2023 inclusive was (19.4 per million of population per year ) x 8.1 million population x  15.75 years = 2,475. In contrast, the number of Occupied Palestinians killed in Israel in this period was 7,077 (2008-6 October 2023) [102] + 1,600 Breakout Occupied Palestinians = 8,677.

Accordingly the number of  Israelis killed by Israelis from 2008-7 October 2023 (2,475) was  (a) 7.3  times greater than the number of Israelis killed by Occupied Palestinians in the same period (940) and (b) was 3.5 times lower than the number of Occupied Palestinians killed by Israelis (excluding the West Bank) in that period [1, 50]. 

From 2008-7 October 2023 Israeli murders of fellow Israelis (2,475) vastly exceeded deaths of Israelis killed by  Occupied Palestinians (940). Following the reprisals logic of the egregiously mendacious Zionazis, why didn’t the IDF  respond to these Israeli homicides by fellow Israelis by reducing  Tel Aviv to rubble and killing 680,000 Israelis? For a similar 2017 analysis entitled “Israelis Kill Ten Times More Israelis In Apartheid Israel Than Do Terrorists” see [144].

(9). Terrorism as terrorism does.

As  previously observed, one person’s “terrorist” is another person’s “freedom fighter” or “national resistance fighter” like the WW2 French Maquis (French Resistance). A quantitative and hence more objective measure of “terrorism” would be the number of people killed by the asserted “terrorists”.   Paradoxically Apartheid Israel’s Shin Bet domestic intelligence organization covertly supported Hamas in a divide-and-rule Apartheid Israeli policy of backing division between the Islamic Hamas and the secular PLO [145]. As outlined above in section (8), in the period 2008-7 October 2023 inclusive, Israeli  deaths attributable to  Hamas totalled 940-1,500. Before the Gaza Massacre Hamas was involved  heavily in social service delivery in severely blockaded Gaza and had substantial popular support. Similarly, about 2,000 Apartheid Israeli invaders were killed by the Lebanese national resistance group Hezbollah in fighting Apartheid Israeli invaders  from 1982 onwards [146]. Hezbollah has substantial popular support in Lebanon and has numerous democratically-elected Parliamentary representatives, whereas Apartheid Israel excludes its Occupied Palestinian Subjects (5.6 million pre-war, now fewer than 5.0 million) from all human rights and voting for the government ruling them .

In stark contrast, as set out in section (8), the US, UK, Australia, France, Germany, the US Alliance and Apartheid Israel are variously complicit  in the following genocidal atrocities (deaths from violence and imposed deprivation in brackets): the Gaza Genocide (680,000 by 25 April 2025), the century-long Palestinian Genocide (2.7 million), 1950 onwards US Asian wars  (40 million) and the post-9/11 War on Terror aka US War on Muslims (32 million). It should be noted that according to world-famous Professor Jeffrey Sachs, Apartheid Israeli PM Benjamin  Netanyahu and key US warmonger Paul Wolfowitz planned the destruction of Iraq [147, 148], and former  top US General Wesley Clark revealed the US Pentagon plan to invade and devastate 7 Muslim countries, namely Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and Iran [149] (all these atrocities eventuated). 

Accordingly, if Hamas and Hezbollah can be described as “terrorists” or “non-state terrorists” over the deaths of several thousand Israeli invaders, then  the US Alliance countries including Apartheid Israel can surely be describes as “state terrorists”, over various involvements in the deaths from violence and imposed deprivation of several millions to several tens of millions of Indigenous people in Africa, the Middle East and Asia.

It is therefore appropriate to  refer to Apartheid Israel state terrorism, US state terrorism, UK state terrorism, German state terrorism, French state terrorism, Australian state terrorism and US Alliance state terrorism that are variously involved in the Gaza Genocide, the century-long Palestinian Genocide  and in the ongoing US War on Muslims that has devastated the Muslim world for decades.

The key ethos of decent Humanity is Kindness and Truth but Zionazi Apartheid Israel and the Zionist-perverted US Alliance are committed to murderous state terrorism involving  genocidal racism, egregious Orwellian mendacity and remorseless grand theft. In the Zionist-perverted UK the state terrorist Starmer Labour Government has turned reason on its head and has declared the non-violent Palestine Action group a “terrorist organization” with 500 of  those publicly supporting its peaceful aims arrested and threatened with draconian custodial punishment. In Zionazi Trump America  the best of America – its anti-racist students,  academics and universities –  are subject to threat. In Zionist-subverted and US lackey Australia the Australian Labor Government state terrorists and the Coalition Opposition state terrorists are complicit  in the Gaza Genocide in 20 ways [136], lie for Apartheid Israel in 35 ways [137, 138] and threaten civil rights and human rights with draconian “anti-terror” laws and Zionist McCarthyism [69].   

Inaction is complicity and silence is complicity. What must decent people do? Decent people must (a) inform everyone they can (Mainstream Western presstitutes certainly won’t) and (b) urge and apply Boycotts, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) against Zionazi Apartheid Israeli state terrorism and against all its US Alliance state terrorist supporters.

References.

[1]. Gideon Polya, “Body Count. Global avoidable mortality since 1950”, 2nd edition, Korsgaard Publishing, 2020.

[2]. Gideon Polya, “Climate Crisis, Climate Genocide & Solutions”,  Korsgaard Publishing, 2020.

[3]. “Ukraine”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine .  

[4]. “Euromaidan”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euromaidan .

[5]. Netherlands Government, “What is the impact of the war in Ukraine on exports of vegetable oils?”, 4 October 2022: https://www.cbi.eu/market-information/grains-pulses-oilseeds/what-impact-war-ukraine-exports-vegetable-oils .

[6]. Gideon Polya, “Ukraine War & US Killing By War & Sanctions”, Countercurrents, 26 March 2022: https://countercurrents.org/2022/03/body-count-global-avoidable-mortality-since-1950-ukraine-war-us-killing-by-war-sanctions/ .

[7]. “International sanctions during the Russian invasion of Ukraine”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_sanctions_during_the_Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine .

[8]. Marianne Stein, “How the Russian invasion of Ukraine has impacted the global wheat market”, ACES NEWS, 5 February 2024: https://aces.illinois.edu/news/how-russian-invasion-ukraine-has-impacted-global-wheat-market .

[9].Stephen Devados and William Ridley, “Impacts of the Russian invasion of Ukraine on the global wheat market”, January 2024, World Development, volume 173, 106396: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0305750X23002140?via%3Dihub .

[10]. Pjotr Sauer, “One million and counting: Russian casualties hit milestone in Ukraine war”, The Guardian, 22 June 2025: https://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2025/jun/22/one-million-and-counting-russian-casualties-hit-milestone-in-ukraine-war .

[11]. Seth G. Jones and Riley McCabe, “Russia’s Battlefield Woes in Ukraine”, CSIS, 3 June 2025: https://www.csis.org/analysis/russias-battlefield-woes-ukraine .

[12]. “Ukrainian refugee crisis”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainian_refugee_crisis .

[13]. Krzysztof Janowski, “Civilian casualties in Ukraine reach three-year high in June, UN human rights monitors say”, United Nations Ukraine, 10 July 2025: https://ukraine.un.org/en/297777-civilian-casualties-ukraine-reach-three-year-high-june-un-human-rights-monitors-say .

[14]. “History of Zionism”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Zionism .

[15]. Eliane Glaser, “Oliver Cromwell and the Jews: a correction”, The Guardian, 9 December 2005: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/dec/09/religion.uk .

[16].  Gideon Polya, “Australian Xenophobia Targets China But Ignores Huge Israeli Subversion Of Australia”, Countercurrents,  7 July 2018: https://countercurrents.org/2018/07/australian-xenophobia-targets-china-but-ignores-huge-israeli-subversion-of-australia/ .

[17]. Adam Kirsch, “Benjamin Disraeli”, Schocken, 2008.

[18]. Mark Burdman, “How Britain’s biggest racists invented Zionism”: https://archive.org/stream/HowVeniceTookOverEnglandandOtherArticlesEIRPalmerstonsZoo/How%20Britains%20Biggest%20Racists%20and%20Financiers%20Created%20Zionism%20-%20by%20Mark%20Burdman_djvu.txt .

[19]. Gideon Polya, “Charles III Coronation Ignored Imperialism, Colonialism, Genocide, Trauma, Deadly Colonial Legacy & Palestine”, Countercurrents, 9 May 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/05/charles-iii-coronation-ignored-imperialism-colonialism-genocide-trauma-deadly-colonial-legacy-palestine/ .

[20]. Frederick Treves, “The Land that is Desolate”, Smith, Elder & Co, 1913.

[21]. Theodor Herzl. “Der Judenstaat” (The Jewish State”), 1896; Chapter 2.

[22]. Nathan Birnbaum, “In Bondage to our fellow Jews”, pp1-9,  in Michael Selzer, (editor), “Zionism Reconsidered”, Macmillan, London .

[23]. Neturei Karta, Jews united against Zionism, “Orthodox Jews demand an end to Zionist arocirites in the Middle east ”: http://www.nkusa.org/activities/Statements/2006July18.cfm .

[24]. Michael Selzer, (editor), “Zionism Reconsidered”, Macmillan, London .

[25]. True Torah Jews against Zionism: http://www.jewsagainstzionism.com/about/index.cfm .

[26]. Sven Lindqvist, “Exterminate all the Brutes”, Granta Books, London, 2002.  

[27]. Leon Gettler, “An Unpromised Land”, Fremantle Arts Centre Press, Fremantle, Western Australia, 1993.

[28]. Gideon Polya, “Book review: “An Unpromised Land” by Leon Gettler” – How Australia escaped becoming Apartheid Israel”, MWC News, 8 July 2009: https://sites.google.com/site/bookreviewsbydrgideonpolya/gettler-leon .

[29]. Martin Gilbert, “Jewish History Atlas”, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1969.

[30]. Justin McCarty, “Palestine population: during the Ottoman and British mandate period”, Palestine Remembered: 8 September 2001: http://www.palestineremembered.com/Acre/Palestine-Remembered/Story559.html .

[31]. “Historic population of Israel/Palestine”: http://palestineisraelpopulation.blogspot.com/  .

[32]. Zachary J. Foster, “The 1915 Locust Attack in Syria and Palestine and its Role in the Famine During the First World War”, CAPES, volume 51, 2014: https://www.periodicos.capes.gov.br/index.php/acervo/buscador.html?task=detalhes&source=all&id=W2070476557 .  

[33]. “Demographic history of Palestine (region)”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_Palestine_(region) .

[34]. June 2022, Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East, “Demographics of Historic Palestine prior to 1948”, June 2022: https://www.cjpme.org/fs_007 .

[35]. Jewish Virtual Library, “Jewish and non-Jewish population of Israel/Palestine (1517-present)”: https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jewish-and-non-jewish-population-of-israel-palestine-1517-present .

[36]. Gideon Polya, “Australia must stop Zionist subversion and join the World in comprehensive Boycotts, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) against Apartheid Israel and all its supporters”, Subversion of Australia, 15 April 2021: https://sites.google.com/site/subversionofaustralia/2021-04-15 .

[37]. “Population of Palestine prior to 1948”, Mid-East Web: http://www.mideastweb.org/palpop.htm .

[38]. Sir Martin Gilbert, “First World War 1”, p373.

[39]. “Surafend massacre”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surafend_massacre .

[40]. Leonard Mosley, “Gideon Goes to War”, Charles Scribner, 1955.

[41]. “The Palestinian Revolt 1936-1939”, The Palestinian History Tapestry: https://www.palestinianhistorytapestry.org/tapestry/0450-kuyffiyeh-1936-arab-revolt/ .

[42]. “1936–1939 Arab revolt in Palestine”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1936%E2%80%931939_Arab_revolt_in_Palestine .

[43]. “Secular, democratic, one state Palestine”: https://sites.google.com/view/onestatepalestine/home .

[44]. “Palestinian Genocide”; https://sites.google.com/site/palestiniangenocide/ .

[45]. “1948 Nakba (Catastrophe) & Palestinian Genocide”, Palestinian Genocide: https://sites.google.com/site/palestiniangenocide/1948-nakba-catastrophe-palestinian-genocide .

[46]. Institute for Middle East Understanding, “Fact Sheet: Palestinian Citizens of Israel”, 17 March 2021: https://imeu.org/article/fact-sheet-palestinian-citizens-of-israel .

[47]. Gideon Polya, “Universal Declaration of Human Rights & Palestinians. Apartheid Israel violates ALL Palestinian Human Rights”, Palestine Genocide Essays, 24 January 2009: https://sites.google.com/site/palestinegenocideessays/universal-declaration-of-human-rights-palestinians .

[48]. “Gaza Concentration Camp”: https://sites.google.com/site/palestiniangenocide/gaza-concentration .

[49]. “Demographics of Palestine”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Palestine .

[50]. “Demographics of Israel”; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Israel .

[51]. Gideon Polya, “Jewish Israeli Gaza Urbicide Erasing The Physical Record Of 4,000 Year Gaza History”, Countercurrents, 8 January 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/01/jewish-israeli-gaza-urbicide-erasing-the-physical-record-of-4000-year-gaza-history/ .

[52]. Gideon Polya, “Free Palestine. End Apartheid Israel, Human Rights Denial, Gaza Massacre, Child Killing, Occupation and Palestinian Genocide”, Korsgaard Publishing, 2024.

[53]. Gideon Polya, “Gaza Genocide By Numbers: Apply BDS Over 0.7 Million Gaza Deaths From Violence And Imposed Deprivation”, 4 July 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/07/gaza-genocide-by-numbers-apply-bds-over-0-7-million-gaza-deaths-from-violence-and-imposed-deprivation/ .

[54]. Gideon Polya, “Mass Starvation In Gaza: World Must End Occupation, Provide Aid & Boycott US, Israel & Germany”, Countercurrents, 25 July 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/07/mass-starvation-in-gaza-world-must-end-occupation-provide-aid-boycott-us-israel-germany/ .

[55]. Gideon Polya, “Conditional recognition of Palestine mere words”, Pearls & Irritations, 6 August 2025: https://johnmenadue.com/letters_to_editor/2025/08/conditional-recognition-of-palestine-mere-words/ .

[56]. Søren Roest Korsgaard, “Quick analysis: Counting the Dead in Gaza”, Rethink Government, April, 2025: https://rethinkgovernment.com/quick-analysis-counting-the-dead-in-gaza/ .

[57]. EXPOSING THE GAZA DEATH UNDERCOUNT, BY RALPH NADER. HON. JOHN B. LARSON OF CONNECTICUT IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, Tuesday, October 1, 2024: https://www.congress.gov/118/crec/2024/10/01/170/152/CREC-2024-10-01-pt1-PgE1000-3.pdf .

[58]. Devi Sridhar, “Scientists are closing in on the true, horrifying scale of death and disease in Gaza”, The Guardian, 5 September 2024: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/sep/05/scientists-death-disease-gaza-polio-vaccinations-israel .

[59]. Gideon Polya, “For science’s sake, vote the Coalition last”, Letters, The Independent, 3 April 2025: https://independentaustralia.net/vn.php?sd=eGpJZTMyenoxOTUyNnxZWFZ6ZEhKaGJHbGhPVGt3TUVCbmJXRnBiQzVqYjIwPXw3MDN8MTY3NzY2MzkwMA ):

[60]. Gideon Polya, “The Lancet: 64,260 Gaza Violent Deaths Indicating 257,000 Indirect Deaths In 9 Months”, Countercurrents, 14 January 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/01/the-lancet-64260-gaza-violent-deaths-indicating-257000-indirect-deaths-in-9-months/ .

[61]. Zeina Jamaluddine, Hanan Abukmail, Sarah Aly, Oona M R Campbell, and Francesco Checchi, “Traumatic injury mortality in the Gaza Strip from Oct 7, 2023, to June 30, 2024: a capture–recapture analysis”, The Lancet, 9 January 2025: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(24)02678-3/fulltext .

[62]. Susan Abulhawa, “Math proves that Israel’s stated goals are an epic lie”, The Electronic Intifada, 27 June 2024: https://electronicintifada.net/content/math-proves-israels-stated-goals-are-epic-lie/47371 .

[63]. Rasha Khatib, Martin McKee and Salim Yusuf, “Counting the dead in Gaza: difficult but essential”, The Lancet, Volume 404, Issue 10449, p237-238, 10 July, 2024: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(24)01169-3/fulltext .

[64]. Gideon Polya, “Estimated 273,000 Gazans Killed In the First Year Of Oxford Union-Perceived Gaza Genocide By Apartheid Israel”, Countercurrents, 6 December 2024: https://countercurrents.org/2024/12/estimated-273000-gazans-killed-in-the-first-year-of-oxford-union-perceived-gaza-genocide-by-apartheid-israel/ .

[65]. Gideon Polya, “Stop The Killing & Occupation: Comparisons Of Jewish Israeli-Imposed Gaza Genocide Deaths With Nazi Atrocities”, Countercurrents, 12 November 2024: https://countercurrents.org/2024/11/stop-the-killing-occupation-comparisons-of-jewish-israeli-imposed-gaza-genocide-deaths-with-nazi-atrocities/ .

[66]. Richard Hil and Gideon Polya, “Skewering History: The Odious Politics of Counting Gaza’s Dead”, Arena, 11 Juloy 2025: https://arena.org.au/politics-of-counting-gazas-dead/ .

[67]. UNHCR Refworld Global Law and Policy Database, Geneva Declaration Secretariat, “Global burden of armed violence”, 2008, Chapter 2: https://www.refworld.org/reference/research/gds/2008/en/64390 .

[68]. Gideon Polya, “Zionist-Perverted Western Mainstream Media Ignore 186,000 Palestinian Deaths In Apartheid Israeli Gaza Genocide”, Countercurrents, 15 July 2024: https://countercurrents.org/2024/07/zionist-perverted-western-mainstream-media-ignore-186000-palestinian-deaths-in-apartheid-israeli-gaza-genocide/ .

[69]. Gideon Polya, “Anti-racist Jews threatened by Zionist McCarthyism” , Pearls & Irritations, 9 August 2025: https://johnmenadue.com/letters_to_editor/2025/08/anti-racist-jews-threatened-by-zionist-mccarthyism/ .

[70]. Gideon Polya, “What Mainstream Australian Media Won’t Report”, Tasmanian Times, 31 May 2025: https://tasmaniantimes.com/2025/05/what-mainstream-australian-media-wont-report/ .

[71]. “Australian Mainstream media lying and censorship”, Mainstream media lying: https://sites.google.com/site/mainstreammedialying/australian-mainstream-media-lying-censorshp .

[72]. “Racist & lying Australian Mainstream ignores awful truths”: https://sites.google.com/site/mainstreammedialying/racist-lying-australian-mainstream-ignores-awful-truths .

[73]. “Gideon Polya Countercurrents articles”: https://sites.google.com/site/palestinegenocideessays/gideon-polya-countercurrents-articles .

[74]. “Countercurrents articles by Gideon Polya”: https://sites.google.com/site/drgideonpolya/countercurrents-articles .

[75]. “Gideon Polya”: https://sites.google.com/site/drgideonpolya/home .

[76]. Mainstream media lying: https://sites.google.com/site/mainstreammedialying/home .

[77]. “Mainstream media censorship”: https://sites.google.com/site/mainstreammediacensorship/home .

[78]. Gideon Polya, “Reckoning: 553,000 Gaza Deaths From Violence & Deprivation Demand Global Sanctions & Huge Reparations”, Countercurrents, 21 January 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/01/reckoning-553000-gaza-deaths-from-violence-deprivation-demand-global-sanctions-huge-reparations/ .

[79]. Kevin Maimann, “”1.7 million” Palestinians in Gaza? Trump’s statement raises questions about death toll”, CBC, 22 February 2025: https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/trump-gaza-population-relocation-1.7457559 .

[80]. “Jews Against Racist Zionism”:https://sites.google.com/site/jewsagainstracistzionism/ .

[81]. “Non-Jews Against Racist Zionism”: https://sites.google.com/site/nonjewsagainstracistzionism/ .

[82]. “International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid”, UN, 1976: https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/documents/atrocity-crimes/Doc.10_International%20Convention%20on%20the%20Suppression%20and%20Punishment%20of%20the%20Crime%20of%20Apartheid.pdf .

[83]. “Geneva Conventions”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geneva_Conventions.

[84]. Universal Declaration of Human Rights : https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights .

[85]. UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide: https://treaties.un.org/doc/publication/unts/volume%2078/volume-78-i-1021-english.pdf .

[86]. UN Charter: https://www.un.org/en/about-us/un-charter .

[87]. Gideon Polya, “IDF Killed Israelis On 7 October Enabling 9/11-style Excuse For Gaza Genocide”, Countercurrents, 31 December 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/12/idf-killed-israelis-on-7-october-enabling-9-11-style-excuse-for-gaza-genocide/ .

[88]. Eric Tlozek, Orly Halpern and Allyson Horn, “Israeli forces accused of killing their own citizens under the ‘Hannibal Directive’ during October 7 chaos”, ABC News, 7 September 2024: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-09-07/israel-hannibal-directive-kidnap-hamas-gaza-hostages-idf/104224430 .

[89]. John Hankey, “October 7 Was An Inside Job – documentary (2024) by John Hankey #RealHistoryChannel ”, March 2024, Rumble: https://rumble.com/v4l4oqw-october-7-was-an-inside-job-documentary-2024.html .

[90]. Yaniv Kubovich, “IDF Ordered Hannibal Directive on October 7 to Prevent Hamas Taking Soldiers Captive”, Haaretz, 7 July 2024: https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-07-07/ty-article-magazine/.premium/idf-ordered-hannibal-directive-on-october-7-to-prevent-hamas-taking-soldiers-captive/00000190-89a2-d776-a3b1-fdbe45520000 .

[91]. “October 7 attacks”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_7_attacks#Name .

[92]. “Israel Knew Hamas’s Attack Plan More Than a Year Ago. A blueprint reviewed by The Times laid out the attack in detail”, New York Times, 30 November 2023: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/30/world/middleeast/israel-hamas-attack-intelligence.html .

[93]. Gideon Polya , “Paris Atrocity Context: 27 Million Muslim Avoidable Deaths From Imposed Deprivation In 20 Countries Violated By US Alliance Since 9-11”, Countercurrents, 22 November 2015: https://countercurrents.org/polya221115.htm .

[94]. “Experts: US did 9/11”: https://sites.google.com/site/expertsusdid911/ .

[95]. Mohamed A. Hussein and Mohammed Haddad, “A nation behind bars: Why has Israel imprisoned 10,000 Palestinians?”, Al Jazeera, 17 April 2025: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/4/17/a-nation-behind-bars-why-has-israel-imprisoned-10000-palestinians .

[96]. Gideon Polya, “Jane Austen and the Black Hole of British History. Colonial rapacity, holocaust denial & the crisis in biological sustainability”, 3rd edition, Korsgaard Publishing, 2022.

[97]. Gideon Polya, “A Shocking List of 52 Zionist- & Apartheid Israeli-Nazi Germany Comparisons”, Countercurrents, 7 August 2021: https://countercurrents.org/2021/08/a-shocking-list-of-52-zionist-apartheid-israeli-nazi-germany-comparisons/ .

[98]. “Zionist quotes re racism and Palestinian Genocide”: https://sites.google.com/site/palestiniangenocide/zionist-quotes .

[99]. “Ardeatine massacre”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ardeatine_massacre .

[100]. Gideon Polya, “Comparing Gaza Genocide & Other Atrocities: Ceasefire Now, End Occupation Now & Boycott Israel & US Alliance”, Countercurrents, 20 December 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/12/comparing-gaza-genocide-other-atrocities-ceasefire-now-end-occupation-now-boycott-israel-us-alliance/ .

[101]. “The Holy Bible., King James Version.

[102]. OCHO (United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs), “Data on casualties”: https://www.ochaopt.org/data/casualties .

[103]. Gideon Polya, “Occupied/Occupier Reprisals Death Ratios: Nazi-style Genocidal Racism Of US, UK, Australia & Apartheid Israel”, Countercurrents, 3 October 2024: https://countercurrents.org/2024/10/occupied-occupier-reprisals-death-ratios-nazi-style-genocidal-racism-of-us-uk-australia-apartheid-israel/ .

[104]. Dr Zoltan Grossman, “From Wounded Knee to Libya : a century of U.S. military interventions”, ” http://academic.evergreen.edu/g/grossmaz/interventions.html . .

[105]. Benjamin Norton, “US launched 251 military interventions since 1991, and 469 since 1798”, Multipolista, 13 September 2022: https://multipolarista.com/2022/09/13/us-251-military-interventions-1991/ .

[106]. Congressional Research Service, “Instances of use of United States armed forces abroad, 1798-2022”, 22 March 2022: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R42738 .

[107]. “World Population Review, “How many countries has the US invaded as of 2023”: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/how-many-countries-has-the-us-invaded .

[108]. Blake Stillwell, “These are the only 3 countries America hasn’t invaded [Andorra, Bhutan and Liechtenstein]”, We are the mighty: https://www.wearethemighty.com/popular/countries-america-hasnt-invaded/ .

[109]. Christopher Kelly and Stuart Laycock, “America Invades: How We’ve Invaded Or Been Militarily Involved With Almost Every Country on Earth”, Book Publishers Network, 2015.

[110]. Gideon Polya , “Why Australia Should Quit Military Links With Serial War Criminal America”, Countercurrents, 28 January 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/01/why-australia-should-quit-military-links-with-serial-war-criminal-america/ .

[111]. David Vine, “Where in the world is the U.S. military?”, Politico, July/August 2015: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/06/us-military-bases-around-the-world-119321/ .

[112]. William Blum, “Rogue State: A Guide to the World’s Only Superpower”, Common Courage Press, 2005.

[113]. “Stop state terrorism”: https://sites.google.com/site/stopstateterrorism/ .

[114]. Gideon Polya, “The US Has Invaded 70 Nations Since 1776 – Make 4 July Independence From America Day”, Countercurrents, 5 July, 2013: http://www.countercurrents.org/polya050713.htm ;

[115]. Cihan Aksan and Jon Bailes, “Weapon of the Strong: Conversations on US State Terrorism”, Pluto Press, 2013.

[116]. William Blum , “Overthrowing other people’s governments: The Master List”: https://williamblum.org/essays/read/overthrowing-other-peoples-governments-the-master-list .

[117]. Gideon Polya, “US-imposed Post-9/11 Muslim Holocaust & Muslim Genocide:, Korsgaard Publishing, 2020.

[118]. Gideon Polya in Soren Korsgaard, editor, “The Most Dangerous Book Ever Published: Deadly Deception Exposed”, Korsgaard Publishing, 2020.

[119]. Gideon Polya, “British Have Invaded 193 Countries: Make 26 January ( Australia Day, Invasion Day) British Invasion Day”, Countercurrents, 23 January, 2015: http://www.countercurrents.org/polya230115.htm ;

[120]. Gideon Polya, “Jane Austen and the Black Hole of British History”, 3rd edition, Korsgaard Publishing, 2022.

[121]. Anne McMillan, “Proscription of Palestine Action ‘a dangerous shift in the law’”, International Bar Association, 12 August 2025: https://www.ibanet.org/Proscription-of-Palestine-Action-a-dangerous-shift-in-the-law .

[122]. Gideon Polya, “President Hollande And French Invasion Of Privacy Versus French Invasion Of 80 Countries Since 800 AD”, Countercurrents, 15 January, 2014: https://www.countercurrents.org/polya150114.htm .

[123]. Gideon Polya, “Apartheid Israel Buries Serial War Criminal, Genocidal Racist And Nuclear Terrorist Shimon Peres”, Countercurrents, 1 October 2016: https://countercurrents.org/2016/10/apartheid-israel-buries-serial-war-criminal-genocidal-racist-and-nuclear-terrorist-shimon-peres/ .

[124]. Gideon Polya, “As UK Lackeys Or US Lackeys Australians Have Invaded 85 Countries (British 193, French 80, US 70)”, Countercurrents, 9 February, 2015: http://www.countercurrents.org/polya090215.htm ;

[125]. Gideon Polya, “Review: “The Big Fix” By Albert Palazzo: Why Australia Should Quit AUKUS & Spurn Genocidal US”, Countercurrents, 3 August 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/08/review-the-big-fix-by-albert-palazzo-why-australia-should-quit-aukus-spurn-genocidal-us/ .

[126].Gideon Polya, “Review: “The Cambridge History Of Australia” Ignores Australian Involvement In 30 Genocides”, Countercurrents, 14 October 2013: https://countercurrents.org/polya141013.htm .

[127]. “Aboriginal Genocide”: https://sites.google.com/site/aboriginalgenocide/home .

[128]. Gideon Polya, “IHRA Letter To Australian Labor MPs Exposes Australian Crimes & IHRA Anti-Semitism”, Countercurrents, 9 October 2021: https://countercurrents.org/2021/10/letter-to-australian-labor-mps-exposes-australian-crimes-ihra-anti-semitism/ .

[129]. Gideon Polya, “30 Ways Anti-Jewish Anti-Semitism Against Anti-Racist Jews Entrenched In Australia & West”, Countercurrents, 23 July 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/07/30-ways-anti-jewish-anti-semitism-against-anti-racist-jews-entrenched-in-australia-west/ .

[130]. Gideon Polya, “Melbourne University Adopts Anti-Semitic & Holocaust-Ignoring IHRA Definition Of Anti-Semitism”, Countercurrents, 5 February 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/02/melbourne-university-adopts-anti-semitic-holocaust-ignoring-ihra-definition-of-anti-semitism/ .

[131]. Jewish Voices for Peace, “First ever: 40+ Jewish groups worldwide oppose equating antisemitism with criticism of Israel”, 17 July 2018: https://jewishvoiceforpeace.org/first-ever-40-jewish-groups-worldwide-oppose-equating-antisemitism-with-criticism-of-israel/#english .

[132]. Gideon Polya, “Zionist-Subverted, US Lackey Australia Rejects TPNW, Backs US, UK & Israeli Nuclear Terrorism”, Countercurrents, 8 November 2022: https://countercurrents.org/2022/11/zionist-subverted-us-lackey-australia-rejects-tpnw- .

[133]. “Why France and 51 other countries voted against UN resolution condemning Nazism”, Le Monde, 9 November 2022: https://www.lemonde.fr/en/les-decodeurs/article/2022/11/09/why-france-and-51-other-countries-voted-against-the-un-resolution-condemning-nazism_6003471_8.html .

[134]. Gideon Polya, “AUKUS & Quad In Context: Australia Violates All Indo-Pacific countries”, Countercurrents, 9 December 2021: https://countercurrents.org/2021/12/aukus-quad-in-context-australia-violates-all-indo-pacific-countries/ .

[135]. Gideon Polya, “Australia violates all Indo-Pacific countries”, Stop state terrorism, 9 December 2021: https://sites.google.com/site/stopstateterrorism/2021-12-09-australia-violates-all-indo-pacific-countries .

[136]. Gideon Polya, “20 Ways Anti-Semitic Australian Labor Government Complicit In Jewish Israeli Gaza Genocide”, Countercurrents, 5 March 2024: https://countercurrents.org/2024/03/20-ways-anti-semitic-australian-labor-government-complicit-in-jewish-israeli-gaza-genocide/ .

[137]. Gideon Polya, “35 Zionist Media Lies, the Killing of Children, Neo-Nazi Apartheid Israel”, Global Research, 24 November 2023: https://www.globalresearch.ca/35-zionist-lies-child-killing-neo-nazi-apartheid-israel/5841145 .

[138]. Gideon Polya, “Gaza Massacre: 35 Ways Zionist-perverted US, Australia & West Lie For Child-killing, Neo-Nazi Apartheid Israel”, Countercurrents, 23 November 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/11/gaza-massacre-35-ways-zionist-perverted-us-australia-west-lie-for-child-killing-neo-nazi-apartheid-israel/ .

[139]. Gideon Polya, “Bear witness: Remembering heroic Anas al-Sharif”, Pearls & Irritations, 13 August 2025: https://johnmenadue.com/letters_to_editor/2025/08/bear-witness-remembering-heroic-anas-al-sharif/ .

[140]. Gideon Polya, “Afghan Holocaust – The Awful Truth Versus US Alliance Lies”, Countercurrents, 22 August 2021: https://countercurrents.org/2021/08/afghan-holocaust-the-awful-truth-versus-us-alliance-lies/ .

[141]. “Report Genocide”: https://sites.google.com/site/reportgenocide/.

[142]. Gideon Polya, “Racist Mainstream Ignores “US-Imposed Post-9/11 Muslim Holocaust & Muslim Genocide””, Countercurrents, 17 July 2020: https://countercurrents.org/2020/07/racist-mainstream-ignores-us-imposed-post-9-11-muslim-holocaust-muslim-genocide/ .

[143]. “Israel murder/homicide rate”, Macrotrends: https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/isr/israel/murder-homicide-rate#:~:text=Israel%20murder/homicide%20rate%20per,a%2011.79%25%20increase%20from%202018. .

[144]. Gideon Polya, “Israelis Kill Ten Times More Israelis In Apartheid Israel Than Do Terrorists”, Countercurrents, 1 March 2017: https://countercurrents.org/2017/03/israelis-kill-ten-times-more-israelis-in-apartheid-israel-than-do-terrorists/ .

[145]. “Hamas”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas .

[146]. “Hezbollah–Israel conflict”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah%E2%80%93Israel_conflict .

[147]. Gideon Polya, “Why Cowardly & Racist Australian Labor Government Won’t Apply Sanctions To Genocidal Apartheid Israel”, Countercurrents. 27 May 2025: https://countercurrents.org/2025/05/why-cowardly-racist-australian-labor-government-wont-apply-sanctions-to-genocidal-apartheid-israel/ .

[148]. Jeffrey Sachs, “TRANSCRIPT: Jeffrey Sachs on the Geopolitics of Peace in the European Parliament”, 22 February 2025: https://singjupost.com/transcript-jeffrey-sachs-on-the-geopolitics-of-peace-in-the-european-parliament/ .

[149]. “Wesley Clark”, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wesley_Clark .

Dr Gideon Polya taught science students at La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia over 4 decades.

15 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

The Accursed Fate of Palestinians in Israeli Prisons

By Vijay Prashad 

It was astonishing to read about the death of Ahmad Saeed Tazazaa (20 years old) on 3 August 2025 inside Israel’s Magiddo prison. Just months earlier , reports emerged that Israeli forces  had killed another Palestinian prisoner in Megiddo, Walid Khaled Abdullah Ahmad (16 years old), on 24 March. Both young men,  boys really, had been picked up from the West Bank; Ahmad from Jenin and Walid from Silwad. Initially, the Israelis remained silent about the death of Walid but later  consented to an autopsy.

The report is painful. The post-mortem of Walid revealed that he had suffered from extreme body muscle and fat wasting, air collections in his chest and abdomen (‘likely caused by blunt trauma’), and there was evidence of oedema and congestion in his large intestine (‘consistent with traumatic injury’). The autopsy confirmed that he died because of starvation and beatings by Israeli prison guards.

Khaled Ahmed, Walid’s father, recalled that his son was not only a top student, but also the highest scorer in his local football team. ‘Walid was preparing to join the Palestinian national team,’ said Khaled. Walid  was killed three days before Suleiman al-Obeid, known as the “Palestinian Pele”, was killed by Israeli fire while waiting in line to get food for his family in Gaza. In just a few days, football lost two of its brightest stars  to the Israeli genocide.

Today, 10,800 Palestinian political detainees and political prisoners languish in Israeli jails. Since 1967, 320  political prisoners have died inside Israeli prisons. On 12 August 2025, the Palestinian Prisoners’ Society published a report detailing  the state of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails. The report is painful to read because of the harsh conditions described. The Society notes that the Israeli prison administration ‘in a systematic and planned manner’ has ‘deprived prisoners of their humanity’ to the point of causing them ‘physical and psychological exhaustion, which may end in their martyrdom’. The three words they used  to describe the overall situation are ‘torture’, ‘starvation’, and ‘cruelty’. Since October 2023, 76Palestinian prisoners have died in custody.

Electric Shocks

Over 2000  Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces  at  food distribution points. With those numbers in mind, it is difficult to truly comprehend  what is happening to the Palestinians in Israeli prisons. Yet, this brutality must be  understood within a broader context, which is Israel’s shredding of the Oslo Accord.

Israel is conducting ethnic cleansing in Gaza through genocidal bombing, bulldozing Palestinian villages and towns in the West Bank, encouraging the settlement of that land with Israelis, and forcibly seizing all of Jerusalem. The bombing of Gaza continues, and in the  West Bank and Jerusalem, the Israelis are arresting the political leadership of the resistance and torturing them in their prisons. The bombing in Gaza and the arrests in the West Bank and Jerusalem are therefore part of the annulment of the Oslo Accords.

The Palestinian Commission of Detainees and Ex-Detainees Affairs released a chilling report on the torture of Palestinians by Israeli forces in Gilboa Prison in northern Israel. The Israeli prison guards storm the cells to conduct inspections, restrain detainees, take them to the prison yard, and then beat them, insult them, and subject them to electric shocks. They are then taken to the showers, drenched in water, and then shocked again. A lawyer from the Commission recounts the situation, ‘the electric shocks are administered using specialized stun guns, which are also wielded as weapons to strike detainees on the head. Being made of solid metal, they cause deep wounds, leaving many detainees bleeding, while guards mock and laugh at them. The level of torture is so severe that numerous detainees lose consciousness’. The use of this violence is intended not only for the detainees to blackout, but for them to also lose their sense of self and be totally deprived of basic sanity. Raed Abu al-Hummus, the Palestinian Commission’s head, said, ‘The goal is clear: to wear them down emotionally, to push them into a state of psychological collapse. This is not isolated. It’s part of an intensifying Israeli policy inside prisons’.

If the political leadership of Palestine has had their sense of self broken, the political formations of resistance will suffer. The electric shocks, therefore, are as brutal as the bombs dropped on hungry civilians  in Gaza: both are intended by the Israelis to crush any Palestinian resistance to the occupation of their lands.

Magiddo prison, one of the worst Israeli prisons amongst a range of terrible prisons, holds special isolation sections for senior Palestinian political leaders such as Marwan Barghouti and Ahmad Sa’adat. Marwan Barghouti (born 1959) is a major leader in Fatah who was arrested during the Second Intifada, and has been in prison for twenty-three years and four months. The Inter-Parliamentary Union found that his treatment at arrest ‘precluded any possibility of a fair trial’ and that he should not be held as he is. During the past few years, Barghouti was beaten in his cell till his ribs broke. The attempt to break his spirit continues unabated. Ahmad Sa’adat (born 1953), Secretary General of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) has been in prison for twenty-three years and three months – one month less than Barghouti. He had initially been arrested by the Palestinian Authority and held in Jericho Prison, where the Israelis illegally seized him and brought him to Magiddo. The point of capturing and holding these leaders for long periods of time is to prevent the development of a focal point in Palestinian society that would revitalise Palestinian politics. This is what the Israeli political theorist Baruch Kimmerling calls politicide, the death of politics. Israel is not only killing Palestinians to seize the land, but they are killing the possibility of Palestinian politics.

Politicide

What is remarkable about groups such as the Palestinian Prisoners’ Society, Addameer: Prisoners Support and Human Rights Association, and Al-Haq: Defending Human Rights is that they have continuously stood with Palestinian political prisoners and not allowed their resistance to be forgotten or diminished. In October 2021, the Israelis outlawed six Palestinian groups – Addameer, Al-Haq, Bisan Centre for Research and Development, Defence for Children International-Palestine, the Union of Agricultural Work Committees, and the Union of Palestinian Women’s Committees. The Israelis accused these groups of being in contact with the PFLP. In November 2021, the Israeli military commander of the West Bank declared these organisations to be ‘unlawful associations’. This takes politicide to another level. Now, not only are the political groups – such as PFLP – treated as terrorist groups, but even organisations that speak for the prisoners are outlawed.

Ahmad Saeed Tazazaa was a young man who deserved to live a full and long life. In September 2024, he was arrested in his home in Qabatiya. The Israelis invaded his  city in the northern part of the West Bank,went to a house and threw Palestinians off the third floor. Ahmad was arrested, brought to Magiddo, tortured, and then killed. The way that they treated him in prison was even more brutal than the way they threw his fellow Palestinians off the third floor.

Vijay Prashad is an Indian historian, editor, and journalist. He is a writing fellow and chief correspondent at Globetrotter.

14 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

Israel’s Plan For ‘Full Control’ of Gaza Heralds A New Nakba – So The West Is Panicking

By Jonathan Cook

Netanyahu’s mass ethnic cleansing strategy pulls the rug out from under their cherished pretext for supporting Israeli criminality: the fabled two-state solution.

If you thought western capitals were finally losing patience with Israel’s engineering of a famine in Gaza nearly two years into the genocide, you may be disappointed.

As ever, events have moved on – even if the extreme hunger and malnourishment of the two million people of Gaza have not abated.

Western leaders are now expressing “outrage”, as the media call it, at Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s plan to “take full control” of Gaza and “occupy” it. At some point in the future, Israel is apparently ready to hand the enclave over to outside forces unconnected to the Palestinan people. 

The Israeli cabinet agreed last Friday on the first step: a takeover of Gaza City, where hundreds of thousands of Palestinians are huddled in the ruins, being starved to death. The city will be encircled, systematically depopulated and destroyed, with survivors presumably herded southwards to a “humanitarian city” – Israel’s new term for a concentration camp – where they will be penned up, awaiting death or expulsion. 

At the weekend, foreign ministers from the UK, Germany, Italy, Australia and other western nations issued a joint statement decrying the move, warning it would “aggravate the catastrophic humanitarian situation, endanger the lives of the hostages, and further risk the mass displacement of civilians”.

Germany, Israel’s most fervent backer in Europe and its second-biggest arms supplier, is apparently so dismayed that it has vowed to “suspend” – that is, delay – weapons  shipments that have helped Israel to murder and maim hundreds of thousands of Palestinians over the past 22 months. 

Netanyahu is not likely to be too perturbed. Doubtless, Washington will step in and pick up any slack for its main client state in the oil-rich Middle East.

Meanwhile, Netanyahu has once again shifted the West’s all-too-belated focus on the indisputable proof of Israel’s ongoing genocidal actions – evidenced by Gaza’s skeletal children – to an entirely different story.

Now, the front pages are all about the Israeli prime minister’s strategy in launching another “ground operation”, how much pushback he is getting from his military commanders, what the implications will be for the Israelis still held captive in the enclave, whether the Israeli army is now overstretched, and whether Hamas can ever be “defeated” and the enclave “demilitarised”.

We are returning once again to logistical analyses of the genocide – analyses whose premises ignore the genocide itself. Might that not be integral to Netanyahu’s strategy?

Life and death

It ought to be shocking that Germany has been provoked into stopping its arming of Israel – assuming it follows through – not because of months of images of Gaza’s skin-and-bones children that echo those from Auschwitz, but only because Israel has declared that it wants to “take control” of Gaza. 

It should be noted, of course, that Israel never stopped controlling Gaza and the rest of the Palestinian territories – in contravention of the fundamentals of international law, as the International Court of Justice ruled last year. Israel has had absolute control over the lives and deaths of Gaza’s people every day since its occupation of the tiny coastal enclave many decades ago. 

But on 7 October 2023, thousands of Palestinian fighters briefly broke out of the besieged prison camp they and their families had endured after Israel momentarily dropped its guard. 

Gaza has long been a prison that the Israeli military illegally controlled by land, sea and air, determining who could enter and leave. It kept Gaza’s economy throttled, and put the enclave’s population “on a diet” that saw rocketing malnourishment among its children long before the current starvation campaign. 

Trapped behind a highly militarised fence since the early 1990s, unable to access their own coastal waters, and with Israeli drones constantly surveilling them and raining down death from the air, the people of Gaza viewed it more as a modernised concentration camp. 

But Germany and the rest of the West were fine supporting all that. They have continued selling Israel arms, providing it with special trading status, and offering diplomatic cover. 

Only as Israel carries through to a logical conclusion its settler-colonial agenda of replacing the native Palestinian people with Jews, is it apparently time for the West to vent its rhetorical “outrage”. 

Two-state trickery

Why the pushback now? In part, it is because Netanyahu is pulling the rug out from under their cherished, decades-long pretext for supporting Israel’s ever-greater criminality: the fabled two-state solution. Israel conspired in that trickery with the signing of the Oslo Accords in the mid-1990s. 

The goal was never the realisation of a two-state solution. Rather, Oslo created a “diplomatic horizon” for “final status issues” – which, like the physical horizon, always remained equally distant, however much ostensible movement there was on the ground.

Lisa Nandy, Britain’s culture secretary, peddled precisely this same deceit last week as she extolled the virtues of the two-state solution. She told Sky News: “Our message to the Palestinian people is very, very clear: There is hope on the horizon.” 

Every Palestinian understood her real message, which could be paraphrased as: “We’ve lied to you about a Palestinian state for decades, and we’ve allowed a genocide to unfold before the world’s eyes for the past two years. But hey, trust us this time. We’re on your side.”

In truth, the promise of Palestinian statehood was always treated by the West as little more than a threat – and one directed at Palestinian leaders. Palestinian officials must be more obedient, quieter. They had to first prove their willingness to police Israel’s occupation on Israel’s behalf by repressing their own people. 

Hamas, of course, failed that test in Gaza. But Mahmoud Abbas, head of the Palestinian Authority (PA) in the occupied West Bank, bent over backwards to reassure his examiners, casting as “sacred” his lightly armed security forces’ so-called “cooperation” with Israel. In reality, they are there to do its dirty work. 

Nonetheless, despite the PA’s endless good behaviour, Israel has continued to expel ordinary Palestinians from their land, then steal that land – which was supposed to form the basis of a Palestinian state – and hand it over to extremist Jewish settlers backed by the Israeli army.

Former US President Barack Obama briefly and feebly tried to halt what the West misleadingly calls Jewish “settlement expansion” – in reality, the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians – but rolled over at the first sign of intransigence from Netanyahu. 

Israel has stepped up the process of ethnic cleansing in the occupied West Bank even more aggressively over the past two years, while global attention has been on Gaza – with the Israeli newspaper Haaretz warning this week that settlers had been given “free rein”.

A small window into the impunity granted to settlers as they wage their campaign of violence to depopulate Palestinian communities was highlighted at the weekend, when B’Tselem  released footage of a Palestinian activist, Awdah Hathaleen, inadvertently filming his own killing. 

Extremist settler Yinon Levi was released on grounds of self-defence, even though the video shows him singling out Hathaleen from afar, taking aim and shooting.

Alibi gone

It is noticeable that, having stopped making reference to Palestinian statehood for many years, western leaders have revived their interest only now – as Israel is making a two-state solution unrealisable.

That was graphically illustrated by footage broadcast this month by ITV. Shot from an aid plane, it showed the wholesale destruction of Gaza – its homes, schools, hospitals, universities, bakeries, shops, mosques and churches gone. 

Gaza is in ruins. Its reconstruction will take decades. Occupied East Jerusalem and its holy sites were long ago seized and Judaised by Israel, with western assent. 

Suddenly, western capitals are noticing that the last remnants of the proposed Palestinian state are about to be swallowed whole by Israel, too. Germany recently warned Israel that it must not take “any further steps toward annexing the West Bank”.

US President Donald Trump is on his own path. But this is the moment when other major western powers – led by France, Britain and Canada – have started threatening to recognise a Palestinian state, even as the possibility of such a state has been obliterated by Israel.

Australia announced it would join them this week after its foreign minister, a few days earlier, said the quiet part out loud, warning: “There is a risk there will be no Palestine left to recognise if the international community don’t move to create that pathway to a two-state solution.”

That is something they dare not countenance, because with it goes their alibi for supporting all these years the apartheid state of Israel, now deep into the final stages of a genocide in Gaza.

That was why British Prime Minister Keir Starmer desperately switched tack recently. Instead of dangling recognition of Palestinian statehood as a carrot encouraging Palestinians to be more obedient – British policy for decades – he wielded it as a threat, and a largely hollow one, against Israel. 

He would recognise a Palestinian state if Israel refused to agree to a ceasefire in Gaza and proceeded with the West Bank’s annexation. In other words, Starmer backed recognising a state of Palestine – after Israel has gone ahead with its complete erasure. 

Extracting concessions 

Still, France and Britain’s recognition threat is not simply too late. It serves two other purposes. 

Firstly, it provides a new alibi for inaction. There are plenty of far more effective ways for the West to halt Israel’s genocide. Western capitals could embargo arms sales, stop intelligence sharing, impose economic sanctions, sever ties with Israeli institutions, expel Israeli ambassadors, and downgrade diplomatic relations. They are choosing to do none of those things.    

And secondly, recognition is designed to extract from the Palestinians “concessions” that will make them even more vulnerable to Israeli violence.

According to France’s foreign affairs minister, Jean-Noel Barrot: “Recognising a State of Palestine today means standing with the Palestinians who have chosen non-violence, who have renounced terrorism, and are prepared to recognise Israel.”

In other words, in the West’s view, the “good Palestinians” are those who recognise and lay down before the state committing genocide against them.    

Western leaders have long envisioned a Palestinian state only on condition that it is demilitarised. Recognition this time is premised on Hamas agreeing to disarm and its departure from Gaza, leaving Abbas to take on the enclave and presumably continue the “sacred” mission of “cooperating” with a genocidal Israeli army. 

As part of the price for recognition, all 22 members of the Arab League publicly condemned Hamas and demanded its removal from Gaza.

Boot on Gaza’s neck 

How does all of this fit with Netanyahu’s “ground offensive”? Israel isn’t “taking over” Gaza, as he claims. Its boot has been on the enclave’s neck for decades.

While western capitals contemplate a two-state solution, Israel is preparing a final mass ethnic cleansing campaign in Gaza.

Starmer’s government, for one, knew this was coming. Flight data shows that the UK has been constantly operating surveillance missions over Gaza on Israel’s behalf from the Royal Air Force base Akrotiri on Cyprus. Downing Street has been following the enclave’s erasure step by step.

Netanyahu’s plan is to encircle, besiege and bomb the last remaining populated areas in northern and central Gaza, and drive Palestinians towards a giant holding pen – misnamed a “humanitarian city” – alongside the enclave’s short border with Egypt. Israel will then probably employ the same contractors it has been using elsewhere in Gaza to go street to street to  bulldoze or blow up any surviving buildings. 

The next stage, given the trajectory of the last two years, is not difficult to predict. Locked up in their dystopian “humanitarian city”, the people of Gaza will continue to be starved and bombed whenever Israel claims it has identified a Hamas fighter in their midst, until Egypt or other Arab states can be persuaded to take them in, as a further “humanitarian” gesture. 

Then, the only matter to be settled will be what happens to the real estate: build some version of Trump’s gleaming “Riviera” scheme, or construct another tawdry patchwork of Jewish settlements of the kind envisioned by Netanyahu’s openly fascist allies, Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben Gvir. 

There is a well-established template to be drawn on, one that was used in 1948 during Israel’s violent creation. Palestinians were driven from their cities and villages, in what was then called Palestine, across the borders into neighbouring states. The new state of Israel, backed by western powers, then set about methodically destroying every home in those hundreds of villages. 

Over subsequent years, they were landscaped either with forests or exclusive Jewish communities, often engaged in farming, to make Palestinian return impossible and stifle any memory of Israel’s crimes. Generations of western politicians, intellectuals and cultural figures have celebrated all of this. 

Former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson and former Austrian President Heinz Fischer are among those who went to Israel in their youth to work on these farming communities. Most came back as emissaries for a Jewish state built on the ruins of a Palestinian homeland.

An emptied Gaza can be similarly re-landscaped. But it is much harder to imagine that this time the world will forget or forgive the crimes committed by Israel – or those who enabled them.

Jonathan Cook is a British independent journalist, who has covered issues of Palestine and Israel for much of his over 20-year career.

15 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

In a letter to EU foreign ministers, Euro-Med Monitor urges pressure on Israel to end starvation in Gaza

By Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor 

Geneva – EU states must urgently pressure Israel to halt the genocide in the Gaza Strip, including all its tools, most notably the starvation policy that has killed hundreds of civilians in recent weeks.

In a letter to the foreign ministers of 18 EU states, including France, Italy, Sweden, Hungary, and Austria, Euro-Med Monitor outlined the catastrophic humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip, more than 22 months after Israel began its genocide in the enclave.

More than 60,000 Palestinians have been killed, including at least 18,500 children, with estimates suggesting the total number of direct and indirect victims exceeds 80,000. Over 145,000 have been injured, and approximately 11,000 remain missing.

Israel has destroyed the basic pillars of life in the Gaza Strip, including health, education, and livelihood systems. It has deliberately cut off food and water supplies as part of a systematic policy to inflict maximum suffering on the population, a fact publicly acknowledged by senior Israeli officials.

Starvation has been a central weapon in this campaign, with Israel deliberately blocking humanitarian aid, destroying farmland, warehouses, and bakeries, cutting off fuel for food production, and demolishing water infrastructure, driving the population toward widespread famine.

The tightening of the blockade since March 2025, combined with the prevention of essential supplies, has caused severe famine and malnutrition. At least 162 Palestinians, including 92 children, have died of starvation, and over 20,000 children have been hospitalised with severe malnutrition, while many mothers are left with only water to feed their infants.

Euro-Med Monitor further noted that the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), backed by the United States and Israel, served merely as a cover for a policy of starvation. Its four aid distribution centres became killing zones, where 1,568 Palestinians were killed and about 5,000 injured while trying to access food between late May and early August.

Restrictions on aid access have left thousands of families, particularly those with disabilities or without a breadwinner, completely deprived of assistance, while the food distributed is nutritionally inadequate and lacks essential items such as baby formula.

Israeli claims of easing humanitarian restrictions have not altered the reality on the ground, as UN data shows that less than half of scheduled aid movements have been fully facilitated, while the blockade and the core policy of deprivation remain in place.

Regarding airdrops, including those by European countries, Euro-Med Monitor stated in the letter that they are insufficient, uncoordinated, and meet only a fraction of the needs. Some have even caused deaths and injuries, underscoring that the only viable solution is to restore UN-supervised humanitarian land corridors as the most effective and safe means of delivering aid.

Statements by Israeli officials since the start of the genocide, notably former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant’s declaration of “a complete siege on the Gaza Strip” and the denial of food and water, reflect a declared policy of starvation. This constitutes a war crime, a crime against humanity, and even genocide, as confirmed by the International Court of Justice in January 2024.

Relevant EU states must cease supporting, facilitating, or legitimising Israeli crimes, and work to impose economic, diplomatic, and military sanctions, including a total ban on arms exports and imports, suspension of military cooperation, freezing the assets of implicated Israeli officials, imposing travel bans on them, and suspending trade privileges and bilateral agreements that benefit the Israeli economy.

Euro-Med Monitor urges EU states to support the International Criminal Court’s prosecution of Israeli officials, open domestic investigations into European citizens implicated in crimes against Palestinians, help end the blockade and illegal Israeli presence in the occupied Palestinian territory and ensure the unconditional reconstruction of Gaza’s infrastructure and housing.

Halting the full-scale genocide unfolding in Gaza demands unwavering global solidarity and decisive action. Euro-Med Monitor calls on EU states to stand on the right side of history, support the Palestinian people’s right to liberation and self-determination, and bring “one of the darkest chapters in modern history” to an end.

Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor is a Geneva-based independent organization with regional offices across the MENA region and Europe

15 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

Has Israel Begun Its Plan to Occupy Gaza City?

By Quds News Network

Gaza (Quds News Network)- Israeli forces have carried out a days-long intensive assault on Zeitoun, one of Gaza City’s largest neighbourhoods, destroying more than 300 homes in the past three days, according to reports citing Gaza’s Civil Defence.

The neighbourhood has faced continuous bombardment and demolitions since Tuesday.

Civil Defence officials said entire families were killed when their homes were blown up without warning using high-explosive bombs that also levelled surrounding buildings.

They added that rescue crews have been blocked from reaching the wounded or recovering bodies, worsening the humanitarian situation.

Mahmoud Basal, spokesperson for Gaza’s Civil Defence, stated on Wednesday:

“A catastrophic reality is unfolding in Gaza City. The city is under intense and relentless Israeli bombardment. High-rise buildings are being targeted, even though civilians remain inside.”

Israel’s security cabinet last week approved plans to seize Gaza City and forcibly displace hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to concentration zones, despite international condemnation from the United Nations and states.

The plan reportedly involves forcing around one million residents southwards before surrounding the city and launching incursions into residential areas, followed by an expansion into refugee camps in central Gaza.

However, earlier Wednesday, the military said its chief of staff, Eyal Zamir, had signed off on the “main framework” for the operational plan during a meeting with top commanders, Shin Bet representatives and senior officers.

Speaking to some of Gaza City residents, Ahmed Dawood, a resident of Tel al-Hawa, told Quds News Network that people in the area have been hearing repeatedly the Israeli tanks moving and approaching.

“Heavy Israeli bombardment, drones constantly hovering, tanks shelling, and homes being blown up in the Zeitoun neighborhood — this is what our nights have become,” he said.

Marah Abu Shaban, a resident of the Sheikh Redwan neighborhood, said that Israel’s occupation plans for Gaza City have begun in recent days, citing the intense and continuous fire belts heard in the Zeitoun neighborhood over the past days.

“Two days ago, I saw more than 10 F-16 jets returning to the east of Gaza after heavily attacking the neighborhood. We heard the sounds and felt the destruction.”

Mohammed Haniya, a journalist from Gaza, reported, “Israeli tanks are now advancing in the Zeitoun neighborhood, south of Gaza City. This comes after days of intense air and artillery strikes targeting the Zeitoun and Sabra areas. We warned you—the ground invasion of Gaza began days ago, even as the occupation tries to divert attention.”

Already displaced Palestinians are pleading for global intervention: “Where are we supposed to go?”

Residents told Quds News Network that Israeli forces appeared to be in the preparatory stage of the expanded invasion, hitting multiple neighbourhoods overnight.

“Explosions [were] clearly heard from the eastern part of Gaza City, particularly near the Zeitoun neighbourhood and surrounding areas as far as the Sabra neighbourhood,” Entisar Abu Sada said.

Israeli Forces Intensify Bombardment of Gaza City Neighborhoods Amid Occupation Plans

Gaza City has been under heavy Israeli bombardment since Thursday night, with several civilians reported to be killed and widespread destruction of homes, amid plans to occupy the densely populated city.

Israeli forces have bombed the Zeitoun neighbourhood of Gaza City, killing at least two Palestinians, according to a source at al-Ahli Hospital.

In the same neighbourhood, the forces destroyed five buildings in 15 minutes on Friday morning. Local sources confirmed ongoing artillery shelling and demolition in the southern area of Al-Zeitoun neighborhood.

In al-Remal neighborhood, the beating heart of Gaza City, two civilians were killed in an Israeli attack targeting a tent sheltering displaced people.

“The explosions are almost non-stop in eastern Gaza City areas, mainly Zeitoun and Sabra. The occupation is erasing homes there, as we hear the bombing sounds,” said Ahmed Dawood, a resident of Tel al-Hawwa.

Israeli forces have carried out a days-long intensive assault on Zeitoun, one of Gaza City’s largest neighbourhoods, destroying more than 300 homes in the past days, according to reports citing Gaza’s Civil Defence.

The neighbourhood has faced continuous bombardment and demolitions since Tuesday.

Civil Defence officials said entire families were killed when their homes were blown up without warning using high-explosive bombs that also levelled surrounding buildings.

They added that rescue crews have been blocked from reaching the wounded or recovering bodies, worsening the humanitarian situation.

Mahmoud Basal, spokesperson for Gaza’s Civil Defence, stated on Wednesday:

“A catastrophic reality is unfolding in Gaza City. The city is under intense and relentless Israeli bombardment. High-rise buildings are being targeted, even though civilians remain inside.”

Israel’s security cabinet last week approved plans to seize Gaza City and forcibly displace hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to concentration zones, despite international condemnation from the United Nations and states.

The plan reportedly involves forcing around one million residents southwards before surrounding the city and launching incursions into residential areas, followed by an expansion into refugee camps in central Gaza.

However, earlier Wednesday, the military said its chief of staff, Eyal Zamir, had signed off on the “main framework” for the operational plan during a meeting with top commanders, Shin Bet representatives and senior officers.

Dawood told Quds News Network that people in the area have been hearing repeatedly the Israeli tanks moving and approaching.

“Heavy Israeli bombardment, drones constantly hovering, tanks shelling, and homes being blown up in the Zeitoun neighborhood — this is what our nights have become,” he said.

Marah Abu Shaban, a resident of the Sheikh Redwan neighborhood, said that Israel’s occupation plans for Gaza City have begun in recent days, citing the intense and continuous fire belts heard in the Zeitoun neighborhood over the past days.

“Two days ago, I saw more than 10 F-16 jets returning to the east of Gaza after heavily attacking the neighborhood. We heard the sounds and felt the destruction.”

Mohammed Haniya, a journalist from Gaza, reported, “Israeli tanks are now advancing in the Zeitoun neighborhood, south of Gaza City. This comes after days of intense air and artillery strikes targeting the Zeitoun and Sabra areas. We warned you—the ground invasion of Gaza began days ago, even as the occupation tries to divert attention.”

Already displaced Palestinians are pleading for global intervention: “Where are we supposed to go?”

Gaza City residents told Quds News Network that Israeli forces appeared to be in the preparatory stage of the expanded invasion, hitting multiple neighbourhoods overnight.

“Explosions [were] clearly heard from the eastern part of Gaza City, particularly near the Zeitoun neighbourhood and surrounding areas as far as the Sabra neighbourhood,” Entisar Abu Sada said.

15 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

Six years after the loss of its autonomy, Kashmir faces a new assault — 25 books banned

By Rama Sundari

On August 5, 2019, a wound was carved into Kashmir’s history that refuses to heal. In a move carried out without the consent of its people, the region was stripped of its autonomy and statehood -rights enshrined for decades in the Indian Constitution. Since that day, Kashmir has become an open-air prison. Freedoms have been dismantled one by one. Journalists are muzzled, news is blacked out, human rights defenders are jailed, and every independent rights organisation in the valley has been shut down. What passes for democracy are hollow elections -staged performances meant to pacify public anger while masking the suffocation of an entire people.

Six years later, on that same date, grief returned in a different form. This time, the weapon was not soldiers or barbed wire, but ink and paper -a ban on 25 books about Kashmir. Setting aside the truth that banning books is an assault on democracy itself, the question remains: why, specifically, are books on Kashmir being targeted now?

The answer is blunt and undeniable: they want to bury Kashmir’s truth. By crafting false narratives to overwrite its complex and painful history, they strip away every trace of sympathy from the mainland’s conscience if any leftover exists. The horrors before and after August 5, 2019, are to be not only forgotten but justified. It is a calculated attempt to begin anew on a blank page where the past is forbidden to exist.

Since 2021, authentic news from the valley has all but disappeared. With the flow of information choked, the people of Kashmir -and those who care deeply about it -have turned to books as their last refuge. In their pages, they find voices long silenced, truths that cannot be aired on censored television or printed in tightly controlled newspapers. These histories bring Kashmir back into the light, allowing readers to trace its past to understand its troubled present. And it is precisely this illumination that makes such books dangerous to those determined to erase the region’s rich and complex history.

As the state tightens its grip on the internet -criminalising even the mildest social media posts and unleashing organised troll mobs to crush dissent -many young people are walking away from these toxic platforms. They reclaim their time for more meaningful pursuits, turning to writing as one of the few refuges left where truth can still breathe. But now, the government turns its gaze toward writers and their words. It dares to ban books, branding them as enemies of the state -easy to criminalise, convenient to punish. In this war on ideas, the written page becomes a battleground, and every sentence a potential act of defiance.

What the banned books reveal

Every title on the banned list is more than a book -it is a record of truths the authorities would rather bury. They lay bare the centuries-long ordeal of a people crushed under successive rulers since the 16th century. They expose the justice denied to Kashmiris after 1947, unravel the political manoeuvres that birthed Article 370, and explain why the region was left to languish as a disputed territory. Page by page, they document how, in the decades following independence, political freedoms and social rights were dismantled in deliberate, calculated steps.

These books are not merely histories; they are indictments -and that is precisely why they have been silenced. In the shadow of the guns that guard Kashmir, these books open a door to a world of silenced pain -telling stories of youth and women scarred by visible wounds and the deep, invisible traumas that still haunt them. They speak of young men who left home and never returned, their fates sealed in unmarked graves scattered across the valley. They describe the chilling stillness of thoughts held hostage at gunpoint, where even an idea can be a crime. And they paint, with unflinching detail, how the abrogation of Kashmir’s autonomy caged entire people in an open-air prison, with the mountains as silent witnesses.

The voices they tried to erase

One such work Kashmir in Conflict: India, Pakistan and the Unending War, British writer Victoria Schofield traces the region’s complex history -from rule under various powers, to the partition of its territory after independence, to the political manoeuvres surrounding its accession to India. She examines the conditions that led to Kashmir’s special status and offers thoughtful proposals for peace.

This book is vital, carrying truths we can no longer afford to ignore. It unpacks the geopolitics surrounding the Kashmir dispute, examining the long-promised plebiscite and the nature in which it was envisioned by the United Nations -one that would be fair, just, and acceptable to the people of Kashmir.  The solution proposed in the book to resolve the dispute is likely to provoke the ire of those in power.

Prominent poet and writer Ather Zia’s Resisting Disappearance: Military Occupation and Women’s Activism in Kashmir does not offer any political solution to Kashmir. It is instead a powerful documentation of the relentless struggle of Kashmiri women fighting for their husbands and sons who vanished in the air. The book revisits the turbulent 1990s, a period that cemented the grim reality of how Kashmiris came to be treated as “killable bodies.” Drawing on real experiences and collective memories, it presents a deeply human understanding of Kashmir’s suffering. This work chronicles the tireless efforts of the Association of Parents of Disappeared Persons (APDP), capturing both their unyielding activism and their undeterred quest for justice.

On the other hand, Colonizing Kashmir: State-Building under Indian Occupation by Hafsa Kanjwal examines how the centrality of Kashmir in the Indian imagination was carefully manufactured through tourism, cinema, and state propaganda. It shows how the pro-India Prime Minister Bakshi Ghulam Mohammad’s vision of “development” in the post-Independence period became a curse for Kashmiris, masking dispossession and control beneath the language of progress. Armed with irrefutable evidence, the book charts the slow, deliberate transformation of Kashmir into a colony.

Renowned journalist and editor of Kashmir Times, Anuradha Bhasin, in her book A Dismantled State: The Untold Story of Kashmir After Article 370, pieces together the harrowing sequence of events and arrests that unfolded before and after August 5, 2019. She takes the reader into the heart of that suffocating period, when phone lines went dead, the internet vanished, and an entire population was cut off from the outside world -left to endure its darkest hours in enforced silence.

None of these works are fiction -and that is precisely why they are feared. Built on meticulous research, every claim is supported by official records, historical documents, and newspaper archives. In many, the bibliography is longer than the main text. A.G. Noorani’s The Kashmir Dispute – 1947–2012 is a case in point: apart from a brief preface, it is a compilation of letters, treaty documents, and meeting records that lay bare political realities. These books are not opinion pieces; they are evidence files -and that makes them impossible to dismiss.

The Zuban books published Do You Remember Kunan Poshpora? stands as a testament to the courage of women from the twin villages of Kunan and Poshpora, who survived mass rape by military personnels on the fateful night of February 23, 1991. It chronicles their decades-long battle for justice, reignited by the nationwide protests after the 2012 Nirbhaya rape case. Here, memory becomes a weapon -a shield against erasure, a refusal to forget, and a demand for accountability.

The right to read, the right to truth

Every book contains both facts and interpretations. Truth, misconception, and conclusions drawn from pain all depend on the reader’s knowledge, attitude, and perspective. The reader must decide what resonates as truth. For example, Rahul Pandita’s Our Moon Has Blood Clots movingly tells of the suffering endured by Kashmiri Pandits when they were forced to flee. These are undeniable wounds and worth knowing. Yet emotion sometimes veils other truths -such as the violence and trauma faced by Kashmiri Muslims after the Pandits’ displacement. To truly understand any region or period -books from all perspectives must be available. The determination of truth must remain with the reader.

Why this moment demands defiance

What the Indian government has done goes far beyond censorship—it is an assault on democracy itself. By banning books, it drags history into darkness and shows contempt for the wisdom and dignity of its readers. Such acts promote selective narratives that favour the government’s actions, laced with distortions, designed to inflame emotions and serve political ends. They manufacture a hollow patriotism that works like a sedative -dulling reason and numbing critical thought. The clearest example is propaganda films like The Kashmir Files. As the state parades such films, granting them tax exemptions and free screenings as if they were unquestionable truths -it tramples underfoot the books that contain verifiable history.

This is not a policy to debate -it is an outrage to resist. To believe it will stop here is to ignore history. We have already seen that when an undemocratic act takes root in one place, it soon spreads across the nation. Any writing that critically examines government actions will be targeted, just as the bans have already begun -starting with printed newspapers, extending to digital media, and even silencing YouTube screenings.

Banning books is not merely censorship; it is the demolition of history, the silencing of political thought, the erasure of public memory. And of all the weapons a state can wield against its people, this is the most insidious -for when the printed word is killed, the mind is next. Those who will not let books live will not hesitate to come for our dreams. In the struggle to keep books alive, we safeguard the very breath of our freedom.

Rama Sundari is a political commentator

14 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

India: Hate Speech Fueled Modi’s Election Campaign

By Human Rights Watch

  • Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s 2024 electoral campaign frequently used hate speech against Muslims and other minorities, inciting discrimination, hostility, and violence.
  • Inflammatory speeches, amid a decade of attacks and discrimination against minorities under the Modi administration, have normalized abuses against Muslims, Christians, and others.
  • The new Modi government needs to reverse its discriminatory policies, act on violence against minorities, and ensure justice for those affected.


(New York) – Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s 2024 electoral campaign frequently used hate speech against Muslims and other minorities, Human Rights Watch said today. The leadership of Modi’s Hindu majoritarian Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) repeatedly made statements inciting discrimination, hostility, and violence against marginalized groups during his campaign to win his third consecutive term of office, which began on June 9.

Several BJP state governments have demolished Muslims’ homes, businesses, and places of worship without due process and carried out other unlawful practices, which have continued since the election. These demolitions are often carried out as apparent collective punishment against the Muslim community for communal clashes or dissent, and BJP officials have dubbed them “bulldozer justice.” Violence against religious minorities has also continued, with at least 28 reported attacks across the country, resulting in the deaths of 12 Muslim men and a Christian woman.

“Indian Prime Minister Modi and BJP leaders made blatantly false claims in their campaign speeches against Muslims and other minority groups,” said Elaine Pearson, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “These inflammatory speeches, amid a decade of attacks and discrimination against minorities under the Modi administration, have further normalized abuses against Muslims, Christians, and others.”

Human Rights Watch analyzed all 173 campaign speeches by Modi after the election code of conduct took effect on March 16. The code forbids appealing to “communal feelings for securing votes.” In at least 110 speeches, Modi made Islamophobic remarks apparently intended to undermine the political opposition, which he said only promoted Muslim rights, and to foster fear among the majority Hindu community through disinformation. 

Modi has rejected allegations of anti-Muslim bias, pointing to India’s democratic, secular, and diversity standards. In interviews with journalists, he said of his party and its affiliated groups: “We are not against Muslims. That is not our domain.” When asked about anti-Muslim speeches during the campaign, he responded: “The day I start talking about Hindu-Muslim [in politics], I will be unfit for public life. I will not do Hindu-Muslim. That is my resolve.”

However, during the campaign, Modi regularly raised fears among Hindus through false claims that their faith, their places of worship, their wealth, their land, and the safety of girls and women in their community would be under threat from Muslims if the opposition parties came to power. 

He repeatedly described Muslims as “infiltrators” and claimed Muslims had “more children” than other communities, raising the specter that Hindus—about 80 percent of the population—will become a minority in India. 

In a speech on May 14 in Koderma, Jharkhand, Modi said that “the idols of our gods are being destroyed” and that “these infiltrators [Muslims] have threatened the security of our sisters and daughters.” 

In a May 17 speech in Barabanki, Uttar Pradesh, he made false claims that the political opposition would harm the newly opened Ram Temple, controversially built atop a razed historical mosque at Ayodhya. He said that if the opposition alliance came to power, “they will again send Ram Lalla [the Hindu deity Lord Ram] to the tent and they will run a bulldozer over the temple.” 

On May 7, in a speech in Dhar, Madhya Pradesh, he falsely said that the opposition Congress Party “intends to give priority to Muslims even in sports. So, Congress will decide who will make the Indian cricket team on the basis of religion.” 

Since Modi’s BJP government first took office in 2014, its discriminatory policies and anti-Muslim speeches by BJP leaders have incited Hindu nationalist violence. The authorities have failed to take adequate action against those responsible, fostering a culture of impunity that has fueled further abuses. At the same time, the authorities have often acted against victims of the violence and sought to persecute critics of the government through politically motivated prosecutions.

India is a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which prohibits “advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence.” Government officials and others who effectively wield governmental authority have a duty not to engage in speech advocating discrimination, hostility, or violence toward any individual or social group, Human Rights Watch said. Those in a position of governmental authority should speak out to dissuade others from engaging in discriminatory conduct.

The Modi government’s actions have violated India’s obligations under international human rights law that prohibit discrimination based on race, ethnicity, or religion and require the government to ensure equal protection of the law to everyone. The government is also obligated to protect religious and other minority populations and to fully and fairly prosecute those responsible for discrimination and violence against them, Human Rights Watch said.

“The Indian government’s claims of plurality and being the ‘mother of democracy’ ring hollow in the face of its abusive anti-minority actions,” Pearson said. “The new Modi government needs to reverse its discriminatory policies, act on violence against minorities, and ensure justice for those affected.”

BJP Hate Speech and the Election Commission’s Failure to Address It

Prime Minister Modi repeatedly claimed the opposition political parties intended to “wipe out Hindu faith from the country.” In a May 2 speech in Junagadh, Gujarat, he said: 

Congress [Party] is not contesting these elections for democracy, but it’s fighting these elections against Lord Ram. … I want to ask you, if Lord Ram loses, who wins? … It was similar thinking that led the Mughals to destroy the Ram temple 500 years ago and that led them to raze our Somnath temple.

He said in a campaign speech on May 10, in Mahbubnagar, Telangana: “Congress wants to make Hindus second-class citizens in their own country. Is this why they are calling for vote jihad?” 

Modi falsely claimed that the opposition parties planned to take away benefits guaranteed by the constitution to historically marginalized communities such as Dalits, Adivasis, and other groups, and give them instead to Muslims. He also asserted without basis that if the Congress Party came to power, it would take away the wealth and assets of other communities and redistribute them among Muslims. In a May 7 speech in Dhar, Madhya Pradesh, he said, “If Congress has its way, it would say that the first right to live in India belongs to its vote bank [Muslims]. … Congress will give quota even in government contracts on the basis of religion.”

Modi often implied that Muslims endangered the safety of girls and women in the country and claimed that the interests of Congress and opposition parties were aligned with Pakistan and “terrorists.” 

On May 5, in Dhaurahra, Uttar Pradesh, Modi said the opposition parties constrained the country’s investigative agencies and did not allow them to take action against terrorism: “After all, who are they doing it all for? There’s only one answer: for their vote bank [Muslims] to appease them.” On May 14, in Koderma, Jharkhand, a state governed by an opposition party, he said: 

It has become difficult to follow our faith in Jharkhand today. The idols of our gods are being destroyed. Infiltrators with a jihadi mindset are ganging up and attacking, but the Jharkhand government is looking away and is supporting them from afar. These infiltrators have threatened the security of our sisters and daughters. 

On May 28, in Dumka, Jharkhand, he stated: 

In many areas today, the Adivasi [Indigenous] population is rapidly declining while the number of infiltrators is increasing. Are the infiltrators not occupying Adivasi lands? Have our Adivasi daughters not been targeted by infiltrators? Our daughters’ safety is threatened, is it not? Their lives are in danger, they are being murdered, an Adivasi daughter is burned alive, another Adivasi daughter’s voice is taken away. Who are these people targeting Adivasi daughters?

Several other BJP leaders, including Home Minister Amit Shah, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Adityanath, Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma, and the former minister for information and broadcasting, Anurag Thakur, made speeches pitting Hindus against Muslims, fueling hatred and insecurity among the Hindu population.

The BJP also published animated videos vilifying Muslims and spreading disinformation during the campaign. On April 30, the BJP’s official account on Instagram posted a video that reportedly received 1.6 million views before it was taken down. The video claimed that the Congress Party was empowering people from the community that infiltrated India and robbed it of its riches: “Congress Party’s manifesto is nothing but the [Pakistani] Muslim League’s ideology in disguise. If you are a non-Muslim, Congress will snatch your wealth and distribute it to Muslims. Narendra Modi knows of this evil plan. Only he has the strength to stop it.” 

On May 4, the BJP’s official account in Karnataka state posted another anti-Muslim animated video that was also taken down after many users complained that it violated the platform’s hate speech policy. After receiving numerous complaints about the video, on May 7, the Election Commission finally wrote to X, formerly Twitter, where the video was also posted, asking them to take the video down.

After Modi’s speech on April 21 in Banswara, Rajasthan, thousands of voters wrote to the Election Commission and asked it to censure the prime minister for violating the code of conduct by “instigating and aggravating hatred in the Hindus against Muslims.” Ordinary voters and several opposition politicians also submitted written complaints about speeches that Modi and other top BJP leaders had made.

However, the Election Commission failed to take adequate action to respond to these violations, Human Rights Watch said. Despite finding that Modi and others had violated the guidelines, the commission only wrote to the office of the BJP president, without naming the prime minister, and asked that the BJP and its “star campaigners” refrain from making speeches along religious or communal lines. These directions did not deter Modi, who continued to make speeches inciting hate throughout the campaign period. 

The Election Commission defended allegations of bias, saying: “We deliberately decided—this is such a huge nation—that the top two people in both the parties [BJP and Congress] we did not touch. Both party presidents we touched equally.” The Election Commission also sent nearly identical letters to the office of the Congress Party president.

Government Authorities Targeting Muslims Since the Elections

Uttar Pradesh BJP Chief Minister Adityanath, in a campaign speech on May 30 in Himachal Pradesh, made false claims that the opposition Congress party, inspired by the 17th century Mughal emperor Aurangzeb, wanted to impose Sharia, or Islamic law, in the country, and warned that those who follow Aurangzeb’s path will be “buried by bulldozers.” 

On June 15, Madhya Pradesh authorities demolished without due process 11 Muslim houses in the Adivasi-dominated Mandla district, saying they had found beef in their refrigerators, as well as animal hides and skeletal remains of cattle. While the authorities justified the demolitions saying the houses had been illegally built on government land, news reports indicated that 16 other houses in the same neighborhood, which authorities acknowledged were also illegal but where no rumored beef was recovered, remained standing. “We demolished the homes where beef was found and left the others alone for now. … We were taking action against cattle smugglers,” a police official told the Indian Express.

On June 25, protests erupted in Mangolpuri in northwest Delhi after authorities demolished portions of a mosque, claiming it was illegal. The demolition came just five days after authorities razed another historic mosque, Jannatul Firdaus, in Delhi’s Bawana area. The mosque’s caretakers alleged that the authorities demolished it without any prior notice or warning.

In July, BJP governments in Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand states issued directives requiring all food sellers along the route of an annual Hindu pilgrimage to display the names and identities of their owners and employees. The state governments claimed it was to ensure the devotees could make an “informed choice” regarding the food they eat during the pilgrimage keeping in mind their “religious sentiments.”

However, on July 22, the Supreme Court ordered an interim stay on the decision, saying that while it is permissible for authorities to ensure that the pilgrims are served “vegetarian food conforming to their preferences,” compelling owners to display “names and address, also of their staff, can hardly achieve [the] intended objective.” The court added that if the directive is permitted to be enforced, “it will infringe upon the secular character of the Republic of India.”

Recent Attacks Against Religious and Other Minorities

Attacks by Hindu mobs and others against Muslims and other religious minorities have continued since the election campaign period.

On June 7, attackers killed three Muslim men—Saddam Qureshi, 23; Chand Miya Khan, 23; and Guddu Khan, 35—who were transporting cattle in Raipur district, Chhattisgarh state. Family members allege that Hindu vigilantes claiming to be a “cow protection” group killed the men and then threw them off a bridge. Police charges stated that men in three cars chased the Muslim men’s truck for 33 miles and hurled spikes and stones until they forced the truck to stop at a bridge by damaging one of its tires. The three Muslims, terrified, jumped off the bridge and died. 

Local Hindu men in Uttar Pradesh’s Aligarh district on June 18 allegedly beat to death Mohammed Farid, a 35-year-old Muslim man. Police said the Hindu attackers suspected Farid of attempted theft at a Hindu trader’s house. After the police arrested six men for murder, a BJP lawmaker joined local Hindu community members to defend the accused, demanding their release and pressing the police not to take action against others named in the case. Eleven days after the killing, the police filed a case against the deceased, his brother and five others on charges of dacoity (banditry) and sexually assaulting a woman.

On June 22, a local Hindu mob in Chikhodra village in Gujarat allegedly beat to death Salman Vohra, 30, while he attended a cricket match. Local activists alleged that the village chief, the son of the local BJP lawmaker, and his cousin were involved in the killing. The activists have requested that the case be transferred to another jurisdiction to prevent political interference. 

During the Muslim festival of Eid al-Adha in June, Hindu mobs harassed and attacked Muslims, including on suspicions of slaughtering cattle. On June 15, a mob attacked people inside a madrassa, an Islamic school, in Medak, Telangana, alleging that they had slaughtered animals during the Eid celebrations. 

On June 16, members of a “cow protection” group allegedly barged into a Muslim home in Khordha town in Odisha and seized all the family’s meat and their refrigerator, suspecting that they were storing beef. On June 18, in Faridabad, Haryana, vigilantes reportedly attacked a Muslim butcher shop owner and two Hindu men who were there to buy chicken.

On June 19, a Hindu mob in Pakri village in Uttar Pradesh attacked a motor rickshaw driver for carrying meat, saying a particular road could not be used to transport meat. On the same day, a mob attacked a Muslim-owned shop in front of the police in Himachal Pradesh state, after the owner allegedly shared a picture of a buffalo sacrifice on his WhatsApp status. 

During this period, Hindu men were implicated in attacks on Christians, Dalits, and Sikhs in several parts of the country. 

A Decade of BJP Hindu Nationalist Hate Speech

There has been a surge in anti-Muslim hate speech in India since the Modi administration first took office in 2014. 

During the 2014 national election campaign, Modi repeatedly called for the protection of cows, raising the specter of a “pink revolution” by the previous government that he claimed had endangered cows and other cattle to export meat. After coming to power, several BJP leaders made statements that spurred a violent vigilante campaign against beef consumption and those deemed linked to it. 

This led to self-appointed “cow protection” groups springing up across the country, many claiming to be affiliated with militant Hindu groups with ties to the BJP. Between May 2015 and December 2018, at least 44 people—36 of them Muslims—were killed across 12 states. Over that same period, about 280 people were injured in more than 100 incidents across 20 states. The attacks have continued, with several more killed since then.

Following widespread peaceful protests across the country against the government’s discriminatory Citizenship Amendment Act in December 2019, some BJP leaders derided the protesters, or more dangerously called them anti-national and pro-Pakistan. Others led a chant to “shoot the traitors,” inciting violence. Government supporters twice showed up at protest sites with guns to use against protesters. 

On January 30, 2020, a 17-year-old with a gun first threatened protesters outside Jamia Millia Islamia university in Delhi, and then opened fire in the presence of police, injuring a student. Two days later, a man fired two shots in the air near a protest site at Delhi’s Shaheen Bagh.

Since 2014, the BJP has denounced what it has called “love jihad,” a baseless theory claiming that Muslim men lure Hindu women into marriages to convert them to Islam. This has led several states to pass anti-conversion laws, which are used against Muslim men who marry Hindu women. Hindu nationalist groups have beaten Muslim men in interfaith relationships, harassed them, and filed cases under these laws against them.

Leaders from the BJP and affiliated Hindu nationalist groups have made statements that led to numerous mob attacks on churches in the last decade. In many cases, pastors have been beaten, prevented from holding religious meetings, and accused under anti-conversion laws, and churches have been vandalized.

After hundreds of thousands of farmers of various faiths began protesting against the government’s new farm laws in November 2020, senior BJP leaders, their supporters on social media, and pro-government media began blaming the Sikhs. They accused Sikhs of having a “Khalistani” agenda, a reference to a Sikh separatist insurgency in Punjab in the 1980s and 1990s. On February 8, 2021, Modi spoke in parliament, describing people participating in various peaceful protests as “parasites.” 

Punjab’s opposition politicians said that anti-Sikh statements by BJP leaders led to a June 10 attack by two men on a Sikh man, whom they called Khalistani, in Haryana’s Kaithal district. “This is the direct consequence of the politics of hate and polarization of various groups that has come to afflict the country over the past decade,” Punjab’s former deputy chief minister posted on X.

Since 2017, an anti-Rohingya campaign by Hindu nationalist groups who claim that Rohingya Muslim refugees are “terrorists” has incited vigilante-style violence, including arson attacks on the homes of Rohingya in Jammu and Delhi. In 2017, the Indian government called Rohingya refugees a “threat to national security.” 

The BJP minister of state for home affairs said: “As far as we are concerned, they are all illegal immigrants. They have no basis to live here. Anybody who is an illegal migrant will be deported.” In 2018, following a fire in a Rohingya settlement in Delhi that burned at least 50 homes, a leader from the BJP youth wing applauded the action on Twitter, saying: “Well done by our heroes … Yes we burnt the houses of Rohingya terrorists.”

Following the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020, Indian authorities contributed to a surge in anti-Muslim hate speech and violence. After authorities announced that they found a large number of coronavirus cases among Muslims who had attended a mass religious congregation in Delhi, some BJP leaders called the meeting a “Talibani crime” and “CoronaTerrorism,” and some mainstream media used the term “CoronaJihad,” with the hashtag going viral on social media. 

Soon, social media and WhatsApp groups were flooded by calls for social and economic boycotts of Muslims. There were numerous physical attacks on Muslims, including volunteers distributing relief material, amid falsehoods accusing them of spreading the virus deliberately.

14 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

Pakistan: How to Win Friends and Sabotage BRICS

By Prof. Junaid S. Ahmad

When the nation’s top general boards a flight to Washington not once, but twice within eight weeks, etiquette has clearly evolved into performance art. Picture Field Marshal Asim Munir—Pakistan’s newly minted five-star wonder, wearing a rank so rare it gathers dust in the history books—striding into Florida and D.C. with the easy grace of a monarch visiting his patron. The honeymoon? It’s not merely blooming; it’s a choreographed waltz, complete with matching smiles and carefully chosen photo backdrops.

This is not the casual diplomacy of “we should catch up sometime.” This is courtship, wrapped in starched fabric, stitched with nuclear thread.

Act I: Dinner, Diplomacy, and a Nobel Nomination

The first act unfolded in the famed Cabinet Room of the White House on a hot June afternoon. The U.S. President—yes, *that* one—shares a private lunch with Munir, the first such tête-à-tête in fifteen years. It had all the trappings of a diplomatic breakthrough, until the Field Marshal casually nominated his host for the Nobel Peace Prize. In the annals of foreign policy theatre, this was a rare flourish—equal parts flattery, opportunism, and political fan fiction.

This wasn’t just a power lunch; it was a scene straight out of a buddy-comedy script: “One serves salad, the other serves strategic compliance.” Everyone leaves the room convinced they are indispensable to the other’s future.

And then, barely six weeks later, Munir was back on a plane to the U.S.—not for a holiday or a conference, but for the next act in a drama that was starting to look like a touring production. This time, the backdrop was Tampa, home to CENTCOM headquarters, where he attended the retirement of one commander and the installation of another. Handshakes were exchanged with the earnestness of a man auditioning for “Most Reliable Ally,” while the Pakistani diaspora was treated to a sales pitch: invest in Pakistan, return to your roots, believe in the motherland.

From the outside, it looked like diplomacy. From the inside, it felt like déjà vu—repeated lines, the same stage, just a change of set dressing.

Act II: Nuclear Blackmail in the Sunshine State

But Tampa wasn’t where the fireworks happened. That was reserved for Florida’s softer shores, where Munir delivered what might be the most theatrical line of his career: “If we’re going down, we’ll take half the world with us.” Not whispered in a strategy session, not jotted in a private memo—said loudly, in public, on U.S. soil.

For anyone unsure, he made the point twice. Turning to India’s dams on the Indus, he promised their destruction with “ten missiles,” adding with unshakable confidence, “We have no shortage of missiles, Alhamdulillah.” In that moment, religious invocation met nuclear threat, a hybrid genre few had dared to attempt.

And then came the analogy that will follow him like a catchy but unfortunate jingle: India, he said, is a Ferrari speeding down a highway; Pakistan is a gravel-laden dump truck. The Ferrari might be sleeker, but if the dump truck collides, the Ferrari is finished. Somewhere in the crowd, a speechwriter surely high-fived himself. Somewhere else, a diplomat buried their face in their hands.

For Indian officials, this was more than rhetoric—it was a grotesque performance of irresponsibility. For Washington, it was theatre: a nuclear monologue delivered on borrowed stages, meant as much for the domestic audience back home as for any foreign listener.

Act III: Washington’s Quiet Checklist

Of course, the theatre is only the front stage. Behind the curtain, Washington’s script for Islamabad is less about applause and more about assignments.

First, Munir must play the role of fraternal defender of Iran in public, while keeping Balochistan primed for covert operations should Tehran become the next battlefield. In this drama, “brotherhood” is a costume; the real script is written in the shadows.

Second, he is to serve as the pliant foil to India’s increasingly independent streak. A brief border skirmish earlier this year earned Pakistan unusual praise from Washington—not because of any dazzling military maneuver, but because India has been testing Washington’s patience. From buying Russian oil without a hint of shame to cultivating relationships that make U.S. officials squirm, New Delhi has made clear it won’t be anyone’s obedient junior partner. Munir’s Pakistan, on the other hand, can be relied upon to play its part on cue.

Third, the relationship with China is to be kept on a short leash. Roads, ports, and railways under the China–Pakistan Economic Corridor are permissible; anything resembling strategic intimacy is not. And if the occasional attack in Balochistan derails a few projects? That’s just “geopolitical weather.”

Fourth, the crown jewel of the to-do list: undermine BRICS. The bloc—fast becoming a credible counterweight to Western economic dominance—is a thorn in Washington’s side. Pakistan’s mission, should it choose to accept it (and it has), is to be the polite saboteur: attend summits, offer handshakes, and plant seeds of suspicion between member states. The goal is as old as empire itself—divide, dominate, extract.

In this role, Munir is not just a Field Marshal; he is a geopolitical utility player, capable of being deployed against multiple targets without appearing to lead the attack.

Act IV: The Mirage of Sovereignty

Beneath the ceremonial glow, Pakistan’s military establishment operates as a state within a state—complete with its own business empire. Banks, factories, real estate developments: all part of a self-sustaining ecosystem known to critics as “Milbus.” This parallel economy ensures the military’s autonomy from civilian oversight, making it easier to align with external agendas without the inconvenience of parliamentary debate or public accountability.

When the military’s financial health depends more on its own enterprises than on the state budget, sovereignty becomes flexible. A foreign agenda can be accommodated if it doesn’t disturb the military’s internal balance sheet. And in Munir’s case, the Washington visits are not about asserting Pakistan’s independence—they’re about securing a place in a foreign-designed order, while preserving the domestic status quo.

The public may hear speeches about partnership and mutual respect. But the real currency in this relationship is obedience, dressed in the language of cooperation.

Act V: The Honeymoon’s True Price

Every honeymoon has a bill waiting at the end. In this one, Pakistan gets the optics of importance: a seat at the White House table, flattering remarks from U.S. officials, promises of military cooperation, and the warm embrace of America’s most influential lobbies.

In exchange, Washington gets a reliable middleman in South Asia: a nuclear-armed country willing to apply pressure on Iran, needle India, limit China’s reach, and play spoiler to BRICS. The fact that this arrangement is cloaked in the symbols of national pride—uniforms, medals, diplomatic banquets—only makes it easier to sell at home.

The problem is that honeymoons don’t last. The garland of roses begins to chafe, the music fades, and the partner once flattered finds themselves more bound than embraced. What today is presented as partnership may tomorrow be remembered as the moment sovereignty was traded for prestige.

Curtain Call: The Satrap’s Smile

Field Marshal Asim Munir is not the first Pakistani general to play the role of satrap, and he won’t be the last. But the speed and enthusiasm with which he has embraced it—the two visits in rapid succession, the nuclear grandstanding on foreign soil, the apparent eagerness to carry out Washington’s regional errands—mark him as a particularly willing participant in the arrangement.

Pakistan remains a country of staggering potential: the fifth most populous nation, rich in resources, positioned at the crossroads of Asia, and armed with a formidable nuclear deterrent. And yet, in the current script, it plays a role written elsewhere, its lines approved before they are spoken.

The satrap’s smile is wide, the epaulettes shine under the spotlight, and the applause is warm. But somewhere beyond the ballroom, the music changes. The strings grow taut. And when the tune shifts from waltz to march, the Field Marshal may discover that the honeymoon was never truly about love—it was always about leverage.

Prof. Junaid S. Ahmad teaches Law, Religion, and Global Politics and is the Director of the Center for the Study of Islam and Decolonization (CSID), Islamabad, Pakistan.

14 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org

You Can’t Stop the Wars If You Don’t Stop the Violence

By David Andersson

It is paradoxical that many advocate for ending wars without acknowledging the root issue of violence. If now is not the time to finally address violence, when will it be? We must name and challenge all its forms—physical, religious, economic, political, psychological, cultural, sexual, and others—because violence in any form is the primary barrier to peace.

Asking for peace without addressing violence is like a homeless person asking for money on the street; it doesn’t get very far. Peace cannot be achieved by ignoring the systemic and pervasive forces that sustain violence. Without addressing the underlying violence, peace remains an empty and unattainable goal.

Violence resolves nothing; it only perpetuates conflict. Diplomatic efforts will falter unless they directly address the role of violence. How can we expect those who profit from or perpetuate violence to be the ones to build peace? We must ask the difficult questions: Who benefits from the promotion of violence? How large is the market for it? Has democracy itself become subject to its sway? Why is honest discussion of violence so rare? In truth, nearly every aspect of human life—directly or indirectly—intersects with violence.

There are many examples of rapid transformation when the roots of violence are addressed. Look at Medellín, Colombia—the country’s second-largest city, nestled in the Aburrá Valley of the Andes. Known as the “City of Eternal Spring” for its year-round climate, Medellín was once infamous for its violence. In just 20 years, it has transformed into a vibrant, innovative city. Its cultural attractions and welcoming atmosphere stand as a testament to the power of change when violence is confronted. Medellín’s transformation wasn’t accidental—it was a strategic, inclusive campaign that combined infrastructure, culture, social policy, and innovation to navigate complex issues around social equity, memory, and safety.

In Mogadishu, Somalia, the effects of years of civil war and militant control began to dissipate after Al-Shabaab militants withdrew in 2011. The city embarked on significant reconstruction, with international collaboration—including with Turkey and the Somali diaspora—to rebuild infrastructure, revitalize public spaces, and boost economic activities. These efforts have contributed to a more stable and safer environment for its residents.

In Jos, Plateau State, Nigeria, recurrent communal violence since 2001 led to the launch of the Jos Forum Inter-communal Dialogue Process in 2013. Spanning 16 months and bringing together diverse communities, this dialogue culminated in the “Declaration of Commitment to Peace,” emphasizing tolerance, respect, and nonviolent conflict resolution. The result has been a more peaceful coexistence among Jos’s varied communities.

These examples show that peace is possible when violence is directly confronted, not ignored. Violent individuals or systems will never deliver peace—they are the obstacle, not the answer. The only path forward is to accept, collectively and without compromise, that violence does not work. Until we reach that understanding, peace will remain out of reach.
First published on 

Pressenza and translated into 

13 August 2025

Source: countercurrents.org